The African vs. the African American

by Kwapi V | July 9, 2009 at 11:34 am
916 views | 96 Recommendations | 20 comments

Photos

African vs. African American | Photo 02

African vs. African American | Photo 02

see larger image

uploaded by Kwapi V

It's a tension Unspoken; a love-hate relationship that often pits the African experience against the African American experience. It often lurks undetected but like a Mamba slithering through the tall wispy blades of our black sub-conscious when provoked it strikes with an indiscriminately potent and unforgiving venom. Its a tension born out of misunderstanding; a tension rooted in misconceptions; and a tension fueled by a misguided interpretation of each others' values.

We often reduce each other to mere stereotypes and caricatures as we assign characteristics that are ill-conceived and uncomplimentary; stereotypes that are further reinforced by the media. The African at times may see the African American as nothing more than a sell-out, an "uncle Tom" or "Menace to Society" while the African American reduces the African to nothing more than those "Hakuna Matata", "Blood Diamond", dashiki-wearing stereotypes. I trust your intellect and so I need not explore or submit a plethora of examples that expound on what I am talking about primarily because I believe that if you're black then you're not blind to it and if you're anything else you can often see it play out with your own kind, the Mexican vs. the Mexican American; the Asian vs. the Asian American and so on.

You see, there is a tension that often forgets that we are a people who share a common legacy and although we were separated by a common injustice, it is this shared heritage we should celebrate. It's a legacy and heritage that predates Michael Jackson and Bob Marley, a history bigger than Martin Luther King Jr and Nelson Mandela, Miriam Makeba or Rosa Parks; a history with more talent than Kobe Bryant, Pele, Okocha or Brian Lara; a legacy and heritage more tragic than colonialism & slavery and yet more monumental and awe-inspiring than the Pyramids of Giza or the Great Zimbabwe.

Sincerely yours,
Kwapi
Copyright 2009
http://www.twitter.com/kwapiv

recommend This comment thread is now closed
1
Amy Judd

Good piece!

2
Mortal

     Well-written piece, man, but what I can't figure out is why nobody ever says anything about all them africans, both blacks and muslims, who put all the people into slavery in the first place.  everybody wants to blame the white man, and hate and all, but nobody tells the other side.  In fact, the muslims did more slavery on the blacks, and are still doin it, than the whites ever did.  For real!  Then, blacks in America get all conned into goin muslim, forsaking their christian heritage.  If God allowed blacks in Africa to sell out their own kind to enslave them, then maybe, as hurtful as it was, God had a plan in it all.  You know, like Joseph.  After all, if they hadn't come to America, they might all have died pagan, never knowing God or christianity.  If that's the case, maybe black America needs to look up and see what God has in store for them instead of being bitter or angry so much.

0
thank U

All i can say to U, as an African myself, and being on the receiving side of that bitterness that African Americans have towards us......., all i can say is thanks! " God does have a reason for everything" and plus I wasn't there when my fellow ancestral Africans were selling other africans, now african americans into slavery, so y in the hell should i, a college student 4rm Africa trying to focus on my education and life be blamed? Very immature..lmao..i had to laugh @ that one...anyways, u have some wise words!

1
DylanH

Interesting post

My Father is African, my mother is american

I wonder where that leaves me

0
My other me

That leave you in the middle of both worlds. I know this because my dad is african and my mother is american as well. So you are not alone

2
Karen Hatter

Asante sana, Kwapi.

2
Paschen

So, an African American has to be black?

What about 120 million White African? And those immigrants to the US that are not black and yet African?

Americans are American and may they be of European, Asian, African or Australian decent, they are American.  Europe would not want them back nor would Africa or Asia, they do no longer share the same cultures, languishes nor traditions.

The Native American may want to claim their land back as Israel did and drive out all the immigrants and they would end up like the Palestinian that no one really wants.

The miss conception of African American or rather Black American and Asian or European America or rather Caucasian and Mongolian-American is to make a world that never existed of sorts a fairy tale a la Disney.

The Irish suffered and so did the Chinese that where used and abused and many others.

