Warren Bonesteel: An astute and distrurbing analysis

by Susan Marie Kovalinsky | September 20, 2009 at 07:38 am
699 views | 28 Recommendations | 6 comments

Photos

Loading photos...
Critical Commentary:  The great left/right ideological divide,  and the pending civil war in America 

Author and researcher Warren "Bones"  Bonesteel was guest commentator last night on Stand Up for America. 
Mr. Bonesteel is that rare breed of classical liberal,  the old-style Jeffersonian Democrat,  hearkening back to another era.

 
His analysis is highly disturbing,  but very deeply-probing and factual.  I thought it of such import,  regarding the growing divide of left vs right within our new era of Obama,  that I posted it several places, and thought I would here as well:
The Rise of Extremism  ("the paradigm is about to crash and burn around your ears):  
Tonight’s guest commentary is a little bit different than the guest commentaries of the past. Tonight I offer one written by someone who is not a regular reader at this site. I admittedly have some from you folks that have submitted them. I began working on them in earnest this week in an effort to have one ready. However, Mrs. Weapon has kept me busy. I first received an email from this author several months ago. He offered his writing as thinking material for me and I remember that it had an immediate impact. It was well written, informative, and caused the reader to perform some introspection. He has written many different articles or “open letters” in the past, and I intend to offer some of his other work in the near future. I offer tonight’s article because I felt that it was a very relevant piece considering some of the discussions that we have been having lately. I hope that you will enjoy what he has to say….

Tonight’s guest author is Warren “Bones” Bonesteel. Warren is a published author, an e-zine-columnist ‘on sabbatical,’ and has written articles for newspapers and magazines. After his Marine Corps career, he spent two years as a construction worker. He later started, operated and sold a successful formal gardening business. He and his wife of seventeen years currently reside in the Black Hills of South Dakota. Warren sent me this piece in an email in June. After corresponding, he provided me with several other extremely interesting articles. I am impressed with the level of research and thought that go into his articles. He doesn’t come to his conclusions easily. They are the result of much work. I hope that you will enjoy this first offering. I have contacted Warren to let him know that the article is running this evening. I am sure that should he find time, he will pop in and join the conversation.

The Rise of Extremism
by Warren “Bones” Bonesteel

The true wonder is…

The rhetorical and political attacks on right-wing ‘extremists’ by left-wing ’extremist’ politicians, activists, media outlets and bloggers are creating the environments for the very things they fear. The same is true with the right’s rhetorical and political attacks on the left. If both sides don’t stop and take a deep breath and think about the consequences of their own words and deeds and examine the premises of their own ideology, open violence and civil war are inevitable.

The Tiller murder and the demonization of more than a hundred million Americans because of it? The eco-terrorist’s destruction of the environment and private property in the name of protecting the environment? (FBI ten most wanted list.) The RNC Welcoming Committee? ReCreate 68? The stalking and ‘mobbing’ of ideological opponents by right-wing and left-wing ’extremists’? The violent and deadly Muslim attacks on innocent Americans? The miltarization of civilian police departments, with thousands of SWAT teams, ‘accidentally’ killing more than three hundred innocent Americans in their own homes, each and every year? All of that – and more – is only the beginning of the violence that we will see and experience for ourselves.

An extreme pov? No. It is historically inevitable. America is not immune from history. The world is not a nice, quiet, middle-class suburb or a gated community. Violence is always the result when opposing ideologies indulge in such rhetorical and political attacks upon one another as are seen in today’s American political and social landscape. Historically, when the government begins to exert control over the private lives of its citizens? When the civilian police forces become militarized? Historically, when opposition parties begin to actively and openly dehumanize and demonize their ideological opponents, as is now occurring in America? Such things are always a prelude to violence and to civil war.

The wonder isn’t that America will experience another civil war or possibly break up into individual nation-states. The true wonder, historically, is that America has held together as long as it has. Both of the major political ideologies in America will bear full and complete responsibility for the death and destruction that is now almost inevitable. The poor and inept leadership by members of the political, social and intellectual leadership in America has led us all to this point in history.

Ideology: Eyes to the left or eyes to the right.

