NP Rank:
"Smacking Law" Works Say Child Advocates
There is no reason for confusion re. the intention behind this child discipline law.
You can grab a child to 'help' but you can not grab a child to "correct".
Friday, 20 March 2009,
Article: BusinesswireFor our children’s sake, let’s be fair and sensible
Joint media release by Barnardos New Zealand, Save the Children, Plunket, Jigsaw, National Collective of Independent Women's Refuges Inc, Te Kahui Mana Ririki, EPOCH New Zealand
March 20 - A coalition of organisations committed to positive outcomes for children and families wishes to set the record straight regarding the child discipline law.
After much debate and consideration of opinion and international evidence, this law was passed by both Labour and National and came into effect in May 2007.
It’s time the nation got the straight story on what the law does and doesn’t say, and how it is being used. The law is both fair and sensible.
It clearly states that parents can still use physical force to keep their children, or other children, safe. It allows parents to restrain or physically remove children, for example, to grab a child to keep them from running onto the road, or to carry them to their room, or to separate children hurting each other. Fair and sensible.
It does not allow the use of force for the purpose of correction. Children and adults now have equal protection under the law from all forms of assault. Fair at last.
It also clearly states that the police are not expected to prosecute in cases where assaults are very minor. Police monitoring of their activity in this area shows no significant increase in complaints, investigations or prosecutions. This information is on the police website for anyone to read and parents can be reassured. Again, fair and sensible.
So, physical punishment is out, positive parenting is in. Love, warmth, guidance, encouragement, clear boundaries – these are the parenting strategies that work and that support children so they know what is expected of them, what the rules are, and at the same time they feel valued and loved.
So let’s clear up the confusion. Let’s be fair and sensible and simply get on with supporting each other to love and nurture our children.
ends


Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (6)
at 20:35 on March 19th, 2009
Children are like geese and gander. Some obey a lecture, others obey a switch. My mother said her fear of her father spanking her, which he did very sparingly, saved her life even when he was miles away. She said she still obeyed his belt and did not go swimming in the silo with the children the day a friend was drowned. She abstained, because she felt like her father would find out somehow and spank her. So she went home when her friends all went swimming that day, and she was spared seeing the catastrophe.
When my daughter was still crawling, she would crawl to our electrical outlets and try to put objects into the holes. You may say I should have covered them. But I could not be with my daughter all of the time, and it was important for her to know that she could not play with electricity. I would instead go and get her from the outlet every time she did it and give her a toy to play with while saying "no, no." This went on for a number of weeks. One day, she was unaware that I was watching her, which I always was doing or she would have been in her crib. I watched her crawl to the electrical outlet and stop to look left and right to see where I was. I was standing in the doorway, but she did not see me. She had a straw from the broom in her chubby little fingers that she wanted to stick into the outlet, but she looked to ensure her mommie would not see her first. That was the day I knew she knew right from wrong and had made a conscious decision to disobey. I dealt with the issue.
By the time we went home to visit my aunt that Christmas, my aunt was amazed that my baby could be trusted to sit on a comforter underneath the Christmas tree with all of its bright decorations, strings of lights, little ornaments that were animated, surrounded by colorful packages. The wonder of it all delighted her, made her laugh, babble, and clap. Yet, she did not touch a single thing.
I had a nephew whose mother considered putting him on Ritalin, because he was so out of control that she felt he may have ADD. At six, he had already had to change schools three times. He never showed those problems when at my house on weekends. I told her that her son was gander, not a goose. He needed spankings. She kept trying not to do that. Finally one day, they came by and even with his mom there, he acted calm and obedient for a change while in her care. When I walked her to her car, I noticed a switch on her front seat. ADD problem solved.
Sometimes, discipline is abused by aggressive parents, some with mental problems. But often, discipline in the form of corporal punishment keeps one's children safe. Lots of African Americans have a saying: "Discipline your kids so the police won't have to." A couple of months ago, an 11-year-old was charged as an adult and facing prison. Maybe he still is.
Thanks for this report about New Zealand!
at 00:22 on March 20th, 2009
Brilliant stories, Duo. I agree entirely!
The problem is distinguishing 'stupid' violent parents from 'responsible' intelligent and truly loving parents!
That is why the law has to be so specific! ...for the stupid violent people.
Thank you very much for your excellent contribution to this subject for discussion!
at 17:06 on March 22nd, 2009
Hi Sara star,
Good question.
It amazes me that "anyone" can have a baby without a license! No questions asked about the quality of life the parent can offer a child. I think the criterion should be the same as for adopting a baby.
The whole argument about birth control, abortion and right to life is "rediculous" to my mind! Which reminds me, have you seen Bill Maher's recent film "Religulous"?
at 19:16 on March 20th, 2009
No one needs to strike me to get their message across, and I don't need to strike anyone else. Now if we could just get a law banning police over-use of tasers...!
at 02:08 on July 8th, 2009
My Dad had a novel way that didn't need smacking-but still made sure i got a VERY sore bottom when i needed one!, he would lay me across his lap and with a small piece of sandpaper rub my bare bottom, hard, for about 20-30 seconds, it didn't feel too bad as he did it but after a few minutes felt like my bum was on fire!. Then in the corner with my poor red sore burning little bottom waving it about trying to cool it down!. He offered cream (which was embarrassing having to poke your bare bottom out to your Dad as he RUBBED it with cream)! but i accepted-anything to ease the burning!!. Then "sorry Daddy" and i obeyed him. I wanted a cuddle (as i loved him a lot) and it worked a treat.