by
urbano411 | October 10, 2007 at 08:39 pm
Who, what, where and when... The basic questions we ask of all things we are curious about. Citizen Journalism has always been a major part of the sharing of information and news. It is as old as curiosity itself! It's a part of nature to observe & gather information of an event or set of circumstances, internalize that information and share it with others. Stuck in traffic, the weather, an accident, gossip, the price of gas all information shared by each on of us on a daily basis with our friends, colleagues and families without any thought of how the information got from here to there.
We are in someways all casual reporters of what we observe and encounter.
This past Tuesday evening (Oct. 9th) the
Paley Center for Media in NYC hosted a discussion titled, 'Beyond the Anchor Desk: The Rise of Citizen Journalism' as part of its series, 'The Public Programs at The Paley Center'. The discussion focused on the Revolution of news gathering and distribution by citizen journalists armed with cell phones and video cameras. The Paley Center gathered a panel of distinguished traditional journalist that included, former CBS News President and Sr. Advisor of Marketspace LLC Andrew Heyward, Debra Galant founder and Editor in Chief of
Baristanet.com, Adam Glenn co-founder of
ireporter.com and Citizen Journalist Pioneer and
DCTV's co-founder Jon Alpert. Representing the new generation of journalist were
Current TV's, star producers and host, Max Lugavere and Jason Silva and representing Citizen Journalist was yours truly, Gus Rodriguez aka Urbano411. Moderating was Now Public's, Chairman of the Board and the Editorial Director of News21, Merrill Brown, who brilliantly kept the discussion focused and informative.
Citizen journalism is the act of everyday people turning unexpected moments & observations into news coverage. The panelist discussed how technology has changed the way information is passed around, giving the average tidbit of information a wider distribution then ever before. Suddenly we no longer have to wait very long to share what's going on. We have cell phones, PDAs, text mail, laptops, our phones can capture pictures and video. The once referred to 'Man on the Street', is now just as well equipped to deliver the news as the famous News van. Now we can observe things and report who, what where & when to a worldwide audience in just minutes. In some cases as the news is actually happening. Providing images, video, audio, text, interviews and opinions at a minimal, if any, cost of production.
Panelist shared video clips of their work, most notably was the work of documentary legend, Jon Alpert, who presented two compelling examples of ordinary people making extraordinary journalism in the heartland of America and the urban streets of Brooklyn, NY. Max and Jason's clip attacked the immigration debate in a very untraditional reporting style that included beachside interviews with South Beach sunbathers. This form of providing compelling information and content is affecting not only how we deliver news but also the quality of the news and information received by us. News is no longer neatly packaged and contained to the sound bites that provide a preferred view of the story. Instead now we find traditional news items are immediately followed and in some occasions proceeded by eyewitness reports and opinions. Examples of this have been seen in our news coverage of the Iraq war, politics, foreign affairs and almost every news item that now exist. Citizen Journalist bring to the publics attention news items and information that otherwise don't make it pass editorial meetings in traditional news rooms. The Jena 6, & the horrible situation in Burma, are perfect recent examples of the way news, that may have been glossed over, receives much needed attention.
All the panelist agreed that citizen journalism, however, is required to hold itself to the same rules expected of traditional journalism. Fairness and accuracy resulting from research, reliable sources, and fact checking are vitally important for all journalist. In closing, Merrill Brown expressed that this new model of reporting was here to stay and expected that it will play a big role in the future of journalism.
Freedom of press is no longer a concept that only pertains to our morning paper, the six o'clock news and the people that bring it to us. That freedom is now pertinent to all of us that share the news we encounter. The discussion encouraged anyone with a curiosity about a subject, that may witnesses a situation during the course of the day, or that may have a unique knowledge of a subject's who, what, where and when to grab a laptop or maybe their cell phone, and become a correspondent.
Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (13)
at 23:05 on October 10th, 2007
Great coverage urbano411.
