NP Rank:
Gender stereotypes suck for men too
Here's an interesting talking point: are men screwed over by societal gender roles as much as women?
Not quite, obviously--discrimination against men isn't institutionalized--but it's stifling to be uncommunicative, stoic, and generally ox-like all the time for the sake of appearances.
This columnist suggests that men would do well to take a page or two from the feminist playbook--blurring boundaries between masculine and feminine, and embracing the full spectrum of the venus-mars continuum. After all, real men not only blast their pecs, but cry as well (or so I'm told).
Feminism has become a dirty word in the mouths of some its enemies, so let's recall one of its basic ambitions – the release of women from the constraints of gender custom and practice. It insists – or should insist – that the blurring of boundaries between men's domain and women's, between traits we call masculine and those we call feminine, is not a dangerous assault on some sacred natural order but an advance for social justice. It's about fair play, freedom of choice and enhancing human happiness.
Men should embrace these principles too, not only for women's sake but also for their own. All else being equal, to be born male is to inherit legacies of entitlement that continue to outweigh those bestowed on those born female. Yet the state of maleness carries its own burden of expectations and constraints. Contemporary studies of boyhood shed light on what we've always known – what I still remember vividly from my own boyhood – about the disabling and limiting influence of male behaviour conventions, homophobia and general "gender policing" on men in the making and the huge anxieties that inform them.
This is the baggage men drag with them through their lives; the pressure imposed both from without and from within to appear hard and never soft, to make a performance of rejecting anything that smacks of domesticity or femininity, notwithstanding the metrosexual and "new man". Even men who seem to embody and thrive on this stereotype can feel like slaves to it, and are often undone by it.
Sensible, grown up, non-sectarian feminism recognises all of this and seeks ways for men to combat it. This is not a matter of asking men to forgo every traditional bond and pursuit in favour of their "feminine side" but of inviting them to see that such distinctions are limiting and very largely artificial. It's not a matter either of unmanning the alleged essential male, but about men flourishing and developing in all areas of their lives, including as parents and in the home. It's about making modern, dual-earner, heterosexual relationships work better; more democratically. It's about a chap discovering that he too can be a nurse in the nursery, a cook in the kitchen and a lover in the bedroom and also, should he be so inclined, wrestle grizzly bears and grout the bathroom tiles as well – and be happy for women to enjoy such freedoms, too.
News Tools
July 8, 2008 at 01:21 pm by Rob Peters, 462 views, 4 comments
Crowd Power
-
istolethetv
New York, New York, United States -
Wanda Wisdom
Minneapolis, Minnesota, United States -
kylemelderis
Australia -
homelesscomic
Tucson, Arizona, United States -
ooolicia
Cleveland, Ohio, United States -
arnaud delrue
France -
fotolilith
Galveston, Texas, United States -
Blue Star Lego
Saint Charles, Illinois, United States -
kayxf004
Castaic, California, United States -
GoldenEel
Denver, Colorado, United States -
water&sleep
Australia -
eschipul
Houston, Texas, United States -
Rob Peters
Vancouver, Canada






Add a comment
Comments (4)
at 14:41 on July 8th, 2008
"This is not a matter of asking men to forgo every traditional bond and pursuit in favour of their "feminine side" but of inviting them to see that such distinctions are limiting and very largely artificial."
Anyone who professes to not quite "get" feminism and how it's still relevant now should read this column. Given the friends I hang out with, I tend to live under the illusion that we've blissfully moved forward from defining ourselves in terms of how many X chromosomes we have, but then I'll be standing at a bus stop some days and overhearing packs of dudes talking about how queer that fag is over there. Ideas of what men are supposed to be are hugely damaging and I think a big cause of widespread and undiagnosed depression among men, and also male violence.
- reply
Anonymous (not verified)at 16:20 on July 8th, 2008
"Not really, obviously--discrimination against men isn't institutionalized"
Ah, yes it is. It's illegal to discriminate against women when considering things like employment, and college acceptance. Unfortunately, it's perfectly legal to discriminate against men in situations like these, and others. Actually, to take the point further, white males hold the smallest degree of civil rights in the United States. Even constitutional protections such as the 14th amendment (equal protection clause) has been abridged due to utilitarian issues of state compelled interests as applied to white males.
I understand this aspect of the article wasn't the thrust of the author's argument, however, I find it quite ironic that there are so many articles in today's media citing patent falsehoods while talking about gender issues.
at 17:28 on July 8th, 2008
Its a fine line. Mainstream media has depicted how a "man" should be like and how a "woman" should act. Anything not belonging in the depicted capacity are often ridculed and targeted. A man showing a bit of emotion would often be labeled as a sissy. Gender stereotypes goes both ways.
- reply
oooliciaat 02:04 on July 13th, 2008
joann's fabrics - in the scrapbooking section.
ooolicia has contributed a photo to this story.