NP Rank:
Robert Pickton: Serial Killer Found Guilty
Verdicts:
Guilty of all six counts of 2nd-degree murders of
Sereena Abotsway, Mona Wilson, Georgina Papin, Brenda Wolfe, Marnie
Frey,and Andrea Joesbury. He will receive concurrent life sentences.
The only question remaining is the possibility of parole, though the number
of convictions may make Pickton's parole, in effect, impossible.
These verdicts seal Pickton's place in history as Canada's most prolific serial killer.
The crown wanted first-degree murder convictions, but instead received
2nd-degree. They're probably disappointed, and the jury apparently
didn't think that the evidence presented warranted a first-degree
verdict.
COMMENTARY: In effect, six 2nd-degree convicitons is the
same as if the crown gotten its wish: parole is astronomically
unlikely.
(updating tags to reflect the names of the women Pickton has been convicted of murdering)
Update:
The possibility remains of a trial for the remaining twenty counts of
murder. Family members will no doubt want such a trial.
Update: Orato's Trisha Baptie,
a former sex worker who has also been covering this trial for
NowPublic, is giving a great interview on CBC right now. She's really
emotional about the outcome, and keeping it really articulate and
clear. CBC is also interviewing Pauline Vankoll,
whom Pickton once tried to pick up. The interviewer seems somehow
surprised that Pickton didn't appear to be as malicious as he was.
(Should come as no surprise that he appeared normal, or he'd not have
gotten away with these crimes for so long)
Vankoll is saying that encounters with men such as Pickton are only some of the risks in the life of a sex worker.
Update: The talking heads are going over possible appeal scenarios, and CBC cut to coverage of a ceremony being held by the victims: candles lit for the six victims for whom Pickton was sentenced, and for the women in the other 20 counts.
[This is very moving: these are women whom society-at-large didn't give a sh*t about until this guy was in the news for killing them; had he not been caught, we'd never even know these women's names]
They're trying to find batteries for the portable music player with which to play a song commemorating the victims; I hear laughter and tears at the same time. Wait, they sorted it out. The music is playing as these people stand in a circle holding candles, in tears, surrounded by a phalanx of TV cameras and photographers.
Reading out the names of the murdered women: Sereena Abotsway, Georgina Papin, Mona Wilson, Brenda Wolfe, Andrea Joesbury, Marnie Frey, Jacqueline McDonell, Dianne Rock, Heather Bottomley, Jennifer Furminger, Patricia Johnson, Helen Hallmark, Tanya Holyk, Heather Chinnock, Sherry Irving, Inga Hall, Sarah de Vries, Cynthia Feliks, Tiffany Drew, Angela Jardine, Diana Melnick, Debra Jones, Wendy Crawford, Kerry Koski, Andrea Borhaven, Cara Ellis, and one woman as yet unidentified. [Spellchecked via Wikipedia]
EARLIER: The jury is expected to deliver its verdict in the trial of Robert William Pickton, accused of murdering twenty-six women and hiding their remains on his property outside of Vancouver. We'll be updating this article live. Though the range of evidence against Pickton has been ponderous, the defense insists that the evidence presented does not link up to positively convict. This is a very, very emotional case, tapping into human nature, how we see our neighbors, how women are treated, the Downtown East Side residents' relationship to the rest of the city, and even British Columbia's image of itself. The vicitms' families will settle for nothing less than a conviction of first-degree murder, though any number of verdicts are possible.
Update: the media is assembling outside the courtroom; the reading fo the verdict will be delayed until everyone's ready, evidently. (I'm at work, watching this on CBC and Global)
Additional coverage from Barry Artiste and mbaumgartner.
NowPublic on Facebook
Crowd Power
-
wleng
San Bernardino, California, United States -
Jordan Yerman
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada -
Orato
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada -
Randor
Coquitlam North, British Columbia, Canada














Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (12)
at 11:25 on December 9th, 2007
jordan, thanks for getting this story out so quickly. It will now show up on the home page for four hours. If new developments justify it, I'll renew this flag for another cycle.
at 11:45 on December 9th, 2007
jordan,Good stuff, though I was typing live in New West as the verdict was being read and hit the Post button :)) Though you state he was found not guilty puzzles me as they state guilty 2nd degree murder. Oops just noticed you changed the verdict, kudos
at 12:12 on December 9th, 2007
I've been updating this in live-edit mode, and the guy was reading the verdicts off of his Blackberry, and kept getting confused... when he said "not guilty", I thought, "WTF?!", but then the real verdicts became evident. As you say, the case goes way back, and there will be a lot of very angry family members over the lesser verdict. Still, I do not predict parole as a possibility.
at 11:49 on December 9th, 2007
Barry, we would like to know people's thoughts on this verdict and of course the possibilities of a second trial, my bet is that there won't be...but there has to be something to address the needs of the families of all the named/unnamed victims...
I've spoken with the family members, and they're asking for a public inquiry into not only the trial but the investigation of Pickton...there's a lot of anger and frustration on the part of the families...
at 11:52 on December 9th, 2007
jordan, hard to say "good" about any of this. But important coverage. and hopefully some relief for the families of the six victims even though there is bound to be some confusion over the 2nd degree verdict.
at 11:55 on December 9th, 2007
Let's not forget this investigation was researched as far back as 1971 on missing women, 48 DTES women if my memory serves me.
As for Pickton, regardless if it is 1st degree or 2nd degree Robbie Boy aint going nowhere, life imprisonment , appeal all he wants, he will be doing it behind bars, where he should have been for years. I was there until a few minutes ago as CBC were broadcasting live and I live minutes away from the courthouse hence my rapid story and laptop.
at 12:37 on December 9th, 2007
jordan, good stuff. But may I suggest that you put an Update notice on top of the text? At one point I found it confusing when the headline and opening text disagreed.
at 13:05 on December 9th, 2007
I'm editing this article live... readers can expect a bit of turbulence as I keep it up-to-date! Thanks for the flag, PEP. It's an important verdict, though the story ain't over yet...
at 13:10 on December 9th, 2007
Thanks for this breaking news. I still wonder who else was involved.
at 13:36 on December 9th, 2007
Indeed, so do I. Perhaps, with Pickton off the streets, the prosecution can focus on finding any accomplices. With all those outstanding counts, the crown has plenty of room to move.
at 11:45 on December 10th, 2007
A sex worker is making a story out of what? She should stay in the shadows. She is a prostitute! Gross! Why do prosititutes exist? Because the law doesn't arrest enough. It should be illegal that way these woman won't get killed. I say make each count of prostitution a felony.
at 17:14 on December 10th, 2007
Prostitution is illegal in Canada, it is the Nancy Boy Justice system in Canada which should be illegal