The greatest Slave trade was in Roman time with European and North African Slaves. The difference is that the Roman went under and where overrun by their former slaves and colonies where as the Slaves in the Americas where freed by their captors leaving a void in their emancipation. 

The history of the Americas is still very young as well and has not yet seen major transition such as Europe and Asia did nor have the Americas know as ethnical war as Europe and Africa and Asia did over the past 6000 years that did wipe out entire groups religions or races with in less then a generation.

Africa is a continent like Europe and Asia and has a multitude of races, religion, ethnicity's and cultures.

Parts of Africa where colonized by the Persian, the Arabs, the Europeans and by African them self and other parts never new colonization or protectorates.

Some Black African Kingdoms where powerful entity such as the Bambara and the Housa and still are, they where also slave traders and breeders since the ancient Greek and Egyptian and still are in some areas today. Same for the Tuaregs that Captured and supplied slaves to the Roman as well as to the American and still hold slaves today of all races and origins.

It is not that simple nor is it as easy as Disney would like to portray it.

In percentage the Roman, and Egyptian counted in certain periods of their history of 80 percent of slaves in their empires population where as the Americas never had more then 15 percent of slaves in their population.

The French and Spanish sold their own people into slavery to the Arabs and Persian or the Tuaregs. It was one way to avoid decent.

To me American are American, regardless of their origins, races or religions just as much as a French is a French and an Algerian is an Algerian. 

I never heard a Libyan call him self African nor would a Sudanese call him self so either. Even those emigrants that came from the African continent to Europe in the past 60 years call them self Algerian, Nigerian Ethiopian... but never African nor Algerian French, they are either Algerian or French but not ever Algerian French. Once they become French Citizen or Italian or the other way around European becoming Egyptian or Libyan then that is it they are French or Italian... no longer Algerian.

Unless you are a cosmopolite and refuse all Nations and religions or Races as some demarcation and shows to be Human instead and forget about being a racist or a nationalist, since that is what it is all about after all, Nationalism and Racism. 

If I call my self Black or White I make certain I separate my self from the rest of Humanity and there for endorse racism. 

I never filled out those US forms asking for once race and just wrote in it "HUMAN". Every thing else would be racist. No matter the race.

8
Kwapi V

I understand parts of what you're saying although I don't necessarily agree. In some regard I think you mischaraterized what I was writing about and took off on a totally interesting but somewhat unnecessary tanget. I fully understand the complexities of what you're talking about but today my opinion piece was specifically about the Black experience. I did think of writing about the White African, the Arab African but I decided to save that for another debate and focus on a specific trigger. My opinion piece is about an on going debate withing the AFRICAN and AFRICAN American community from a Black context; often brought about by debates about Obama for example- is African or is he African American; is Africa because of his father or African American by experience - the question of whether or not he is BLACK enough. Its not a topic I've heard my WHITE South African or Arab African friends (who tend to identify themselves with the middle east) debate; but rather its a topic always debated in the African American centers at Washington State University, the University of Idaho and Eastern Washington University. Like I said your argument seems interesting but it really mischaracterized what my piece was about today.

If I could I would talk about everything and anything underneath the sun. If you look at my past opinion pieces for example, I will talk about Gay Relationships in one, then Gay Marraige the next then followed by Gay Adoption. My style of writing tries to be short and somewhat focused on one element or aspect versus trying to cover every topic in one sitting.

1
Paschen

Great comment Kwapi V, I did read your post though and did not try to stray on another pass, however by using the term African-American and associating it with a Race you automatically discriminate against all American of African origin that are not Black.

This is not an accusation nor an attack or personal, it is a point of view from a non American perspective. I dealt with the subject to great extend and read a vide variety of books about it and took part in many debates about the subject.

If I look at my own roots and Family I find people of all sorts Colour and all sorts of religion and Nations, even though I my self have Caucasian skin would I call my self white I would reject my Berber Ancestors, would I call my self African, I would reject my European ancestors and DNA there for, wish is not logical nor realistic or fair.

