In June 2008, Stacey Doss of Rancho Santa Margarita, CA got a phone call that changed her path in life. The public relations consultant, was recently divorced and after years of unsuccessful fertility treatments, still longing for a baby, to raise in the same loving family she had grown up in. She decided adoption was her best choice to fulfill the dream of motherhood and a short time later she was matched with a young woman from Ohio. Doss said when they talked on the phone they just "clicked". On June 13, 2008, the call came from the bio - mother, after she had given birth a couple weeks early - Doss caught the next flight to Dayton, to meet her new baby. A precious little girl, with big brown eyes and soft curly hair; she named her Vanessa and after filing a petition of adoption on July 1, 2008, Doss brought her baby home to Southern CA.
The open adoption was facilitated by a private agency and the paperwork was done, including a legal documents, signed by the birth mother, Andrea Conley, stating the baby's biological father was not in the picture, the pregnancy was the result of a one night stand. Unknown to Doss - the biological father, Benjamin Mills, Jr of Dayton, Ohio and Conley, in fact, had a long tumultuous history - that included to two daughters, who are in the custody of their paternal grandmother and Mills' year long prison sentence resulting from his conviction on domestic violence charges
. A repeat offender, the charges became a third degree felony in Ohio, due to two previous convictions for domestic violence and a child endangerment charge on his record.In January 2005, Mills was arrested when Conley placed a call to law enforcement after Mills showed up at her apartment and beat her, strangled her and dragged her around the apartment by the hair, while holding their young daughter in his arms. In the police report it was noted that there were bloody clumps of Conley's hair - pulled out from her scalp - scattered around the apartment, she had bruises on her face and throat.
Domestic violence is often nothing more than an issue of control - and men or women behind the abuse, will say outright, their partner deserves whatever they hand out because the abuser is in charge - the boss so to speak and GOD help whoever steps on the shadow of the boss. Is little Vanessa caught in a battle of wills, because her birth mother wanted a better life for her baby and the only way to achieve that life, is to keep Benjamin Mills, Jr. out of it?
What better way to continue the violence against the birth mom, than to make sure she doesn't get away with making this decision without Mills' permission. The child is nothing more than a pawn - collateral damage, in his battle to control Conley.When Mills discovered his former girlfriend had given birth, he showed up at the hospital, claimed the baby as his own and said that the adoption was done without his consent. DNA tests results arrived four months later and confirmed him to be Vanessa's biological father.
Since that time he has been waging a battle with Doss, through the courts of Montgomery County, Ohio and Orange County, CA to return baby Vanessa to him. Something that is not likely to happen, no matter where Vanessa is being raised. According to Montgomery County Social Services - Mills has four other children who are in the system - he does not have custody of any of them. Two with his ex- girlfriend, the birth mother of baby Vanessa and two with his former wife.
Because of the claims by Mills, Vanessa's adoption was never finalized, she has technically been a ward of the Montgomery County, Ohio Social Services since birth. Since 2008, they have allowed Vanessa to remain in the care of Stacey Doss, the only mother she has ever known, in the only home Vanessa has ever lived in.
Until last month, when a judge in Ohio ordered Vanessa's immediate return to Montgomery County - where she will be placed in foster care until the custody case is settled. Ohio social workers tell her that neither Mills' home nor the paternal grandmother's home is a place for Vanessa. Leaving the family devastated over the prospect of foster care being the only option for a little girl who has a good home, with a mother and family who loves her.
Doss has filed an emergency appeal to block the order, and her attorneys successfully argued that an emergency custody order still in place, is valid. On Friday July 2nd, Orange County Superior Court Judge Michael Naughton granted jurisdiction of the case to Montgomery County. Giving Doss until July 16 to return Vanessa to Ohio or appeal the decision. If denied on appeal,
two year old Vanessa will be picked up by social workers from CPS and taken back to Ohio, to live with strangers, in Foster Care. Two psychologists who are experts in reactive attachment disorder, spent time with Stacey and Vanessa,
then wrote reports on the devastating effects this kind of a separation would have on Vanessa, breaking her heart and spirit.
Regardless whose side anyone takes in this battle, a biological parent or an adoptive parent - the bottom line is and always should be what is the best interest of two year old, Vanessa Doss. It should not take a rocket scientist to figure out the damage that will be done to a two year old baby, when she is taken from her home, where she has been been raised in a family of loving, stable people who have this little one's best interest at heart and fear not only for her physical safety, but for her emotional health and the lifetime of problems that will be this baby's future - if she is placed in foster care or with an abusive parent.
