Damn emotions, why we make bad $$ decisions

by ryan | August 10, 2007 at 09:26 am
625 views | 24 Recommendations | 3 comments

Photos

sm_Trailer_Front_5-3-05

sm_Trailer_Front_5-3-05

see larger image

uploaded by Have No Job

Worldwide markets are crashing. The sub-prime mortgage market imploded. And now, as the puzzle pieces come apart and details of the loans people were taking out to finance their oversized homes emerge...the only thing left to ask is - what were they thinking? A reverse amortizing, variable interest rate loan?!?

Psychologists take on the task.

So why do people take out sub-prime loans? Don't they realize that they won't be able to afford the ensuing 28 years of mortgage payments? I think a big part of the reason sub-prime loans remain so seductive, even when the financial terms are so atrocious, is that they take advantage of a dangerous flaw built into our brain. This flaw is rooted in our emotional brain, which tends to overvalue immediate gains (like a new house) at the expense of future costs (high interest rates). Our feelings are thrilled by the prospect of a new home, but can't really grapple with the long-term fiscal consequences of the decision. Our impulsivity encounters little resistance, and so we sign on the bottom line. We want the house. We'll figure out how to pay for it later.

The problem seems to lie in the conflict between emotion and logic. I want it now versus this is a financial risk I can't and don't want to take.

When we opt for a 2/28 mortgage, we are acting like experimental subjects choosing the wrong gift certificate. Because the emotional parts of our brain reliably undervalue the future - life is short and they want pleasure now - we end up delaying saving until tomorrow (and tomorrow and tomorrow.) George Loewenstein, a neuroeconomist at Carnegie Mellon University and a collaborator on the Cohen paper, thinks that understanding how we make decisions will help economists develop better public policies: "Our emotions are like programs that evolved to solve important and recurring problems in our distant past," he says. "They are not always well suited to the decisions we make in modern life. It's important to know how our emotions lead us astray so that we can design incentives and programs to help compensate for our irrational biases."

Advertisement
recommend This comment thread is now closed
Jordan Yerman
Jordan Yerman
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 09:37 on August 10th, 2007

Emotion is key to purchasing decisions. Emotion creates housing bubbles, in which real-estate prices are inflated beyond their real-world value; whn I was a rentals agent in NYC, I saw that people, when faced with a place they just loved but could not afford, would put in an application anyway, even if I, the broker tried to talk them out of it... Emotion makes us buy, and easy credit is our enabler!

PEP
PEP
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 09:11 on August 12th, 2007

This is really good stuff! I think that all of us struggle between "instant gratification" and the delaying of pleasure in some far-off, unknown future.

Easy credit is the new version of the old "three card monte" or "shell game" that hustlers played on the streets. Bottom line: no matter what you choose, the system is now structured to, in essence, punish you for using their credit and services. There are secrets, too.

Once I was charged a late fee when I had actually paid on time. The reason given--it was processed in our system after 1 p.m. and we count that as late. Never mind that I had paid online, via their website, and the payment was sent in way ahead of time! Had I not called (and I got my money back), I would never have learned that 1 p.m. rule.  

 Interesting experiment: call your charge card companies and ask them what the cut-off time for "on time" payments is on the due date. Then contemplate: if you submit a payment 5 to 7 days, or even 3 days, ahead of time, and it's their computers that handle the payment time, or their process that handles the mail, what are the chances that the process could easily sling many payments into the "late" bin?

0
ryan

PEP,

Thanks for the wonderful comment. You are definitely right about the danger and appeal of credit. But it's no surprise that  business capitalized on this human tendency as such is the nature of the beast...

Our dependence and trust in the electronic systems that run every system we interact with is a huge weakness...we blindly trust computers and their makers. 

 

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

NowPublic on Facebook

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Jordan Yerman
First Flagged at 9:37 AM, Aug 10, 2007 by Jordan Yerman
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in Tech & Biz

 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from