NP Rank:
Earth's Coral Reef Catastrophe
Now Public Contributor E. Lizardo
August 14, 2008 4:20 PM
ARTICLE:
Corals and Geological History
We all know what ocean coral is. It's beautiful stuff. For many, when we see a specimen somewhere in a curio shop our first impulse is to examine it closely, touch it, handle it, observe it from all sides, feel it's weight and balance. Coral comes in many colors, shapes and sizes. 'Very Organic' is the way many would describe it, for indeed coral often brings to mind images of exotic vegetation, ferns and prehistoric plant life.
Without doubt ocean coral has been around a long, long time. Just how long seems to be a matter of some debate. The Global Coral Reef Alliance, certainly a credible organization, says the following
Reefs have been built over the last 500 million years by a variety of marine organisms ... Modern corals probably build the largest and fastest-growing reef structures in history because of the remarkable enhancement of skeleton growth caused by symbiotic algae ... After a period without reefs, modern corals and reefs spread. Over the last several million years oscillating ice age and non-ice-age conditions have caused ocean levels to swing up and down by 100 to 150 meters, forcing corals to migrate up and down in response.
Sounds to this writer as if the reefs have been with us several million years at least.
Catastrophe Theory
When the word 'catastrophe' is mentioned, as it has been in the title of this article for instance, people become concerned, and probably for good reason. Catastrophe, as defined in the dictionary implies some very negative connotations, up to and including sudden disaster. But the point of this article is not to instill fear and dread into the hearts of readers but rather to present a calm and rational review of the issues involved with the sudden decline of Earth's ocean corals. Hence, I now introduce a decidedly unemotional definition of catastrophe from the technical perspective
In mathematics, catastrophe theory is a branch of bifurcation theory in the study of dynamical systems ...
Bifurcation theory studies and classifies phenomena characterized by sudden shifts in behavior arising from small changes in circumstances, analysing how the qualitative nature of equation solutions depends on the parameters that appear in the equation. This may lead to sudden and dramatic changes, for example the unpredictable timing and magnitude of a landslide.
All dynamical systems follow trajectories, or paths through some space, in a manner of speaking. An example might be the trajectory of a light airplane as it flies through the sky overhead, sometimes moving in a straight line, sometimes banking either to the right or to the left, climbing up, descending, et cetera. Depending on the pilot's skill an observer might even be treated to the thrill of a well executed loop-de-loop, or some other amazing performance.
Technically speaking, as long as the airplane's position traces out a smooth trajectory which stays within certain boundaries it is considered to be in a stable orbit.
Of course the dynamical system in our example above is the airplane itself. At another level the system could be considered not only the airplane, but local atmospheric conditions, other entities in the immediate vacinity, even including the crowd on the ground watching below. To keep the presentation simple we have only focused in on the airplane itself, but the scope could be changed according to the requirements of the observer.
Bifurcation means to branch. A bifurcation in a stable orbit will cause the system to behave in very unpredictable ways. In the airplane example above such a bifurcation might occur after a very small change in fuel level when tank goes from being very nearly empty to completely empty ...
The Widespread Death of Earth's Ocean Corals
Fifteen years ago or so I recall hearing some seemingly unimportant news reports that a coral reef somewhere in the Carribean, for instance was suffering from the effects of too much tourism. I may have heard reports of a reef somewhere else which had been showing signs of poor health perhaps due to an increase in nearby industrial pollution. These reports mentioned something I had really never considered up to that point - ocean coral reefs are the rain forests, the breeding and feeding grounds of aquatic ocean species, the base of the pyrimid of our planet's salt-water ecosystems. I was reminded these reefs were more important than just interesting places to scuba dive, mere venues for finding souvenirs with which to stock the cabinets back at home.
That the ocean's coral reefs were more than just a bit ill here and there, and were actaully dying off en masse worldwide, I was not aware of until only a few years ago. Here's what one source had to say about the situation in 1998
Spatial and temporal range of coral reef bleaching
Mass coral moralities in coral reef ecosystems have been reported in all major reef provinces since the 1870s. The frequency and scale of bleaching disturbances has increased dramatically since the late 1970’s. This is possibly due to more observers and a greater interest in reporting in recent years. More than 60 coral reef bleaching events out of 105 mass coral moralities were reported between 1979-1990, compared with only three bleaching events among 63 mass coral moralities recorded during the preceding 103 years.