While Benjamin Mills, Jr. has stuck to his claims that Vanessa is his daughter, therefore he has the legal right to raise her - we must wonder, why? Why is he fighting to take Vanessa out of a loving environment, when he has four other children, right there in Ohio, four children who he does not have custody of. His battle, by the way that is paid for by the state - with his appointed lawyers in CA and Legal Aid of Western Ohio.
Last year, Stacey Doss paid for Mills trip to CA, for him to visit Vanessa. A trip that was at least educational on her part, when she discovered Mills doesn't even want to be a parent to Vanessa,
but he sees the baby as his "property". And she said, Mills was more interested in sight seeing - than he was in seeing "his daughter", choosing to sit shot gun in the car, rather than sitting with Vanessa. What a disappointment he must have been. Is anyone in the judicial system listening? Even a little?
There is a hearing, in Ohio on July 29 to determine whether Mills behaved as the "presumed father" while Conley was pregnant. Doss may have a stronger case if it is determined Wells was not an active participant during that time.
Stacey Doss has been waging this tug of war - for two long years, she is drained; physically, emotionally and financially. And yet as any mother would, she is still pushing on and has vowed not to give up until this is settled and Vanessa is her legal daughter - for life.
Mills' FREE legal advice is now criticizing Doss for going public with her battle, "Mr. Mills trusts the court will continue to issue appropriate orders to protect his daughter,'' Gorman said. "Mr. Mills and Legal Aid of Western Ohio Inc. remain focused on the law and not on the publicity generated by Stacey Doss.''
Gorman said "Mills is doing everything he can within the legal system to regain custody."
Had Doss not put this out into the court of public opinion, Vanessa would have very likely ended up lost in foster care - never to be seen or heard of again. Any judge should have to think about this for all of a split second, to know the right thing to do for Vanessa. Doss and her supporters can only hope and pray he realizes this too. You can help, please send letters to the following courts, stating your support and asking for the courts to do the right thing for baby Vanessa ~ leave her with her mother, who has been there every day of this little one's life and who will continue to be there caring for her and loving her, for life.
Superior Court of California, County of Orange Lamoreaux Justice Center Dept. L66
341 The City Drive South
Orange, CA 92868-3205
(657) 622-6069 — Family Law General Information
Montgomery County Juvenile Court
380 W. Second St.
Dayton, OH 45422
(937) 225-4267 — Court Administration
Operation Vanessa: http://ink-la.com/helpvanessa/blog/
Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (15)
at 06:55 on July 10th, 2010
LC Mom, another heart wrenching story. And, wth is up with CindyR88?
Anyway, I saw this story on the news and I could almost feel the fear Stacey Doss is feeling. That is her baby and someone wants to take her out of her arms and put her in the arms of strangers. The bio father has no right to claim Vanessa as his own, I think just beating her bio mother should be enough to eliminate the paternal claim. This is insane. If he was a clueless man who wanted to be a father, not only to Vanessa but to her four half-siblings, than I might have some sympathy for him. His only reason for fighting is a control issue - you nailed that. I don't understand why the court is not considering the best interest of the child. It scares the crap out of me. That little girl does not know what is going on and to take her out of her true mothers home is cruel and unusual punishment, not only to Stacey but to Vanessa, for something they are not guilty of. I really hope the OH courts see that the so called father is not doing this in the best interest of the child.
We all know how a 2 year old clings to their mother. The seperation of Stacey and Vanessa would be tragic. I have images in my mind of Vanessa crying for her mommy, only to be taken away and given to some stranger. I know there are good foster parents out there who would take good care of her but she has someone already in her life who takes care of her just as well as any foster family could physically. Emotionally this little girl would never recover. I can't imagine the confusion Vanessa would feel, the betrayal, the hurt - not any fault of her mother. How do they expect this child to be normal if they take her from Stacey. Even if it is only during the trial, it would still destory the spirit of Vanessa.
Stacey, if you are reading this - I pray for strength for you. I know you will fight with everything you have. I am sending some of my strength and emotional support to you. You are doing the right thing. I hope to god the courts get this right.
at 13:23 on July 10th, 2010
BBB thank you so much! Once this was picked up by the news it spread like a wild fire, the truly frightening comment that I read on several sites, is that this is just another day in the life of Judge Michael Naughton; people claiming he has a problem with women and has gone so far as to scream at them and call them liars on the stand or make a judgement that goes against common sense without ever hearing their side, not allowing them to testify. On further search I have not yet found any legal rulings against the judge, in the State of California Commission on Judicial Performance - but I did find an attempt to have him recalled in 2007.
