Who Won America's Next Top Model All-Stars 2011? ANTM Controversy

Who Won America's Next Top Model 2011? The New ANTM Winner Was Named Amid Controversy

America's Next Top Model All-Stars named its winner on Wednesday, December 7, 2011 amid a controversial disqualification.

The final three contestants of this ANTM All-Stars cycle were Lisa D'Amato, Allison Harvard, and Angelea Preston.

For reasons that largely went unexplained, ANTM Judges disqualified Preston, leaving D'Amato and Harvard in the running.

Who Won America's Next Top Model All-Stars 2011?

Eventually, D'Amato was named the ANTM All-Stars 2011 winner.

As for why Preston was kicked off the show, the network released a statement on the matter.