Nearly all of the world’s major coral reef regions (Caribbean/ western Atlantic, eastern Pacific, central and western Pacific, Indian Ocean, Arabian Gulf, Red Sea) experienced some degree of coral bleaching and mortality during the 1980s.
The following is from a more recent report published in 2003
Coral bleaching and mortality have steadily increased over the past 20 years. Coral bleaching occurs when the critical symbionts of corals become stressed and the symbiosis breaks down. Mass coral bleaching (global episodes) has not been reported prior to 1979.
What really got me thinking about all this was news on web-sites and in many papers this spring about the shocking disappearance of the west coast Salmon. In fact the situation is so severe that there was a total ban on salmon fishing imposed there this year.
All salmon fishing banned on West Coast
Friday, May 2, 2008Salmon fishing was banned along the West Coast for the first time in 160 years Thursday, a decision that is expected to have a devastating economic impact on fishermen, dozens of businesses, tourism and boating.
Commerce Secretary Carlos Gutierrez immediately declared a commercial fishery disaster, opening the door for Congress to appropriate money for anyone who will be economically harmed.
The closure of commercial and recreational fishing for chinook salmon in the ocean off California and most of Oregon was announced by the National Marine Fishery Service.
It followed the recommendation last month of the Pacific Fishery Management Council after the catastrophic disappearance of California's fabled fall run of the pink fish popularly known as king salmon.
It is the first total closure since commercial fishing started in the Bay Area in 1848. Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger declared a state of emergency last month and sent a letter to President Bush asking for his help in obtaining federal disaster assistance. Schwarzenegger plans to appropriate about $5.3 million for coastal salmon and steelhead fishery restoration projects.
Of course the west coast of North America also happens to be the east coast of the Pacific Ocean, the southern part of which was the location of quite a great deal of atmospheric nuclear weapons testing during the span of 35 years beginning in 1945 and continuing until its worldwide prohibition in 1980.
And, if all this is not bad enough, it now appears that the Great Barrier reef off the coast of Australia, in another southern ocean is experiencing it's own local catastrophe as well
'White syndrome' disease threatens Barrier Reef
Posted Tue Jun 17, 2008 1:48pm AEST
Updated Tue Jun 17, 2008 2:03pm AESTA coral disease known as 'white syndrome' is the latest threat to the Great Barrier Reef off Queensland's coast.An Australian Institute of Marine Science (AIMS) survey shows it is causing major damage near Cooktown, Cairns, Townsville and Rockhampton.
Dr Hugh Sweatman says coral disease is killing off areas that used to have the best coral cover on the Barrier Reef.
"In the last couple of years that's dropped by half and most of the coral that's been lost has been the species of coral that are susceptible to white syndrome," he said.
"For the first time we've seen what appears to be the negative effects of coral disease on the Great Barrier Reef."
Dr Sweatman says it appears to be spreading.
"There's been a lot of focus on coral disease in the world because in the Caribbean reefs, coral disease has been a very serious issue and has removed a lot of the coral," he said.
"This area that I'm talking about has had relatively high levels of white syndrome most of the time since we started surveying."
Implications
Many of the references I reviewed and even one of those cited for this article makes the case for the cause of impending coral reef extinction as being global warming. As cited above, corals have been with us for millions of years. During that very large span of time there has been a continuous cycle of ice-ages and subsequent thawings. The resultant cycles in water temperatures of plus or minus a few degrees celsius have never killed coral reefs off before. The only difference between those ancient times and now seems to be all that plutonium fallout from the weapons testing which now is in the water.
In summary I would offer my apologies for the unusual length of this article. People are quite busy and have little time left over for reading, especially when the subject matter is as unsettling as that presented here.
I hope this article was interesting and informative and has offered a ballanced view of the facts.
