NP Rank:
Catholic school board bans Godless book
Banning so-called atheistic books is a dumb move in my opinion. For someone to develop a solid world view it needs to be challenged. What are they so afraid of? (Answer: eternal damnation).
The Halton Catholic School Board has pulled The Golden Compass and two other related books from its libraries after board officials deemed their content was “not something that we feel is appropriate.”Alice Anne LeMay, the board’s chair said: “If parents chose these books for their children, that’s fine, but the board felt the series of books did not have a place in our schools’ libraries.”
The books, a trilogy by British author Philip Pullman — an avowed atheist — have come to the fore since the recent release of the film The Golden Compass, which stars Nicole Kidman.
“[Pullman] is very definitely against religion, against God,” said LeMay. “Is this what we want to teach the kids?”
Following complaints from parents, the book committee for the Halton board, which oversees about 45 elementary and secondary schools in the southern Ontario towns of Oakville, Burlington, Milton and Halton Hills, had originally found the books suitable for Grades 7 and up.
But the board overruled that decision Tuesday night.
“There are other books that we can use to teach [students] critical thinking,” LeMay said Thursday.
Earlier this month, Calgary’s Catholic school board also banned the book.
Crowd Power
-
Orato
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada -
PunkJr
Seattle, Washington, United States -
heathertruett
Brandon, Mississippi, United States -
thecosmickid
United States -
kimbot
Arcata, California, United States














Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (4)
- Sign In or Join to post comments
snowflakeschanceat 12:49 on December 21st, 2007
Well, I have grown up with narrow-minded, opinionated people... I wonder if they just don't fear their children growing intellectually and thinking for themselves. Also, it's just a story... It doesn't matter what the author has written, it is the readers' responsibility to interpret it. I hardly think that this or any book would change someone's beliefs. There are always people out there who twist things to their sick logic. Look at the white supremacists and their use of the same book Catholics use. Also, the Catholics sat by and didn't say anything while millions went to the gas chambers in Nazi Germany... let priests molest children.... I'm frankly surprised there are any Catholics left.
snowflakeschance has contributed a photo to this story.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
heathertruettat 20:17 on December 21st, 2007
Sure... Godless book. Um.... how many movies and books do we enjoy all the time that are also Godless? Most things of this world are Godless. Go on... ban life.
PlumPoet has contributed a photo to this story.
at 21:21 on December 21st, 2007
Rob Peters, you've convinced me you've done the work - it's authentic. I also think that you've been fair and thorough. I didn't get the sense that you were hiding your biases, or passing off other's work as your own. Or worse -- getting paid by those you cover -- so it's transparent and independent. I also think you deserve praise for being an eyewitness, and for your investigative efforts. Good stuff.
This is excellent stuff, Rob, because you've brought attention to an issue that most people are too yellow to talk about although they wholeheartedly agree with you, ie the hypocrites (yes, that's the way it's spelled)
at 21:23 on December 21st, 2007
As a footnote, I'd like to add that whatever you repress, grows harder. We all know that, don't we?