On the surface, I wouldn't have a problem with a judge choosing one state or the other to resolve this matter - two years is too long to be dragging this through the courts without any end in sight, but coming on the heels of Ohio Family Services demanding the baby be immediately returned so she can be placed in foster care! No, that makes no sense at all. IMOO, if there had been any indication Stacey was incompetent, that would be different, Vanessa has thrived in Doss' care. To snatch her away from her mother, is cruel and unnecessary. The threat to Vanessa's well being is very real and anyone in their right mind must be aware of the potential for harm. Acts such as this is at the crux of our need to over-hall the system put in place to serve children and their well being.
The case of abuse against the birth mother is available thru the Lexis-Nexis (I hope I spelled that correctly) web site. After testifying before the grand jury, she supposedly signed a document reneging her claims of abuse - then went underground, refusing to show up in court. He had been charged with a form of kidnapping, unlawful detainment I believe. After showing up at her apartment and beating the stuffing out of her, Mills made himself comfy and spent the night. During the fight, Andrea had made a phone call to a friend, asking for her to come pick her and her daughter up - this friend testified to listening to Andrea screaming at Mills to stop, several times before the line went dead. The court allowed this testimony and used the sworn statement from the Grand Jury to convict Wells of Domestic Violence, but the detainment charges were dropped.
I am calling this was a case of a woman too frightened and still under the emotional control of Mills, unable to stop herself from going back to him time and again, since Vanessa was conceived after Mill's was released from prison. The courts used the fact she and Mills had a child together - to make the "domestic" violence charges stick - verses run of the mill abuse of a stranger. Mills, through his attorney, denied paternity of the child!! This was cleared up by a paternity test. What a jerk! To deny his child, then turn around a couple years later and use the same test that helped convict him, one time to try to gain custody of another child. A child that he has no desire to raise, just to add to the birth mother's misery - when she made such a bold and valiant attempt to save this baby from the cycle of abuse.
Andrea's parents have come forward and said Andrea put Vanessa up for adoption for all the right reasons and they are backing Doss, 100%. While the birth mother has not returned any requests to make a statement, she posted the following on her MySpace page: “My world is in array... My heart goes out to the true victims of this awful ordeal and you are truly in my prayers, I want you to know that.”
at 13:03 on July 12th, 2010
My husbannd and I have been foster parents for 14yrs. with Greene Co. CSB (the county right next to Montgomery in Ohio.We also adopted a little boy nine yrs. ago.My heart breaks for you.We see what these kids go through even on weekly visits.We recently had a baby in our home for 7months and it was terrible to break the bond even after that short time so she could return to her Grandparents.Vanessa needs the stability and unconditional love you have given her.If her father really loved her he would let you keep her and maintain visits with her.I hope and pray a judge will do the right thing.Our prayers will be with you and YOUR daughter. Kelly and Gary Wallace
at 22:16 on July 12th, 2010
Gary and Kelly it would mean so much for you to write the to the court, this makes no sense to take a baby out of the only home she has ever had, with the only mother she has ever known to put her in foster care. It is wrong. If the judge is successful he should be recalled, no one in their right mind would do this to a baby or her mother.
Thank you for your in put.
at 05:50 on July 15th, 2010
Please, please, please get this message
at 06:58 on July 16th, 2010
I just pray to God, and I ask all of you to do the same, that this child not be pulled from her mommy and given to a violent stranger who donated his sperm years ago. California is her home and Stacey is her mommy. Please, God, don't let them take her away from Stacey? Please?
at 11:24 on July 18th, 2010
This child's personality is in a crucial form of development to the extent any harm done now may have ramifications for the rest of her life. This "father" is just committing a different form of abuse against "his"child".
My prayers go out to Stacey Doss and Vanessa, also to Judge Michael Naughton to use wisdom and see that this child has a family who will love and raise her. Leave those spots in the Foster Care system for a child who doesn't have alternatives.