Dr. Thomas J. Goreau
After studying in Jamaican primary and secondary schools, he earned degrees in planetary physics at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, in planetary astronomy at the California Institute of Technology, and in biogeochemistry at Harvard University (Ph.D.)...
His current work focuses on coral reef restoration, fisheries restoration ... He was formerly Senior Scientific Affairs Officer at the United Nations Centre for Science and Technology for Development. He is currently President of the Global Coral Reef Alliance.
Crowd Power
-
peggy.
Palm Harbor, Florida, United States -
bluewavechris
Kihei, Maui, Hawaii, United States -
Aquatic_Explorer
Saint Petersburg, Florida, United States -
bluebluewater
Wynnum, Queensland, Australia -
Maireid Sullivan
Melbourne, Australia -
uusjio
Jakarta, DKI Jakarta, Indonesia -
ArneKuilman
Netherlands -
imung satriani
Jakarta, Indonesia -
CountryGuys
Witts Springs, Arkansas, United States -
whipartist
Oakland, California, United States -
rainejewel
Middlesex, New Jersey, United States -
waterdaughter
London, Ontario, Canada -
mattk1979
London, United Kingdom -
Brian Walsh
Reston, Virginia, United States -
BobHahnPhoto
Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, United States -
Karennnnn
Canada -
melonball6
Naples, Florida, United States -
foqus
Winter Park, Florida, United States -
Michael Doig
Brooklyn, New York, United States -
garywbecker
Madison, Wisconsin, United States -
gvmatera
Pelham, New York, United States -
rustyjd211
Wahiawa, Hawaii, United States -
russ_sexton
Toney, Alabama, United States -
hekkeller
Canada -
wildsingapore
Singapore, Singapore, Singapore -
ck.loveshorses
Southlake, Texas, United States -
delanedp
Sacramento, California, United States -
andythirlwell
Australia -
sweet east pearl
Jakarta, Indonesia -
Gareth Phillips
Australia -
honottnor
Norway -
krystof
Australia -
Mojo_89
Maldives -
Philippe Colling
Canada -
doommeer
Germany -
Señora Presidente
Old Saybrook, Connecticut, United States -
IslesPunkFan
Valley Stream, New York, United States -
evasionoftruth
Powhatan, Virginia, United States -
greengardn
Singapore -
rpointer00
Rocky Point, New York, United States -
kactusficus
France -
jill ee
Half Moon Bay, California, United States -
World Resources Institute.
Washington, District Of Columbia, United States -
Emilio Lizardo
Ann Arbor, Michigan, United States











Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (12)
at 13:02 on August 14th, 2008
In the 60's and 70's the Russian fishing fleet had an agreement to use our waters from 12 to 200 miles out. They dragged heavy nets with chains on the bottom to get all the fish off the bottom and also destroyed our seabeds. The government was fully aware and did nothing. Those nets were banned at the time by the UN.
at 15:28 on August 14th, 2008
Good point! Thanks for comment, Bill !
at 18:56 on August 14th, 2008
Thanks for GS, moonwolf!
at 01:54 on August 15th, 2008
Emilio Lizardo, I like this story. It's good stuff.
At the Tokyo University research is under way trying to save the Japanese Coral reefs and yet so far the results indicate that it does not look good and we may not be able to save the Coral reef any longer!
at 08:27 on August 15th, 2008
I looked around quite a bit - didn't find a single paper dealing with the possible effects of radioactive fallout on ocean corals ...
Just smells fishy to me, pardon the pun ...
at 08:53 on August 15th, 2008
I sort of missed this, so sorry. Our stories can link actually.
at 08:57 on August 15th, 2008
Thanks for flag, Tiha ...
All this 'linking' - is this an HTML thing or something more abstract ?
at 20:00 on August 15th, 2008
Both works E, (html and the abstract thingamabob) ;-)
at 11:00 on August 15th, 2008
Great information. I will share the story..thanks.
at 01:34 on August 16th, 2008
Good stuff.
at 03:34 on August 16th, 2008
Thanks for flag !
at 08:37 on August 16th, 2008
Informative n good read... Thanks for sharing!