NP Rank:
Anatomy of a Tribal Revolt
This account is a fascinating look inside the culture of tribal society
as it has existed for probably centuries. It describes how their tribal
leaders are trusted above anyone else.
More Iraqis have lined up
with the coalition troops and the government to fight the enemy. The
successes in security have begun from the "bottom-up", rather than from the
national level down. The "surge" against the extremism belongs to the
Iraqis, in their own time, on their own terms. It's like a ladder, to
build on each success, to improve the lives of their community.To understand what follows, you need to realize that Iraqi tribes are
not somehow separate, out in the desert, or remote: rather, they are
powerful interest groups that permeate Iraqi society. More than 85% of
Iraqis claim some form of tribal affiliation; tribal identity is a
parallel, informal but powerful sphere of influence in the community.
Iraqi tribal leaders represent a competing power center, and the tribes
themselves are a parallel hierarchy that overlaps with formal
government structures and political allegiances. Most Iraqis wear their
tribal selves beside other strands of identity (religious, ethnic,
regional, socio-economic) that interact in complex ways, rendering
meaningless the facile division into Sunni, Shi’a and Kurdish groups
that distant observers sometimes perceive. The reality of Iraqi
national character is much more complex than that, and tribal identity
plays an extremely important part in it, even for urbanized Iraqis.
Thus the tribal revolt is not some remote riot on a reservation: it’s a
major social movement that could significantly influence most Iraqis
where they live.[Read full article]
News Tools
September 3, 2007 at 07:31 am by merrie, 234 views, 4 comments






Add a comment
Comments (4)
at 07:50 on September 3rd, 2007
merrie, good stuff. It gives us a different perspective on the situation. One comment: are the first two paragraphs your original commentary? If so, you can post them outside the highlighted text. If you need any help with highlighting, feel free to contact me or any of the editors.
I notice the article's author uses the term "not some remote riot on a reservation," which is US-centric, I think. Also, the article to me seems to say that most Iraqi tribes are related and share a common culture. However, in the U.S., separate tribes are just that--separate. Fascinating stuff to compare.
at 08:24 on September 3rd, 2007
PEP, Hey there, yes the first paragraph is my commentary. I haven't figured out how to "nest" the main body
of the content and also, I will attempt to format a video sometime when I find one I think is worthwhile.
I noted the phrase regarding the reservation, but I think his typing got ahead of his brain.
By the way, Larry Craig should fight that disorderly conduct case.
at 08:32 on September 3rd, 2007
Hi Merrie, see if this helps with highlighting.
You might consider uploading your article first, then adding video later. That way, you don't get hung up on the video.
I think Craig's case is going to be quite controversial.
at 09:34 on September 3rd, 2007
Merrie, could you please email me? There's a button for that on my member page. I have some tips for you.