Canadian seal hunt suffers European pressure

by Kaitlin | January 11, 2008 at 10:10 am
999 views | 9 Recommendations | 12 comments

Videos

Loading videos...

Photos

HW-3-26-025

HW-3-26-025

see larger image

uploaded by IFAW

The oft-criticized Canadian seal hunt faced another blow this week when the national Ambassador for Fisheries Conservation acknowledged that the hunt is threatened by pressure from European animal rights groups.

Loyola Sullivan, who was appointed Ambassador last year, has been criticized for this statement by the Newfoundland provincial Fisheries Minister Tom Rideout. Rideout called the statement "unnecessarily negative," stressing that the issue is far from resolved, and that his government's defense of the hunt has recently gained ground.


“We were astounded and surprised at the view taken by the Canadian ambassador for fisheries conservation,” Mr. Rideout said Friday in a statement.

“It is never too late and this is quite a defeatist attitude for an ambassador to take when the issue is still very much ongoing.”

Mr. Sullivan, who attended a gathering of about 100 sealers Tuesday, told reporters that it is difficult to overcome the anti-sealing lobby now because their message has acquired a strong foothold in Europe.

According to Government of Canada websites, Sullivan's capacity as Ambassador means he is responsible for
making sure the world is clear about Canada's priorities for global fisheries. These include sustainable resource use, and the conservation and rebuilding of global fish stocks.
Sullivan has had a long career in Newfoundland provincial politics; he also at one time was the owner and operator of two fish processing operations in the province.


recommend This comment thread is now closed
LotusFlower
LotusFlower
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 14:02 on January 11th, 2008

Kaitlin, I like this story. It's good stuff. Good research - I like the personalisation of the story with your interweaved commentary - thanks.

SOLARLIFE
SOLARLIFE
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 02:00 on January 12th, 2008

Kaitlin, important awareness article



Canada is late in take off for protection
of Wild life
anyway I am surprised that
this barbaric slaughtering for a handfull of $
is not stopped by the Canadian public will ?
Why no action ? Europeans protect the place
where they want to live in the future, this is
called "Man and his home planet"
Invite you all to join now
Get some proposals published
thanks for taking care of planet

Barry Artiste
Barry Artiste
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 21:14 on January 13th, 2008

Kaitlin, excellent story. Though seal hunting is a livlihood for many Newfoundlanders, the other aspect of the hunt is to control seals who indiscriminately take a single bite out of a Cod and killing it,(a cod may carry 50,000 eggs that will never see life) thus contributing to the decline of of the cod stocks come fishing season. Again, two sides to a single story (seal Hunt) no one ever thinks about. Culling the seals save Cod, culling seals provides a living to a centuries old tradition, and cod fishing provides a livlihood to a dying industry. Without both, oil exploration is a new lifeline to Newfoundlanders who would rather be fishing, because Newfoundlanders know oil derricks and the resulting pollution and activity may result in the elimination of both species one day.

0
Tracy2

Cod actually composes only a small amount of the harp seals' diet.  The cod industry in Canada/Newfoundland crashed from overfishing, a fact that the Canadian Dept. of Fisheries now finally admits on its own website.  As far as tradition goes, seals were once taken for use by the indigenous people of the area.  And they only killed what they needed to survive, not the 250,000 baby seals that are butchered now. Unfortunately those people were pretty much wiped out by the settling Europeans.  At least when the original inhabitants killed the seals, they used all of it.  Today's seal clubbers skin them alive half the time and send the pelts so someone in Russia can satisfy their vanity with a coat.  Did you know that there is a company in Germany who was willing to pay the seal killers more money than they make clubbing seals to obtain their hair by a non-lethal method (BRUSHING) but the Canadian government said no? Did you know that most of the pups from the last couple of years drowned due to poor sea ice and the rest were killed anyway?


The people who live in these areas could absolutely rake in the money by giving eco-tours - letting people see these beautiful animals in their own environment.  What is happening now is a tragedy and an affront to nature.  There is no place for this brutal mammalian torture/slaughter in the year 2008.


I BEG EVERYONE READING THIS -  go to www.harpseals.org and get the facts for yourselves.  Then do something to help these animals.  Boycott Canadian seafood, write to your representatives, participate in the International Day of Action...do something before another innocent species goes extinct due to the arrogance and ignorance of humans!

