Anger over DRM-free iTunes tracks

by ricknight | June 2, 2007 at 06:37 pm
731 views | 10 Recommendations | 3 comments

Photos

The launch of music tracks free of digital locks on iTunes has been overshadowed by the discovery that they contain data about who bought them.

Some fear this data could be used to identify the owner of the tracks if they turn up on file-sharing sites.

The tracks from record company EMI cost more and are of a better quality than standard iTunes songs.

Apple has yet to comment on what it plans to do with the information embedded in the music files.

Update June 3rd 

Apple is under fire. DRM-free tracks bought through iTunes would seem to retain information about the person who bought them - even after the files have been converted. Several blogs have picked up on the issue, which emerged after Apple announced the iTunes Plus service yesterday.

This is the same personal information that is already found embedded in any DRM-protected song bought from the store. Of course, the addition of personal information would appear to be designed so the tracks don't start appearing on file sharing networks. Tracks have the full name and email address of the purchaser embedded within.

However, the Electronic Frontier Foundation has further investigated the information found. It's discovered that, while there is no personal information residue left if you convert the files, there is a disparity in the file size. So there is potential for personal information to be carried over.

 

Advertisement
recommend This comment thread is now closed
Jordan Yerman
Jordan Yerman
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 04:24 on June 3rd, 2007

Just as online life is redefining "space" and "community", so too is it redefining "ownership". For such smart folks, Jobs and his ilk don't seem to comprehend that they are simply driving consumers toward file-sharing, as the inroads into consumer privacy make the prospect of buying these products unpalatable. I just buy the CD, unless it's a SOny CD, as I'm no fan of the rootkit...

0
nk

Don't understand the problem. You bought a licence to listen to the song on any device. No more, no less.You are not allowed to give it away legally anyways. What's the problem?

0
Jordan Yerman

Good question. Whilst marketed as "DRM-free" (and priced at a premium as well), I would argue that the tracking of user data attached to a dowloaded track is indeed a form of digital rights management. If I buy a CD, the songs are not tracked; the disk itself is my property. Despite the marketing used by Apple, this is not the case with iTunes purchases. Example: my own iPod was recently lost (don't even get me started), and, had I not converted (most of)my iTunes songs into MP3's and backed them up as data on DVDs, they'd have been gone... The downside of downloaded music is that there is no hard-copy, which is a problem should something happen to your hard drive or listening device: if I were to have lost my CD player, I'd have only lost one CD at the most! Hopefully it wouldn't have been my Very Best of Nina Simone record; I couldn't handle that.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

NowPublic on Facebook

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Jordan Yerman
First Flagged at 4:24 AM, Jun 3, 2007 by Jordan Yerman
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in Tech & Biz

 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from