I am there for a Human born in Cameroon and holding 3 passports, could I get an international Passport, I would most certainly take it and forget about all this none sense of Nationalism. However, since that is not yet available, I collect Citizen ships in the mean time and maybe once I have enough Passports the UN will grand me my International passport. :)

If I look at my DNA and I did so for the sake of making a point earlier in a major political debate a decade ago. I have so many races with in my DNA that I could most likely call my self any thing I wanted from a genetic point of view. 

Making Race and Nation hood illogical, same would go for religion as well.

We are born into a certain context, of Nation, Race and religion wish we can not help or shows. However, we can shows what we become and what we are. 

I shows to be Humanoid and a mammal at best, I am neither White nor Black, European or African, Nor am I Christian, Muslim, Jew or Buddhist, For it would not be logical nor do I want to impose such burden on my own Children. 

Children, are amazing that way, if you look at them and observe them in a free setting, they do not see each others race, religion or Nationality, but they just have fun and get along rather well as long as no adult with some misconceptions messes them up.

Sorry if I side tracked here. Great post as always,  I do follow your posting for some time now, because those are interesting and good postings.

4
Pythiian1

Good article and thanks for sharing your perspectives. 

While most non-Asian would not or never notice, but I'd venture to write that there are  tensions that exist and continue to exist between Asian Americans and overseas Asians. To a great extent, it is a subject that most Asians are quite reluctant to discuss to non-Asians, even among college students. 

2
AFRIMERICAN

Late but not absent.

This post is an echoe of the MATRIX mind.

The so-called African-American is you, if you are a person born in Africa that has now decided to become a naturalized American.

The persons born in Africa that have come to America and taken on the moniker African-American for the most part either don't know they were used as pawns in United States racist agendas to further disenfranchise, and convulated the identity, and citizenship, and human rights of Afrimericans.

On the other hand, there are those Africans who have come to the United States with full knowledge of the lie resulting in what's described above, and have used it to further their own ends, while at the same time being willing co-conspirators in perpetuating the lies surrounding African-American nomenclature applied, falsely, to Afrimericans.

The average Afrimerican knows nothing about Africa, speaks no African language, knows very little to nothing about the geography, or tribal settlements. In short, the average Afrimerican knows nothing about Africa except what they see in the news, or read in a magazine, and in recent years those stories have focused on Aids and poverty in Africa, or the romanticized myths about Africa in a manner that sells the idea that Afrimericans born in the U.S. are just as much African as persons born in Africa which is the lie that has been imparted as truth thus creating a MATRIX Mind where the lie is accepted as truth.

The whole of this matter is extensive and filled with lies and myths and agendas, and the basic facts of law and nature are completely ignored.

Ironically the only people having this discussion are Blacks. The White Africans from Chad, Libya, Egypt, and other caucasic African nations remain silent because like Whites, not all, some, many, around the world, they get a big laugh from the fact that Afrimericans are misidentying themselves, and Africans that know their tribe, tribal language, tribal history, and tribal geography fuel a debate on points that are of little relation to them with the ironic exception of their desire to want to be part of, or just like the misinformed, uninformed Afrimerican that has accepted the White self appointed master, and their House Negroes lies.

2
batvette

Ironically the only people having this discussion are Blacks. The White Africans from Chad, Libya, Egypt, and other caucasic African nations remain silent because like Whites, not all, some, many, around the world, they get a big laugh from the fact that Afrimericans are misidentying themselves, and Africans that know their tribe, tribal language, tribal history, and tribal geography fuel a debate on points that are of little relation to them with the ironic exception of their desire to want to be part of, or just like the misinformed, uninformed Afrimerican that has accepted the White self appointed master, and their House Negroes lies.

