NP Rank:
Scotland: Farmer tell's Donald Trump "Piss Off"!
I saw a brief interview on this, and found it in the news, where a Scottish Farmer in his scottish brogue basically tell the Donald to "Piss off" his farmland is not for sale. This dashing Donald Trumps dream to create a billion dollar golfers mecca on the shores of Scotland.
For "The Donald" lessons learned that for one Farmer money sometimes can't buy you everything.
BALMEDIE, Scotland • The wild stretch of east coast Scottish shoreline near the village of Balmedie hardly looks like the setting for a battle between the most famous U.S. property tycoon and a stubborn farmer.But this idyllic village is near where Donald Trump wants to build a billion-dollar golf resort, a five-star hotel, 950 time-share apartments and 500 houses, providing he can overcome the objections of Michael Forbes.
The 55-year-old salmon farmer has enlisted the support of well-wishers from around the world in his fight to stop Mr. Trump from developing the Menie Estate near Balmedie beach, about 21 kilometres north of the city of Aberdeen.
He is also refusing to sell land that sits right in the middle of the proposed development, believes the U.S. developer's plans offer little for Scotland and is annoyed at Mr. Trump for describing the state of his property as "disgusting."
"They say that money talks; not with me it doesn't," Mr. Forbes said.
"He has no chance of getting it. Take your insult and shove it. Do not bother me again: Not for sale."
Local opinion is sharply divided ahead of a key meeting next Tuesday, when councillors are due to make an initial ruling on Mr. Trump's plans. Meanwhile, the letters for and against keep pouring in.
The golf resort would be Mr. Trump's sixth, but the only one on this side of the Atlantic.
It would, he says, be a product of his links with Scotland. His mother grew up on a croft in Stornoway on the Isle of Lewis in the Outer Hebrides.
"Because my mother is Mary MacLeod from Stornoway - she lived in Stornoway for many years, I guess about 20 years before she came to the United States - I really had a preference for Scotland, and it's also the home of golf," Mr. Trump said in an interview posted on a Web site created by his company to promote the development (www.trumpgolfscotland.com).
"We saw a piece of land in Scotland that was really beautiful. And it's our ambition to ... build the best course anywhere in Europe and maybe the best course in the world, and I think we have the piece of land to do it."
The development provides a "unique opportunity to conserve and enhance the environment," according to Trump International.
The developer told Britain's Guardian newspaper he is "saving" the dunes: "It's a piece of land which is disappearing ...it's blowing all over the place."
But environmental groups, including Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH), a government conservation agency, and pressure group Sustainable Aberdeenshire have criticized the plans to stabilize a rare, 4,000-year-old sand dune system, one of the top five dune habitats in Britain.
SNH says the development would effectively destroy a site of special scientific interest and is an important habitat for plants and animals.
On Mr. Trump's side are economic development and tourism agencies - Scottish Enterprise and its Scottish Development International arm, Aberdeen and Grampian Chamber of Commerce and Visit Scotland.
Crowd Power
-
LotusFlower
Nottingham, United Kingdom -
Barry Artiste
Vancouver, Canada








Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (5)
at 05:48 on November 16th, 2007
Barry Artiste, many thanks for highlighting a little Scottish secrete.
The Scots do not sell their land unless they really have to. One of the reasons is the large land owners tend to hold hundreds of thousands of acres and money is not as important as soil. Good stuff.
at 06:36 on November 16th, 2007
Thanks Liam, I guess "The Donald" isn't used to the word NO! When people with Billions of dollars get no for an answer it certainly can ruffle your hairpiece.
Of course his hot wife can console him, because unlike the farmer she knew a Goldmine and the Donald must know if he were a Joe Punch clock without his billions, his wife would not have given him a second look. You have to respect the Farmer for sticking to his sporran and heritage
at 07:09 on November 16th, 2007
It's beyond money, and goes back deep into Scots history... John McGrath wrote about the history of Gaelic defense of their land in The Cheviot, the Stag and the Black, Black Oil.
at 03:27 on November 21st, 2007
Barry Artiste, I like this story. It's good stuff. I've been following this story for a while and somehow missed your story when first posted - it was all over the papers again yesterday here in the UK when the local planners approved Trumps plan - stories where the 'little people' take on corporate might especially when it comes to environmental issues are important - i don't yet know what the consequences of approval if ratified by Scottish parliament will be for Michael Forbes - he may be made to sell - compulsory purchase - if so that wiould be a despicable use of power, money, influence - and what for - a golf course - yes we really do need more luxury golf courses!
at 01:32 on December 2nd, 2007
On Thursday 29th Aberdeenshire Councils Infrastructure Committee rejected the Donald Trump proposal by 8 votes to 7. This was great news, however the Council are now crawling to Trump and trying to overturn their own representives decision! backed by Alex Salmond!
In my opinion they were absolutely right to reject this proposal. The development asked the councillors to break their own planning and environmental policy and go against legislation that protects the site of special scientific interest (SSSI). It was Mr Trump's inflexibility regarding the SSSI that caused the proposal to be rejected, not the councillors decision. Once such laws are broken then Mr Trump can, and will, do as he pleases.'' No SSSI will be safe!
Press coverage such as that in Aberdeenshire Evening Express paper has been totally biased, yesterday it launched a campaign to "Stuff the Council Neeps - we're supporting Trump" . Cllr Deborah Storr was confronted at her home by a woman who pushed her and shouted abuse. This behaviour is being fuelled by such coverage and now by the SNP. It's absolutely shocking the SSSI is non negotiable- but the papers tell a different story.
On the Menie not Money web site (the campaign group against the development) the forum had to be closed following abuse and threats that suggested the councillors responsible shoud be shot!
Many people in Aberdeenshire do not want this development. There are three petitions against it:
http://www.meniescotland.co.uk/speak_now.htm
This whole development is acknowledged in a council report as -having a significant effect on the environment but then go on to suggest that the economic benefits outweigh the environmental impact!
Dianne