You complain about the economy and about big government spending… but you vigorously defend your own debt and credit-driven lifestyles. You quite correctly accuse your ideological opponents of corruption, but violently defend your own. You complain when another ideology legislates a law that restricts your own freedom, but you vigorously pursue laws which restrict the freedoms of others. Thus, you now live in a society where anything not approved by the government is a crime – and there is very little that the government approves. Then, you wonder why America has the highest incarceration rate of any nation on earth. Are Americans so evil that we must lock them all up? Or have we imprisoned nearly two million people just because you don’t approve of them? The majority of American ‘criminals’ who are imprisoned have performed no violent crime nor have they committed fraud or interfered in the freedoms of others.

You think you are free…you’ve been told that you are free. …but you cannot make a move without some form of government approval; paying a tax or a fee or getting a license or a permit. Every move you make is regulated by the government. The very air you breath is now being taxed.

But, in the midst of your Keynesian-consumerist driven and government-controlled lifestyles, you think that you are free…and you think that you are just…and you think that you are patriotic, freedom-loving fools…and you believe that anyone who disagrees with you is an unpatriotic ’extremist.’

Whose ‘eye’ is to blame?

As Americans have continued to elect and re-elect such inept and corrupt leaders as we now have in Washington and in state legislatures around the nation, we each bear responsibility for the inevitable result of such leadership. If we wish to place the blame for the current state of affairs on anyone, we need only look in the mirror and reflect upon the eyes that we see.

Disclosure: Although I registered as a Republican for a local election in 2004, I am actually a rare breed these days. I’m a ‘Jeffersonian Democrat.’ A true Classical Liberal. Of course, from the pov of our government, that makes me an enemy of the state. From the pov of the political right, I’m a left-wing liberal. From the pov of the left, I’m a right-wing extremist. The Cassandra Effect does apply, here. You see, your own hubris and ideologies have blinded you. Most of you believe, in complete denial of all of the facts and against all of the evidence of mankind’s recorded history, that ‘this sort of thing just can’t happen in America.’

I’ve got news for you.

That paradigm is about to crash and burn around your ears.

(NOTE: The enclosed links and attachments provide the ‘bibliography’ and ’footnotes’ for this commentary and include peer-reviewed authors and materials as well as government websites and resources. Approximately 30 pages of references with 90 pages in total.)

Warren “Bones” Bonesteel
Author and Researcher
Sgt USMC 1976-1983


Advertisement
recommend This comment thread is now closed
6
Karen Hatter

Although I tend to understand the seriousness of the dynamics now playing out for all the world to see, I am hopeful those in the majority, who I will assume are displeased with the more exclusionary elements within this country, those within the fringes, will act accordingly to give voice and take action to avoid the possibility of the outcome the author envisions, another civil war or dissolving of the union.  

2
a211423

Historically, when the government begins to exert control over the private lives of its citizens? When the civilian police forces become militarized? Historically, when opposition parties begin to actively and openly dehumanize and demonize their ideological opponents, as is now occurring in America? Such things are always a prelude to violence and to civil war.

We already made it through an attempt by the federal government to take control of the private lives of citizens with the reign of J.Edgar Hoover in the FBI from its inception in 1935 and continued until its "dictator's" death in 1972. 

In 1956, Hoover was becoming increasingly frustrated by Supreme Court decisions that limited the Justice Department's ability to prosecute people for their political opinions, most notably, Communists. At this time he formalized a covert "dirty tricks" program under the name COINTELPRO. Its methods included infiltration, burglaries, illegal wiretaps, planting forged documents and spreading false rumors about key members of target organizations. Some authors have charged that COINTELPRO methods also included inciting violence and arranging murders. In 1975, the activities of COINTELPRO were investigated by the "United States Senate Select Committee to Study Governmental Operations with Respect to Intelligence Activities" called the Church Committee after its chairman, Senator Frank Church D-Idaho and these activities were declared illegal and contrary to the Constitution.  Hoover amassed significant power by collecting files containing large amounts of compromising and potentially embarrassing information on many powerful people, especially politicians. According to Laurance Lieberman appointed Deputy Attorney General in early 1974, FBI Director Clarence Kelly thought such files either did not exist or had been destroyed. After The Washington Post broke a story in January 1975, Kelley searched and found them in his outer office. The House Judiciary Committee then demanded that Silberman testify about them. An extensive investigation of Hoover's files by David Garrow showed that Hoover and next-in-command William Sullivan, as well as the FBI itself as an agency, were responsible.

