Canada: Day pledges Taser probe

by Barry Artiste | November 16, 2007 at 08:36 am | 599 views | 7 comments

Opinion

Barry Artiste, Now Public Contributor

One would hope this Probe does not turn into a all Political parties showboating for the Media and Vote Grabbing turning this into a Political Points Three Ring Circus.

Tasers were introduced during the Federal Liberals Reign, so when accusing fingers are being pointed, one must remember three of those fingers will be pointing back at the Liberal Opposition.

The victims family should be allowed some dignity during this tragic time. Let's hope the media do not congregate around the victims Mother, looking for a Barbara Walters style interview. Walters interviews famous for goading interviewees to cry on camera.

As for the RCMP members, justice certainly will prevail, and Tasers may be banned from our Police Forces and rules for alternative use of force may be regulated.

My Final Thought
Canada will have a tough road ahead in repairing the damage seen around the world, as the world sees the actions of a few in this video, thereby unfairly judging all RCMP members and Canadian Immigration officers and bureaucrats, as uncaring towards Immigrants to this country.


Dramatic video of a distraught Polish immigrant dying after being shot by an RCMP stun gun has ignited a fiery national debate on the use of Tasers.

The 10-minute clip was captured on video by another passenger at Vancouver airport and beamed to the world Wednesday. MPs and human rights groups are calling on the government to explore tighter regulations for the potentially deadly use of force.

Piotr Ogrodzinski, Poland's ambassador to Canada, said he was shocked and heartbroken by the video.

"My impression, based on what I have seen, is that the RCMP took action that was not necessary," he told Sun Media in an interview. "He was agitated, frustrated and desperate for help."

Ogrodzinski said the footage was to air on television stations across Poland last night, and he expected widespread shock and outrage. He called for a moratorium on Tasers pending reviews.

Robert Dziekanski, 41, had arrived in Canada to start a new life with his mother last month. After several hours of delays in processing at the airport, he began to yell and throw objects. The video shows him writhing on the ground after four Mounties tried to subdue him with a Taser. He died moments later.

Yesterday, Public Safety Minister Stockwell Day said the RCMP will review the use of Tasers, and the incident will be scrutinized by a coroner's inquest and the Commission for Public Complaints Against the RCMP.

"Many of us who watched that video footage can certainly understand the shock and grief, especially experienced by the mother of the deceased individual. Our hearts go out to her," he said. "We want to make sure that public safety is maintained and that answers are found on this particular issue."

The American company that manufactures the weapon stands by the safety of its product, insisting it saves thousands of lives.

Taser International spokesman Steve Tuttle said the incident appears to follow the pattern of many in-custody deaths, which are wrongly blamed on Tasers, and said medical and law enforcement experts have concluded the technology is effective and safe.

"Cardiac arrest caused by electrical current is immediate. This video indicates that the subject was continuing to fight well after the Taser application," he said. "This continuing struggle could not be possible if the subject died as a result of the electrical current causing cardiac arrest. His continuing struggle is proof that the Taser device was not the cause of his death."

Sign In or Join to post comments Comments (7)

jordan
good stuff:

Considering the RCMP originally tried to bury the video, I have a tough time mustering faith in a "full investigation". Canadians will forget about this, most likely sooner rather than later, but I think the damage to the RCMP's reputation abroad will last longer.

jordan

Oh, and I don't think that the talk shows will able to stop themselves from going after the grieving mother. Ratings... can't... resist!

Barry Artiste

True Jordan, Canadians may forget over time, that's unfortunate, but the damage is done, for some they won't soon forget.

rooboy

 The police claim Tasers are non lethal , and a better option than a gun . It'd be interesting to know how many deaths from police


gunshots there have been in Canada since the time tasers started being used , and how many before that time  , over a similar period .


It seems that if the police are told tasers are preferable to guns , and non lethal , they'll use them much more freely ,


and with much less thought than they'd use their guns . The damage to Canada's reputation , and the RCMP's , is terrible


after this Vancouver airport shooting .  Hopefully the enquiry will look into the claims of the manufacturers , and the instructions


the police are given , and what , ( what the Military call ) the police rules of engagement are .


I doubt the blame lies 100% with the cops on the beat . 


 

jordan

Indeed, manufacturers sold police departments on the non-lethality of Tazers, and police departments in turn sold the public on it. Turns out the label is clearly misleading!

nk

This guy died from the police officer kneeling on his neck, not from the taser shot IMO.

Kaitlin
good stuff:

Barry Artiste, thanks for your work here. The taser debate is certainly one that will continue to rage in the media. The fact remains that sending electric currents through the body is an unpredictable (at best) way to deal with them. Every person is different, and every body handles stimuli differently depending on circumstance. Saying that tasers are safe is a complete generalization. I hope this drives further investigations (outside the RCMP, of course, since, as Jordan said, internal investigations are unlikely to uncover anything).

Good stuff. 

November 16, 2007 at 08:36 am by Barry Artiste, 599 views, 7 comments

is reporting from

closeSign in to NowPublic