I can't speak for anyone but myself, but I don't believe anyone is laughing at all. It's puzzled bewilderment that even though (except for parts of the deep south where blacks are still discriminated against as an institution-in the SF bay area where I began public school in 1967, rascism was not acceptable) the vast majority of us invite you to be our neighbors, work alongside us, date our daughters, hell just forget about the color of your skin and be fellow Americans-Discard your anger and realize that if you are rejected for employment, housing, it may not be for the color of your skin the person sees as you walk in, it is the chip on your shoulder they cannot look away from.  Too many people seem to be wrapped up in this fantasy best portrayed in an old Saturday Night Live vignette with Eddie Murphy called "white like me". You know, where he puts on makeup and disguises himself as Joe Peckerwood and watches as the black guy gets off the bus, and immediately the confetti flies, they start passing around money, the white chicks take their clothes off and perfoprm sexual favors....  he goes to job interviews, home loan applications, it's all a world of the good ole buddy club.

It was funny as hell but I'm not sure if Eddie or the writers were entirely being facetious, or maybe deep inside Eddie felt there might be truth to it.

Again, except for armpits in Misssissippi, Alabama, a handful of states down there and various pockets of hate elsewhere, we're not having a circle jerk with you as the pivot man. We're not having the discussion  because we're not as obsessed with this non issue as some of you are. Perhaps the reason you're focused on being "african" as opposed to american, is you find it impossible to have respect and pride for this nation for what was done to your ancestors 6, 7 or more generations ago, and the bigotry and racism which followed. So you seek to immerse yourself in the culture and history of Africa instead. This is understandable but stifles progression into your future and that of your children, and theirs.

Yet you seem to be a well educated and enlightened person by alluding to the fact that many fabricate a romantacized vision of the continent which as I understand it, facilitated the slavery industry themselves- and even today many African countries, governed by Africans, exploit their countrymen with horrific and inhuman practices which cannot be blamed on any "white devil" but on the cold evil that exists in the hearts of many men, their color is inconsequential.

I believe Will Smith, after spending an extended period of time on the continent when the Muhammed Ali story was filmed, expressed a candid yet controversial view that whatever the means of how his parents and theirs got here, he was eternally grateful for being born in America rather than in Africa. Maybe that's the debate more people should be having, not perpetuating an eternal victim card which, while real enough and of no fault of theirs for previous generations, becomes not so in most of America starting in the 60's and entirely of their own making as we try to forge ahead.

Oh, in parting, I might add we have all been lied to in many ways in America, and in civilizations past there were surely lies as well. Freedom is not as free as we think, the press does not seek to print the truth, when we go to war for democracy or capitalism, that's generally bullshyte too.

I guess it's a good thing when we get old enough that we've seen enough to realize that we're too tired and weak to tear it all down.

1
158

A very informative and interesting article

2
patgarcia

Great article!

1
tikun

Thanks Kwapi.

Great piece and very informative. I appreciate your candor and honesty.

2
Mayra

I trully understand what is being said here. I was born in Puerto Rico but at the age of two my mother moved us to the states. We lived with my aunt who was beyond determined to keep our culture alive in us. It wasn't till my cousins and I started school that we were allowed to speak english and then it was only when we were doing homework and studing for school. She made sure we could speak,write and read both languages but our Puerto Rican culture was the most important thing to learn and keep alive.  Yet when we would go back home to the island we were treated like out siders by our own people because we had embraced another culture. We were even given a new name "New York Ricans".  I see what you mean  because I've lived it.

1
batvette

I might be said that those you feel labelled you with a disrespectful or contemptuous monniker, (assumedly) for your transition to a different cultural path, did so simply out of petty jealousy of your brighter future. If that doesn't make sense because (in the case of blacks whose ancestors' "brighter future" was delayed by enduring generations of slavery, this is even more true) the future from your POV wasn't so bright, that might be a case of the grass always being greener....

I think everyone who "gets out of the hood" be that hood an American ghetto or another continent, gets treated with disrespect superficially by those left behind. You can feel sorry for yourself that you are no longer suffering with them, or "down" with them, or portray what was left behind in a romantacized way and wistfully think you would be happier if you were a  "real" African/Puerto Rican/etc. This generally requires the detached view including all the positives and none of the negatives of the obviously oppressed culture.

On that note, I wonder how many Haitian-Americans feel "dissed" by such a comment from a Haitian. Or Vietnamese, for that matter.

Thank you for the provocative thoughts about your cultural diversity.

