Why don't girls play guitar?

by Amy Judd | April 12, 2008 at 01:52 pm
2287 views | 7 Recommendations | 15 comments

Photos

According to a study by the BBC, when school children pick an instrument to play, their choices are stongly influenced by gender stereotypes. So more girls play the flute and more boys play the guitar. I have many girl friends that play the guitar however, so I hope this is changing.

When a child utters the words "I want to play the drums", even the most musically-minded parent's heart must sink a little at the thought of all that, well, noise.

But the more peaceful households are those with girls because they prefer the harp or flute while boys go for electric guitar and drums, according to a report by the Institute of Education.

Many instruments learnt in schools are dominated by one sex or the other, says the study which examined the provision of music for five to 16-year-olds in every local authority in England and Wales.

Only one in 10 school harpists and flautists are male, while the electric and bass guitars are enjoyed overwhelmingly by boys.

There are many reasons why strides made in bringing equality to other areas, such as school sports, have not reached the music room, says Professor Sue Hallam, co-author of the report.

"I think that over a long period of time, these kinds of ideas about what is suitable for children to play, or adults to play, have been around for so long we've internalised it," she says.

recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
Jordan Yerman

Hopefully Chrissie Hynde, Kelley Deal, Lita Ford, the Wilson sisters, and others can serve as proper rockin' role models...

0
Amy Judd

Totally, I hope so too!

0
Mimi smile

I think it is popular to say that you're playing the guitar.
But I think also there 're a lot of girl, who play the guitar very well.
I learned at school for my study at Primaryschool teacher.
I really love the play to set a side my thought and to reflex and relax.

Mimi smile has contributed a photo to this story.

0
Amy Judd

I agree that the guitar has become the 'cool' instrument to play, and I think many girls play the guitar very well. Some better than boys!

Barry Artiste
Barry Artiste
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 15:49 on April 12th, 2008

amyjudd, I like this story. It's good stuff. I think anyone who plays a musical instrument and plays it well says something of their artistic side, and their choice of music their emotional side,  for me I play my guitars as stress relief from lifes daily grind, I prefer my Classical model and playsing Eric Clapton or Cat Stevens does the trick for me.

0
Amy Judd

I play the violin, although not very well, and that appears to be a unisex instrument so I have no idea what the study says about me! I find it relieves stress though!

0
Libelul

Libelul has contributed a photo to this story.

0
Barry Artiste

Your welcome Amy, I think everyone should learn to play a musical instrument, regardless whether a sheet of paper over a comb or hitting pots with a spoon, we would need less medication if we were to play music, as they say soothes the savage stressed out emotional beast within all of us.

0
vegaswatchdogdotcom

So, Amy, you really want to know? First let me list the best female pickers in each musical field:

#1 in Blues / Rock has to be Bonnie Raitt. (no competition as far as popularity)

#1. in Blues / Soul has to be Tracy Chapman. (she can make it talk)

#1. in Country has to be Mother Maybelle Carter (June's Mom) who created a style of finger picking that male and female have copied for many decades. Also here, Barbara Mandrell has to be mentioned since she really was a serious picker on a whole bunch of instruments even as a little girl when she played the casino nightclub circuit with her Dad. She plays excellent steel guitar.

#1. in Classical according to all the sources I can find is a lady named Lily Afshar who was among the twelve international guitarists selected to play for Andrés Segovia in his master classes. And she seems to have won every major competition in the world for the female Classical guitarist.

#1. for female bass guitar player (which would be even more difficult fingerwise for a lady) has to be
Carol Kaye. one of the busiest studio bassists to ever work in Los Angles.
She played on the Beach Boys' "Good Vibrations", Glen Campbell's "Witchita Lineman", Joe Cocker's "Feelin' Alright" and hundreds more hits. Her film credits include: Mission Impossible, Bonanza, Airport, Bill Crosby, Bob Hope, Academy Awards special etc...she's backed on record: Ray Charles, Quincy Jones, Frank Sinatra, Count Basie, Stevie Wonder, Burt Bacharach, Herb Alpert, Mel Torme
It would be very hard for even a male picker to match her achievements.

Why do chicks shy away from guitar more than the flute or harp? Well, tonight for three hours try pushing a thick kitchen knife as hard as you can into the middle of the top of the three fingers located between your thumb and your pinkie. Even nylon strings will do this if one seriously practices regularly.

And until the nerves in the ends of your fingers actually become numb to the feel of the strings, playing guitar is not a lot of fun even for guys.

They have a pretty good physical explanation about the strength it takes to play guitar at www.bluesforpeace.com

But after decades of performing on stages and working with top musicians in The Entertainment Capital of the World, I can tell you that you may not know their names, but I have seen and played with dozens of chicks that would make most male guitarists go hide under the stage. One all chick band I worked opposite in the 70s at The Aladdin Hotel was called "Jo Ann Bon & the...(I think it was) The Coquettes?" Six chicks that played with as much force as a Superbowl offensive line. So fellas, don't ever think that women cannot take over the world if they choose to. Just be nice to them and maybe they will let us stay around to admire them and their talents.

The key to anything is "to do whatever YOU want to do will take that determination, persistence and hard, hard work." If one is willing to pay the price necessary to achieve goals, memorize the old Nike commerical slogan...."Just Do It"!

And if there are any ladies who desire to know some shortcuts in learning to play guitar, just email me from WildBillUSA.com and I can probably give you some suggestions as to how to start playing real songs fairly quickly instead of grinding away week after week never being able to really play a tune. But you still have to be willing to practice faithfully. It will be worth it when the next time you show up to sing karaoke, you bring your guitar and play along with the song on the stage.

Playing a guitar on stage, ladies, is an excellent way to gain the attention of every male in attendance. All the dressed up "wanna bees" will be left standing at the curb, while your Prince Charming zooms away with you in his Golden Chariot.

That alone should be worth a couple of months with sore fingers. So grab that guitar and make some music!

PEP
PEP
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 03:45 on April 13th, 2008

amyjudd, I like this story. It's good stuff. I used to play the guitar, although not very well. Folk songs and all that, mostly.

Hmm..I began learning the recorder, play piano (badly), and also the Indian flute. Had a try at the Celtic harp, too, now awaiting a new string and my surgery. Come to think of it, not sure if I've ever seen a prominent male harpist? Hmmmm.

0
Barry Artiste

One only has to look at old footage of Harpo Marx to see a Prominent Harpist. As for today, I guess a Rapper or Heavy Metal artist would look a wee bit Loopy swinging a Harp on stage. Though in Ireland they do have harpsicords

0
xuen

i love guitar. it brings me a lot of FUN !

xuen has contributed a photo to this story.

0
mila.pequena

That's me in my room, playing guitar. I always wanted to learn, my brother plays, but he never taught me. Now, my fiancée has given me some classes and I keep practicing at home.

mila.pequena has contributed a photo to this story.

0
jjenet

Ya girls play guitar they really love and know music comparatively to that of boys.

In my group there are two girls who plays guitar nicley with us when we are out with our guitars

I think you also love to play Guitar Is't it?

0
Fevine

We girls are also playing Guitar. We love to play Bass Guitar Lessons.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Barry Artiste
First Flagged at 3:49 PM, Apr 12, 2008 by Barry Artiste
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in Culture

 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from