While Mr. Bonesteel's observations of "government control in our lives" can be a threat, a representative government of checks and balances is also in place and works, which is exemplified by the investigations into the FBI.  Granted, it took years of abuses by Hoover for unconstitional practices to be intercepted, but the fact is eventually they were, which is proof the system works.  

Countries with dictatorial governments and military junta's are internally fragile because they lack the stability of a representative government that provides a congressional infrastructure for peaceful legislative confrontation and change enlisting the support and "buy in" of the greater population.   Therefore, the risk of civil war or toppling unstable, dictatorial governments is ever present.   This is not the case in the United States.    

2
APE131313

Why won't people realize that there are people on BOTH sides that can be pushed to their  limits by this constant turmoil? History has proved it again and again. Those in the media are complicit and will not be held blameless. We need to stand together, as Americans first and demand both sides act in responsible ways....................enough is MORE than enough!

0
John Steinsvold

An Alternative to Capitalism? The following link, takes you to a "utopian" article, entitled "Home of the Brave?" which I wrote and appeared in the Athenaeum Library of Philosophy: evans-experientialism.freewebspace.com/steinsvold.htm John Steinsvold

2
Jim Arnold

I'm not impressed. I don't call Mr. Bonesteel a "right-wing extremist." To equate the "left" and the "right" is the signature of the sullen, confused, and not-so-insightful "middle." The "left" protested Bush with t-shirts, and got arrested. The "right" protest Obama with firearms, and walk freely. Yeah, samey same. The "right" produces and consumes outrageous and stupid lies about the health-care initiatives, the "left" advocates access to decent health-care for all, like in other industrialized countries, with no need to lie about it. Samey same. The "right" calls the "left" traitors, the "left" calls the "right" foolish, misguided, and selfish. Samey same. To fail to recognize the overwhelming power of corporatism in our country, and the need to reign it in, is to be played for a fool (if a "right-wing" tea-bagger) or an irrelevance (if a "middling" mirror-gazer).Put down your mirror, Mr. Bonesteel. Look outside.

0
gregory sacchetti

debt and credit driven lifestyle how could it really be any other way or haven't you noticed the erosion of the middle class the suppression of wages . the domination of retail by walmart and the race to the bottom. with the distribution of wealth upwards the most extreme since the 1920s ! 1% own more them the bottom 40% this is not conducive to democracy  our economy looks more like mexico than Europe's. For politicians how could it be any different money so dominates our system that we have a political class which work with and for the special in-tress who bribe them. ( and are them : every member of the senate is a millionaire) with million and millions and receive billion back in return. and they like the money and the power it buys why else would they rig redistricting to ensure their reelections, both parties. wall street insist on unreasonable returns gutting companies and shipping jobs overseas, working people pay higher rates of taxes then investors who reek only discourse and anguish. and when their greed gets the better of them we bailed them out with trillions of tax payer dollars and their arrogant is not to be believed but why not they took our money and bought the best government they could get, even now their lackeys on capital hill are gutting any regulations their masters don't want and it is only going to get worse while our strict Robert's supreme court are preparing to overturn a hundred years of law to allow corporations free speech rights(money) to completely dominate the bankrupt political system we are burdened with now with direct political contributions. hate mongers control talk radio and fox news our culture is so dominated by the right wing and their corporate agenda. That I believe we may already be a fascist nation how else to explain a foreign policy that benefits only corporate global in-tress, that of big oil , halaburtion and blackwater. our government needs a professional army(an army of the poor and the rural) no citizen army would fight for such a ambiguous cause. but lets also blame the left also maybe acorn importing illegal weapons like black water was, or the burning of unoccupied development in areas out west is really a prelude to civil war I see the discourse at about a 80 , 20 split if even that. and the war may have already been fought and lost just need some tiding up around the edges is all

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

NowPublic on Facebook

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Karen Hatter
First Flagged at 7:57 AM, Sep 20, 2009 by Karen Hatter

Related Stories

Recommendations (28)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from