NP Rank:
E-masculinity
Manhood is a slippery idea. It seems to rest most comfortably in the chests of simple, brutish men. Men with biceps. Men that unbutton their shirts that one extra button. I have long since desired to be a simple man, but the mere act of self-analysis which revealed my desire forever casts me as one of the unfortunates, the sensitive & complex, a “smart guy,” carrying in greater measure than my love of sports a desire for new words, puns, and pithy sayings. It’s not that I look down on a well-formed deltoid, it’s just that it’s much easier for me to wield a limerick than a barbell. When M tells James Bond that he’s to exercise his judgement “dispassionately,” I make a mental note to use the word in the next day’s conversation.
An undying love for Jane Austen kicks off a cavalcade of grimace-inducing characteristics, coming one after the other in a cockeyed little parade, while the tubas oompa-oompa everything merrily along. Let’s start with the Austen problem.
The grimaces-induced don’t come from the fellas, mind you - most of them have no idea who she is, assuming that I am referring to a girl I’d French-kissed at summer camp or felt up in a car that summer I got my license.1 No, the grimaces come from the ladies, some of whom find it unfathomable that a guy that prefers the vagina to the penis would also find it pleasurable to spend an afternoon at the Dashwood’s or at Rosings Park with Lady Catherine de Bourgh.2
But don’t despair, my good readers. I’m prepared for any assaults on my manhood. If confronted by a fellow male, I intend to deliver this blazing retort:
“I’m not affronted by repressed, bosomy women in dresses that make the Wonderbra seem like a minimizer. Are you?”
Now, let’s break this down. There are five (5) major masculine errors in that statement, any one of which puts you at the dork end of the phys. ed. spectrum, and right into the “Hey, can I borrow your notes for the test?” spotlight.
- “Affronted” - This word is not used by anyone that isn’t female or a member of British Parliament.
- “Bosomy” - Most fellows don’t even know what this means, thinking it has to do with someone’s grandmother, or Abraham.
- Saying the word “dresses” - This simply isn’t done. It hints that you have a respect for fashion. Hetero-poison. Also fouls: “skirts,” “halter top,” “spaghetti strap,” “pumps,” “empire waist,” and “slip.”
- “Wonderbra” - Talking about breasts is both acceptable and encouraged while in the company of men. Discussing particular brands of lingerie is second only to actually having a period.
- “Minimizer” - Most men can’t possibly begin to grasp why something so pointless would even exist in the first place. This is in the same category as breast reduction surgery or harvesting one’s eggs.
My problem is that I love language, something that rarely pops up on someone’s “About Me” section on their sports blog. The boys at Sportscenter know how to turn a witty phrase, sure, but a writer can’t discuss the sharp, biting smell of a fresh Sharpie by using words like “bam,” “boo-yow,” and “back-back-back.” It would simply take too long.
I temper my lack of hairy man-ness with a carefully chosen and well-constructed assemblage of man-centric activities that I actually enjoy, things like scuba diving, paintball, and running. However, anyone with half a brain and a closer look will no doubt see that my copy of The Secret Life of Bees and the ease with which I can quote Ouiser Boudreaux from Steel Magnolias puts a questionable spin on the masculine purity of my Appalachian State University license tag.
What can I say, I’m unpredictable.
- Neither of which has ever occurred in my life [↩]
- There is a standing bet between myself and my friend Sheri that, on the event that I lose, I must create and affix an “I Love Jane Austen” sticker to my bumper for a period of one year, no questions asked. [↩]
Crowd Power
-
Albert Milliron
Columbia, South Carolina, United States -
&time
Saint Louis, Missouri, United States -
LadeeAlana
Mountain View, California, United States -
MsJudi
Peshtigo, Wisconsin, United States -
ryan_roxx
Breese, Illinois, United States -
djares1
United States -
P.eanut
Mexico -
antsin3d
United States -
happyjoelmoss
United States -
garyoneonly
Australia -
gartlande62
United States -
Man_Watch
United Kingdom -
OtokoJoe
Japan -
adiemus
New Zealand -
Sacred Eyes
United States -
claudia z.
Germany
Recommendations (32)
-
Jordan Yerman
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada -
mudricky
Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom -
Uwe Paschen
Narita, Chiba, Japan -
Terri Potratz
Vancouver, Canada














Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (8)
- Sign In or Join to post comments
Terri Potratzat 16:36 on January 30th, 2009
Hilarious.
at 18:58 on January 30th, 2009
:)
- Sign In or Join to post comments
Sacred Eyesat 23:28 on January 30th, 2009
I definetly believe that masculinity is not just one sided issue, as women have alot to do with the concept of it; after all, most men are raced by women and our mentality is somehow shaped by what women think about men.
Also, the concept of masculinity strongly changes from country to country and culture to culture. I find this to be very obvious when I observe the position industrialized nations take on masculinity and how they spread it through their media and how different the masculinity concept is perceived by developing countries. I think in developing countries masculinity depends more on their needs than in their muscles.
Sacred Eyes has contributed a photo to this story.
at 03:38 on January 31st, 2009
I find it a bit amusing that my photo ["Me at Rinchen Zoe La (PA150439)"] was used for an article about masculinity. I weigh 130 pounds, and I prefer reading David Sedaris and Augusten Burroughs to watching football. Although I'm straight, I certainly don't consider myself a symbol of masculinity.
at 06:34 on January 31st, 2009
Huh. I thought "Minimizer" was a Sonic Youth album.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
EileenG (not verified)at 08:06 on February 1st, 2009
Photo #17 is mine, and was takaen at the Polar Bear Plunge in Annapolis MD. I'm not sure why it was picked to show masculinity, because these macho men are huddling together really closely for warmth in the 36 degree weather, pre-plunge!
- Sign In or Join to post comments
garyoneonlyat 01:55 on February 2nd, 2009
This man's quiet contemplation got to me. He was in the north east of India, this January just gone.
He looked very male, very sure of himself, stunningly handsome; however I do not consider the truly masculine to be measured by self assuredness, classic handsomeness or an appearance of contained strength. Indeed what I admire more in a man is the ability to laugh at himself, to cry, to hold and to be held, to nurture, to love, be loved and be equal with or to another.
For me a man should be a challenge and a comfort all at once, he can be an enigma that is a blessing for all of that!
The men who have come to mean the most to me are those who cry with me, laugh beside me and are vulnerable (as needed), yet fun and exciting when there is space for that. J
garyoneonly has contributed a photo to this story.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
OtokoJoeat 19:13 on February 4th, 2009
It would be wise to specify which country, and possibly which part of that country, you're referring to. Here in Japan, social norms deem it appropriate and sometimes necessary for a man to burst into tears, depending on the situation (winning a contest, etc.). Every culture has their own sense of what masculinity should be and shouldn't be relegated to the American standard which you're referring to.
Intellectuals have always been the minority in societies--something you should cherish if that's what you believe yourself to be. Just because masculinity refers to a set of historically male traits and femininity to female ones doesn't mean that intellectualism is limited to one or the other or even means that one has to choose between intellectualism and masculinity (i.e. capable and popular leaders throughout history).
By the way, this photo was taken infront of a pachinko parlor in Japan and has nothing to do with masculinity. If you've ever been to one, you'd understand why.
OtokoJoe has contributed a photo to this story.