0
Just never understood this!!!!!!!!

okay, this may not have to do with the whole article, my question is more on the part of the African Americans not getting along with the Africans. To be honest who cares to explain the dislike that most africans like myself get from African americans in the U.S. Not to sound racist, but we are alot more accepted by other races( ie. hispanics, caucasians, europeans etc..) than by those who we are supposed to have the same heritage with; "African"Americans. i wonder what I as a person, has personally done to an African American just because am African. One of my brothers, as I call them( an african american) was kind enough to tell me that africans are disliked for selling their own people, who are now african americans into slavery. Good, i agree thats hurtful, bad, horrible etc...BUT did I do that????????? I feel like its high time, people as whole realize that the past is there to help us know where we come from, inorder to know where we are going, not to make us live on/in the past! What does it matter if i come from a different continent, country, speak with an accent etc....these things does not qualify me to be treated differently aka.. badly..lol.

If u read this, I really am not following this article to the T, just wanted to say what was on my mind.., u can punish me 4 that..lmao.."No one is perfect"

0
sooziQ

Ouote from "Just never understood this!" 16:13, 7-13-09:

<<Not to sound racist, but we are alot more accepted by other races( ie. hispanics, caucasians, europeans etc..) than by those who we are supposed to have the same heritage with; "African"Americans. i wonder what I as a person, has personally done to an African American just because am African. One of my brothers, as I call them( an african american) was kind enough to tell me that africans are disliked for selling their own people, who are now african americans into slavery. Good, i agree thats hurtful, bad, horrible etc...BUT did I do that?????????>>

So now you know how INNOCENT whites feel.  Some in my family (Caucasion) came to the US as indentured servants during it's infancy.  That means non-paid "slaves" until their debt, whatever it might have been, was paid. Some were shipped here because of political dissent, or so their lands could be stolen in the "old country".  Others in my family came from a fishing culture in Wales...never having owned very much of anything, much less a SLAVE!  So WHY should I, as a Caucasian of mainly European descent, be required to bear the burden of wrongs never done by me or my ancestors?  If black African Americans won't forgive their very own race in Africa who sold them to Caucasians, why should that taint be passed along to another race?

But welcome to the USA, and especially to the southern USA where we've been the "whipping boys" for rascism in this country.  But you might be surprised where the REAL racisim is in the USA.  We have a saying down here in the south and it is simply this: "Yankees" (those not born in the historical southern US) many times love the African Americans as a group but HATE them as individuals, while Southern whites many times hate African Americans as a group but LOVE them as individuals. 

I've seen more racism, many times covert but no less real in the northern US states, than in my own southern state.  Ask any black American how hard it is to catch a cab after dark in New York city.

Racism, but lets' call it by a more proper name, bigotry, isn't confined to one race of humans, one nationality of humans, or indeed one group of humans within a race.  The lighter skinned Japanese have been historically prejudiced against the darker skin Japanese.  What is more, physical characteristics, such as skin color many times doesn't even figure into bigroty!  The Prussian Germans have historically considered their more bucolic Germans as inferior.  Heck, even the collective assessment of the people in my central region of our state seems to be that the eastern and western parts of my state are less sophisticated and less educated than we are!  That's a blanket bigotry which does injustice to the individual   It is human nature to be prejudiced.  It's how we learn to be civilized and respectful of our human kind as INDIVIDUALS, no matter their DNA we never seem to master.

0
batvette

An outstanding commentary, especially:

"Yankees" (those not born in the historical southern US) many times love the African Americans as a group but HATE them as individuals, while Southern whites many times hate African Americans as a group but LOVE them as individuals. 

And since I did single out several southern states for the recent past and current situation for blacks,  please accept my apology for the unfair generalization.

It is likely a very true situation in the south that while the world looks at the whites as institutionalizing racism, the individuals themselves are raised with very close friendships between the races that defy this stereotype.

(I live in California but spent 6 months in Tennessee in 1980 and loved it, so don't think I hate on the south)

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Anonymous
First Flagged at 11:55 AM, Jul 9, 2009 by Anonymous (not verified)
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (96)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from