The ‘Swap Prisoner’ as a Readymade

by korzac | August 7, 2008 at 01:18 am
335 views | 2 Recommendations | 4 comments

Photos

The ‘Swap Prisoner’ as a Readymade

The ‘Swap Prisoner’ as a Readymade

see larger image

uploaded by korzac

The 'swap prisoner culture. Facts and opinion.

I 'admire' the Israeli jail system, specializing in producing healthy educated terrorist. Samir Kuntar is such a product. Manufactured in 29 years of precision work, he serve as a  ’ready made’ graduate prisoners swap candidate, holding a bachelor’s degree in social studies and humanities… for a killer it has certain advantages to know something about humanities..

‘On the shelf Kuntar’

 The Kuwaiti newspaper “Al Watan” in an article “Their POW and ours” (by Fouad AlـHashem) tells the tale of such a meticulous production line.

…”Lebanese prisoner, Samir AlـQuntar, spent 29 years in the Israeli prisons. No ears or hands were amputated and no rape was reported to have taken place. Three meals were offered to him on a daily basis and, he was generously, allowed to read newspapers and watch television. He consequently learned Hebrew and joined an Israeli open university as a distant learner.

Published photos of AlـQuntar after his release showed that he enjoyed good health. I”m sure that he is happy to see his mother and his younger brother who was only one year old when AlـQuntar was captured by the Israelis.
 
Now, he can start a new life. He can go to a restaurant in Barmana area to enjoy delicious meals, smoke shisha and have a toast for the Israelis who treated him better than Saddam Hussein and his Baath party.
 
AlـQuntar should thank God a lot because Lebanon neighbors Israel and not Iraq ـ a country once ruled by the oppressive Saddam regime. If AlـQuntar had been imprisoned in Iraq, he wouldn”t have returned to his country alive. He would be in a plastic bag like our Kuwaiti POWs.
 
In 1992, Saddam Hussein and his party killed 600 innocent Kuwait POWs. Although those innocent people didn”t attack Iraq or kill Iraqis, they were tortured in Iraqi prisons. They had to eat stale bread and drink dirty water. Of course they weren”t allowed to join a university in Iraq. No court orders were issued against them. They were simply shot and buried in mass graves in the Iraqi desert.

I’d like to congratulate our brothers on Lebanon on AlـQuntar’’s release and also we would like to express our utter envy for neighboring Israel, see here.”…

So Fouad AlـHashemin, the senior journalist at the Kuwaiti newspaper Al-Watan, envy the sentenced for an on life imprisonment in Israel: it is a recipe of longevity and good education. And if you are a premium swap candidate, then the hero reception with fanfares, is the ultimate  proof of the manufactured swap product quality.

 ‘On the shelf Barghouti’

Another on the shelf ‘ready made’ premium swap prisoner is Marwan Barghouti. He live in healthy condition in the Hadarin jail. From inside the jail, he directs a network of directives, distributed openly under the watchful eyes of the Israeli prison warden.  If his swapping will pay a good prize to both sides, then Gilad Shalit, the by Hamas abducted  Israeli soldier , is considered as a candidate for the swap and Marwan Barghouti a candidate to be the future Palestinian leader, the latter, manufactured with the same prescision tools as Samir Kuntar.

 

Advertisement
recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
Heritage

Some prisoners, such as Samir AlـQuntar, are high value bargaining chips and are treated well because of their value, not, unfortunately, because that is the norm.

For the vast majority of the thousands of Palesintian prisoners, most of whom are locked up without due process, torture is routine. 

Korzac wrote: "I admire the Israeli jail system..."

The Public Committee Against Torture in Israel is an Israeli NGO whose reports give a very bleak view of life in Israeli custody.

Zahalka: torture of Palestinians in Israeli prisons is the rule, not the exception

June 2008

Nablus / Amin Abu Wardeh – Palestinian member of the Israeli Knesset, Jamal Zahalka, is using Thursday, the International Day in Support of Victims of Torture, to bring the issue of Israeli torture of Palestinian political prisoners to the table.

Zahalka is proposing a full discussion on the report issued by the People’s Committee against Torture in Israel which details the ways in which Israeli soldiers routinely mistreat Palestinians.

“The occupation soldiers are trained in the school of sadism; they torture Palestinian detainees and abuse them.”

The report referred to how the soldiers deal with the Palestinians after they are handcuffed, shackled and have had their eyes covered. It outlines 90 cases among thousands where political prisoners are subjected to brutal torture by Israeli soldiers.

In his speech Zahalka described this kind of treatment as sadistic, that torture is used just for tortures sake and that no matter what types of Israeli justifications they try to employ, there never can be.

He pointed to the fact that they do not pose a threat to the soldiers: not in their cells, during the interrogation or questioning, or during the process of being transferred to interrogation.

Zahalka said that the Israeli army's claim that there are no set procedures for dealing with the Palestinian prisoners is the “ugliest excuse for their guilt.” He asserts that there are procedures and rules, even if they are not written on paper.

As a small example in a sea of mistreatment, said Zahalka, are soldiers beating Palestinians, but before doing so throwing them onto the hot steel of the hoods of military jeeps. After that comes the kicking.

Finally Zahalka said that torture and ill-treatment is the rule rather than the exception.

cassy82
cassy82
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 04:39 on August 7th, 2008

korzac, I like this story. It's good stuff.

0
korzac

cassy82, thanks for the GS.

0
Heritage

This is a related story from tomilaineclark



“Did you discuss the prisoner swap?”

Sami Kuntar was one of the prisoners Israel released to Hezbollah. He spent the last 30 years in jail for murder. She said that prison was like Club Med for him- he got an education, he was taken care of. I said that she does not have a very accurate idea of her own prison system.

She frowned and I debated whether to continue. Should I educate her on her own country’s jails? She did bring up the subject, after all.

So I went on, and told her carefully that, based on many, many first-person accounts I have heard, no matter what crime you are arrested for, you are tortured. Israelis almost without exception torture their Palestinian detainees.

For detainees who are suspected of the most innocuous crimes, this torture may consist of forced nudity, stress positions, and sleep deprivation. For those who are accused of more serious crimes the torture may consist of subjection to surgery without anesthesia.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

NowPublic on Facebook

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

cassy82
First Flagged at 4:39 AM, Aug 7, 2008 by cassy82
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in Culture

 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from