0
Barry Artiste

Well your comments certainly makes me feel all warm and toasty.  Here is the facts, if you say 250,000 seals are killed every year, I counter with that is AT A MINIMIUM of 250,000 COD of for sake of argument 100,000 are egg laying females carrying 50,000 eggs.  Here is a FACT Seals do not devour COD , Seals take a sizeable and FATAL Bite out of an Codfish which then floats to the bottom of the ocean to it's death.

You see Tracy, Newfies, much like the First Nations used to catch Cod as part of their livlihood and part for food.

Your reference for everyone in the World to Boycott Canadian Seafood, certainly shows us your Eco Sensibility "most likely you are an ill informed teen"  as well in all things misinformation in the ECO World.  Tracy2, If you wish to find out for yourself, do the research or read my past Opinion columns, there you will find very little Canadian Seafood if any is caught in Canada, or North America. Why? Well partly due to Seals indiscriminatley killing seals one bite at a time, but actually the biggest threat to Cod is there is cheaper seafood found elsewhere such as CHINA. Canadian Fisherman on the East Coast haven't fished for decades, one of the major Buyers HIGHLINER gets the bulk of their Fish in China and Vietnam which they process in Canada and sell to North American consumer who mistakenly think they are getting a Canadian product. 

There ya go, now you know something ,you should have researched in the first place. 

0
MichM.

I agree with your comments, Tracey2.  Another thing that goes conveniently unmentioned by supporters of the baby seal slaughter is that killing large numbers of seals actually contributes to the demise of cod-stocks, since harp seals prey on several species of cod-predators.  Harp seals help keep the ecosystem and cod populations healthy by keeping these predator species in check.  (As  you said, cod represents barely a fraction of the harp seals' diet.)  In fact, even the most ardent "sealhunt" supporters (of which there are very few) have ceased to blame seals (at least publicly) for the depletion of the cod fishery as this has been so widely scientifically discounted. 

0
Barry Artiste

The cods main predators are Seals!! Read a Book. I work in the environment industry, having witnessed seals corner a BC salmon near a dock and take a single bite out of it. Thank God for Orcas,

Newfoundlanders by an large are small boat fisherman, not like European fishing liners the size of a friggin tankers who rape the seas of fish regarless of species off the coast of Newfoundland. That is the problem of overfishing. Newfs kill Seals to control the population, they need to make a living as they did for hundreds of years, their families have to eat, since welfare is not an option they want. MP Tobin over two decades ago had to send Navy warships to stop foreign fishing vessels from encroaching our seas,

Overfishing in part is true, but while newfoundlanders have not fished in over a decade other countries, Portugal and other countries continue to fish cod offshore of newfoundland, taking immature cod etc.  Iceland had this problem with other countries overfishing their terroritories until they took action using warships and media to turn away fishing boats,  Iceland today has a healthy fishing population and economy, no depleted stocks.  Ottawa on the other hand legislated, mandated and pretty much screwed Newfoundlanders by prevernting them from ensuring fishing stocks remained viable.  Newfies would not overfish, as this is their livlihood . Reading off Government websites on Cod Stocks for Info is one sure way  ingest verbal diaherra from a government.  Newfs have lived and fished there for 500 years, so I would surmise they know what they speak of, when the Rodents of the Sea indiscriminately kill Cod laden with thousands and thousands of eggs, something has to be done to cull the seal herd. True not pretty, but then neither is a dead community.

Again, I refer you to read a book, do more research and never rely on Government websites who most bureaucrats likely never fished for their livlihood. 

 

0
Mark Donners

There is a peculiar tendency of Canadians to shift the blame, pointing bloody fingers at other countries while refusing to clean up their own backyard. The idea that seals are livestock is ludicrous, they have been part of an ecological balance for millions of years and Canada is destroying that balance. Canadians used the same tactic when they wiped out vast stocks of North Atlantic fish. An impoverished Newfoundland joined Canada after they had exterminated the Beothuk Indians, the Labrador Duck, the Giant Auk, the Walrus, the Newfoundland wolf and ravaged the populations of sea-birds and pilot whales. They fed pilot whales to mink in cages until the whales just simply disappeared. They joined Canada reluctantly because Canada offered them the baby bonus -- they would receive money just for having kids. That was the deal clincher for Newfoundland. As for the lie the seal killers and the corrupt politicians in the Canadian government keep floating around, "Seals are overpopulated": More than half the seal nurseries disappeared last year because of ice loss due to global warming and up to 90% of the pups were lost. The Canadian DFO which is composed of essentially corrupt officials, can't and won't make an accurate account, surveys indicate close to three million..compared to their original population of 40 million.. probably much lower, and dropping like a stone.