Regardless of this judge's feelings towards the "he said she said thing" all he needs to do is look at Mill's previous record to see what is the right decision. It is obvious the right thing to do is make her adoption final with Stacey Doss. If he really feels this father deserves a chance, let Vanessa stay with Doss until he can prove he is "fit" the same as he would be required in foster care before having rights. Let him make child support payments, have structured visits, whatever......up to this point he has already proven himself unfit, make him prove he is capable before disrupting Vanessa's life. OK, one more prayer...God please allow Benjamin Mills, Jr. the guts to make a decision in the best interest of this child instead of his own. Amen
at 12:46 on July 18th, 2010
Well said, my friend. At this point I'm having trouble believing his attorney's will back his trying to do the right thing. They sound like they may have an agenda too.
But I also don't see this being something he would consider anyway. Reading the posts starting in June from people who claim to know both of the bio-parents. B-mom was at least trying to save her baby. Mills may not know the right thing if it bit him in his boy parts.
If you google this case - the comments from all around are just heartbreaking or heartwarming depending where they originate. Poor little Vanessa must feel the stress in her mommy - there is no way, no matter how hard she tries that this will not be oozing out of her pores.
The worst thing about all this is no matter the outcome, it will not effect the day to day life for Mills - although it could (and would) damage Vanessa for life. Mills won't be given custody - no matter what and Doss, has already promised to keep her birth family in little Vanessa's life.
at 12:10 on August 9th, 2010
Doss may say she plans to keep the birth family in Vanesa's life, but she has no idea who these people even are! I have met them - mind you only a few times, but Rena Jordan is a very kind woman who loves and wants to know her granddaughter, yet Doss refuses to allow VAnessa to come to Ohio to visit! Wow, she sure is convincing...I'm impressed.
at 19:10 on August 9th, 2010
Did you know Doss paid for the father to come to CA to see Vanessa - to work out visitation privately - only to find out the father wanted to see the sites not his daughter? Didn't even want to sit next to her in the car.
It is the father Doss is fighting for custody not Ms Jordan. I'd love to know what he would have done if he had to use his own funds to support this case as Doss has.
at 12:16 on August 9th, 2010
RE:"Leave those spots in the Foster Care system for a child who doesn't have alternatives. " You fail to see the point here, sweetheart! This child was never given up. Not legally anyway. Inter-family placement is the top priority for Child Protective Services when a bio-parent is deemed not suitable to rear the child him/herself - not foster care. Foster care is supposed to be a last resort - a last resort option which Doss managed to score for herself, over anbd above above the rights of her REAL family here in Ohio to raise Vanessa with her sisters when her dad couldn't do it himself.. It is the father's FAMILY I support, not the father himself.
at 19:02 on August 9th, 2010
Stacey was in the process of adopting Vanessa from an agency - it's not like she bumped into to the birth mother in a back alley and tried to take her out of the state illegally. Why should Stacey and Vanessa have to suffer because the birth mother felt she had to lie to save this baby from the abuses of her bio-father or maybe this time, there was a 1 nite stand in there too. We don't know. Should Vanessa have waited in Foster Care for 4 months til the DNA test came back? What if it proved she wasn't his - did he still want her anyway? I'm guessing no. If the grandmother wanted Vanessa so badly where was she prior to the birth and why has she not petitioned the courts?
I am glad to see you feel the grandmother is such a great person - then she should realize what a devastating effect it would have on Vanessa to suddenly up root her from the only family she has known. Is a 60 yr old plus grand mother who is already raising 2 other kids really the best person to raise a two year old? How many more babies will her son bring home and drop on her doorstep?
I have witness the effects, of tearing a 2 yr old from a home where she was loved - up close and in person - the baby was 2 almost 3 - she had a relationship with her (bipolar) mom, (antisocial) dad and sibs - a 10 year old with severe behavior problems and a 6 year old already dx bipolar and the doctor had warned she had all the makings of a serial killer at age 5; after she was suspended from kindergarden the first week - due to zero tolerance policy on hitting/kicking other children (3 random attacks in 4 days). I lost a 2 year old I dearly loved to the family she was sadly born into - no notice, no appeals.
At this time Vanessa has been ordered by the state of CA to remain in this jurisdiction - should Stacey take her out of the area she could lose custody.
at 12:42 on July 22nd, 2010
Hoorah! I saw the appeals court gave a temporary stay. Good gosh, that was a no brainer.
at 22:17 on August 19th, 2010
LCoast Mom, thank you so much for this story. It needs to be told, and you are one of Vanessa's guardian angels for telling it. Much love, S.
at 03:40 on August 20th, 2010
Stacey, thank you for that and many blessings to you and Vanessa. LCMom