I have a thought that maybe someone can address. I agree that citizen journalism should be held to the same expectations as traditional journalism. However, do we hold the same expecations when talking with friends, acquaintances, or complete strangers? When having a personal conversation with someone about a newsworthy topic, we don't demand thorough research and fact checking - instead we use our BS detectors when something seems awry (which ONLY works if we are familiar with the information being presented). However, when published online on a blog or a participatory news site like NowPublic, such expectations are demanded - is this simply due to the reach an article on NowPublic might have, whereas one-on-one conversations reach only one other person (although, arguably many more than one person - we are all familiar with rumours)?
Citizen journalism may be here to stay, but I fear both credibility and accuracy might be lost in the transition - especially since anonymous writers have nothing to lose when providing biased/false information, and there are few people with enough formal training in the veritable plethora of newsworthy information willing to dedicate time (which equals money to most) to the cause.
at 05:26 on October 11th, 2007
Great question ScienceDave. During the Q&A portion of the discussion there was a question ask by a member of the audience, "what is journalism?". I think that we can all agree that there are those who report news with self serving interest. But I am of the opinion that good journalism is considerate of Fair and Accurate reporting regardless of one's personal point of view. We have always encountered news and information that is colored with a leaning opinion, but I believe that the presence of Citizen journalist will help bring more transparency to news items and will help in many cases to give us a greater amount of information to help people sort out the truth. It was encouraging to see young vibrant minds with such genuine interest in journalism and I, being the optimist I am, feel that many future journalist will bring credibility and integrity to their reporting. But you are absolutely correct that credibility and accuracy are often lost in translation, this however is true of all journalism.
at 02:18 on October 11th, 2007
It was great to see you there, Urbano411.
at 05:33 on October 11th, 2007
Likewise Brian. It is great to know that NP is supported by people who are really excited about what they do and focused on how they can make NP better. My hats off to you, Michael, Merrill and all the people that make NP possible.
at 04:13 on October 11th, 2007
urbano411, Congratulations! Siempre Siembra!
at 05:37 on October 11th, 2007
Gracias Pat! De cada semilla un arbol; que lindo crece nuestro bosque...
at 08:08 on October 11th, 2007
urbano411, Good stuff.
at 09:21 on October 11th, 2007
urbano411,great stuff.
I think that honesty and accuracy are minimum requirements. The minute someone decides to say that they are acting as a citizen journalist in any way, they have stepped into an arena where higher standards are required.
Basically, what citizen journalism is about is the amplification of sources. Before, a source would tip a journalist to a potential story. Now, the source becomes the CJ--but the hard work of accuracy also comes with it.
I also suspect that most CJ's won't be willing to take on the often-deadly risks of professional journalists. So there will still be people acting as sources to the professionals simply because risking your life, and maybe that of your family's, for 45 seconds of video clip one day isn't worth it.
Bloggers, I think, also, in a perfect world, *should* also seek accuracy and fair play. However, on the whole, blogging is more about editorializing than reporting. And that's their niche. You can do whatever you want with a blog. Some gain transistory fame and some bucks by being controversial or provocative. Some build towards something else. It's whatever someone chooses.
at 12:36 on October 11th, 2007
You make a good point about the line that that distinguishes were accuracy and fair play become part of the job description. I agree that it takes a special commitment to go from Citizen Journalist to a professional journalist and suspect that many of us CJ's have a great respect for those who take great risk to bring us news. But deep down we would all love to get that ultimate 45 sec clip!
at 12:17 on October 11th, 2007
Good work.
at 12:24 on October 11th, 2007
A straight-up excellent post, with a stellar comment string as well. Thanks, urbano411
at 12:33 on October 11th, 2007
Good stuff, Urbano411.
at 13:06 on October 11th, 2007
I'm going to add my voice to this cacophony and say "Good Stuff."
I can't think of a user more suited to representing us at a live event; you're the perfect example of a great CJ: committed, passionate, possessing an intellectual curiousity and a sense of wonder and awe at the world and the news. Thanks for your ambassadorial work, urbano411.