0
Mark Donners

A completely false argument of the seal killers is that seals eat all the codfish. It was Canada that wiped out the vast populations of cod, haddock, whiting and plaice with their greed and their factory trawlers. The diet of seals is ONLY 3% food fish like cod. The main diet of seals is the predators of the fish like skate and squid, so therefore the vast populations of fish that Canada had destroyed by 1992 will never come back since the predators numbers have grown with the brutal massacres of seals. Another propaganda point is that seals are killed for food. They are not. Seals are killed for the fur market in Asia and their carcasses are discarded on the ice. The rotting flesh can't be sold and the Canadian government buys them up as an indirect subsidy. Even the fur prices have plummeted to half because of lack of buyers. In collusion with this mafia, Norwegian factory they shipped furs to illegally burned furs to try to drive the prices up. The sealers and the government officials that support them are essentially a small group of organized mafia. Another bogus argument is this is necessary income for "poor" people. There are only a few people who do these atrocities in the offseason for EXTRA money, many actually travel from the cities. Last year the income of this group was a paltry six million, one 20th of 1% of the revenue of the East Coast. The main income of the sealers is in various fisheries throughout the year, shellfish such as snow crab makes up a huge portion of that. The economy of Newfoundland grew by 9%, so there is no scarcity of jobs.

0
Mark Donners

These few sealers are in fact acting like traitors to Canada. To earn the pitiful $6 million profit they bilked the Canadian taxpayer for over $30 million dollars in subsidies (Coast Guard helicopter/ship support, overseas propaganda vacations for corrupt officials, etc) and cost Canada half a billion dollars in boycotts, much of that snow crabs, the mainstay of Newfoundland. To add insult to injury, many sealers are plagued with alcoholism and drug use and many do not work the rest of the year, collecting welfare checks instead.

The Canadian seal massacres are the largest most savage extermination of wildlife in history. The cruelty is unspeakable and sickening, with scenes of mother seals screaming trying futilely to revive and protect their bloodied cubs from the relentless clubbers. That is why the European Parliament is banning the seal trade in all 27 member states, and why the US has banned it since 1974. An independent veterinary investigation revealed that 42% of the cubs were still conscious while they were being skinned alive. Europe has received 660 documented/filmed cruelty cases, including seals being skinned alive and large numbers of whitecoats illegally clubbed. Large numbers of maimed and wounded seals which escape to slip under the ice and die a slow death are never included in their kill counts.

Canadians are selfish and narrow-minded if they think an entire species or population of seal even belongs to Canada. Arctic seals are a world heritage and were here millions of years before Europe sent their ex-convicts and refugees to Canada and before those immigrants exterminated the real Canadians, the Beothuk Indians living on the East Coast. Those Indians had no effect on seals, and they would not agree with a greedy factory operation by a handful of thugs to slaughter millions of seals for the fashion industry in Asia. Canada's factory bloodbath on the ice has nothing to do with either native survival or "tradition".

0
I love turtles

Mark Donnors you are a nut!

Where did you get those facts? Paul Watsons personal account of NL history? If you are going to give a history lesson give it in its entirety. But alas.....the reality is more complex.

You prefer to distort, exaggerate, lie and spread hate. You spread hate and a distorted view of history to the uneducated and idiotic about  the whole population of NL. Despite the fact that less than 1% of its population engages in an activity YOU don't like.

Luckily most will look at your posts and see them for what they are: THE RAMBLINGS OF A SPITEFUL AND INSANE ANIMAL RIGHTS EXTREMIST

0
I love turtles

MarkDonners: By the way ,the seal hunt is not the largest slaughter of wildlife per year.

www.nafa.ca will show you this. 485,000 raccoon pelts are up for auction this May at the North American Fur Auctions to be held in Toronto. Amoung millions of other furs from other species. Seal is not on the list. What was this years seal quota: 280, 000. Do the math genius.

Oh Mark ,why don't you go to a real web site like Statistics Canada and find out about fur production by province and territory. You see, other provinces equal and surpass NL in  wild fur production. But hey, keep spreading the lies, slurs and stereotypes.

You are pathetic, I hope the thought of sealers keeps you awake at night.. LOL

Mark, make like the Donnor party.


This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

LotusFlower
First Flagged at 2:02 PM, Jan 11, 2008 by LotusFlower
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in Environment

 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from