NP Rank:
Hawaii SuperFerry Impact
For updated Hawaii Superferry information as well as heated forum discussions, go to Hawaii SuperFerry.
This last week protesters staged a traffic simulation showing just how congested the roads will be once the cars are unloaded. They proved that getting through Kahului may take over 2 hours. Right now you can drive through it in ten minutes. This will be an everyday occurance. And this was just demonstrating the Hawaii Superferry effect on Traffic when unloading. Ponder for a moment on what will happen to the rest of Maui. If you've ever driven to or from Lahaina during rush hour, you know it can be bad. One lane on each side can cause major delays, not including the accidents. You may think that Maui will compensate for the new influx of traffic by adding lanes to roads and new roads. But have you seen the roads to Lahaina and to Hana? It would take 20-25 years to build even one extra lane through the Pali and up to Lahaina. And that's Mainland time. Maui time will take closer to 35 years, without exaggeration. Plus, with the new construction that's going on in Olowalu, it looks as though they're clearing right up to the road. This road lines the ocean by mere feet; a new lane has no where to go.
Hana residents will remain Hana residence. This means they won't be able to get to the rest of the island without making it a 2 day excursion. With 250 new cars a day, the road to Hana will take twice as long if lucky. imagine the Road to Hana in stop and go traffic. The people of Hana already hate the tourists, and in turn causes them to close off their natural gems to the public. With all the congestion, they're going to get really upset. This could lead to violence and more of Hana being guarded from visitors.
Then there's the homeless problem. Yes, we have homeless living on our beaches, many with substance abuse problems. If you've been near one of their broken down car/tent shanties, you'll recognize the odors of makeshift bathrooms. This can't continue on our pristine beaches. With the Superferry bringing huge amounts of cars and people from all islands, and especially Oahu, how are we going to control the masses of homeless from taking over our beaches and making them into toilets. With the substance abuse comes crime and violence.
Drug trafficing will never be easier. Having an entire automobile to stash drugs will be easy considering the inspectors are projected to be having less than half a minute to inspect each car.
And what about the cars? We already have a major problem with abandoned cars littering our roadside. What's to stop people from other islands to come over, and leave them here? They can always jump back on the ferry on foot.
Then there's the environmental issues. Our mongoose on Maui have decimated the low nesting bird population. there will be little to no protection from them getting to the other islands. Not to mention the invasive species of plant life and other animal life like coqui frogs. And then there's the humback whale problem. The routes that the Super Ferry take are parallel or intersect the humpback migration routes. Even on the Hawaii Superferry website they show the routes as parallel from Oahu to Kauai and they intersect on the other islands. Even if they went completely different routes, their would be whale collisions. if you've been whale watching, you know that they're cruising around everywhere. They don't stay along the same narrow path. Whales come here to give birth, mate, and swim all around. If the Superferry disagrees with this notion, than take a look at the mother and calf that got lost up a river a couple weeks ago. These are huge mammals that travel all around the world and fuel our tourist industry. It'd be nice if we could continue to have them come here without being slaughtered. Seeing that at least one or two fatalities happen off of Maui per year, I can't imagine what this fast, huge Ferry will do.
The pollution will certainly also become a problem. It's a known fact that our Hawaiian sealife and reefs have decreased dramatically in the last 10-15 years because of human run off. Having hundreds of cars spilling their toxic fluids off the side of the Super Ferry will cause irrepairable damage. The SuperFerry itself will be unloading its own filth too. The vehicle oils will saturate all parts of the island from the ferry and from the roads.
On a positive note, it will bring us more business from the other islands. But then again, our island is doing fine as is. With over 2 million visitors to our island of Maui a year, our tourist trade is flourishing without the new ferry system. Actually it could cause more of a problem seeing that many of our visitors will likely rent a car and spend half their stay on another island.
That's about the only positive thinking I have on the Superferry situation, and even that is riddled with possible negatives. Even if the owners and operators of the Hawaii SuperFerry felt compelled to address these issues in full, the price of a ticket would be raised hundreds of dollars, and it would take 10 hours to get from island to island.
All of this coming from one of the most positive girls on island. I love Maui and all of our islands. This is a special place to live and/or visit. I wish what i've written was fabricated.
Even with all of its obvious impact, the Hawaii Superferry is scheduled to begin its routes later this summer. Looks like big money talks louder than logic.
Crowd Power
-
Robin Thom
Vancouver, Canada -
Kaitlin
Vancouver, Canada






Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (10)
at 13:50 on June 8th, 2007
jennyP123, thank you for posting this. I think we have our first Hawaii correspondent! Great work.
at 04:08 on July 12th, 2007
jennyP123, fascinating stuff - thanks so much for this.
at 17:09 on December 12th, 2007
Looks as though the Superferry is beginning service tomorrow. One of the latest problems is that with the protests, no one can surf Kahului Harbor anymore. This is one of the better spots on the North Shore of Maui. The drama continues.
at 17:10 on December 12th, 2007
Looks as though the Superferry is beginning service tomorrow. One of the latest problems is that with the protests, no one can surf Kahului Harbor anymore. This is one of the better spots on the North Shore of Maui. The drama continues.
at 17:10 on September 15th, 2008
I'm so glad to see somebody being concerned!
I just returned from Maui and can only say - I'm sure it was wonderful ... once.
There seemed to be not much concern for all the garbage on the side of the road, the rusting cars in the countryside, the wasted water (do hotels really need to water their properties for two hours every night??), almost non-existent recycling, adeqaute water treatment, etc.
Some of the snorkeling areas that were described as the best anywhere in several (older) books I had checked out of my library were almost dead, with lots of nasty brown algae.
I could see how beautiful the island is, underneath it all, but - as sadly almost everyhwere else - a lot of indifference was to be observed, by locals as well as guests. (Come on - you really need to have every item bagged in a single plastic bag or two?? At least my hotel provided a reusable shopping bag, for which I was thankful, because I didn't bring an own.) I think I will forfeit the next vacation and donate the money to the Pacific Whale Foundation instead. They were one of the few glimpses of hope for me on a vacation that was meant to relax me, in "paradise."
at 05:25 on March 26th, 2009
Looks as though the Hawaii Superferry had its last voyage on Thursday! The Hawaii Supreme Court finally stopped all the tom-foolery. See full article at:
Hawaii Superferry Dead
at 05:37 on March 26th, 2009
Thanks, Sam.
Maui is still an amazing place. You may have been looking in the "Too Touristy" areas. There are plenty of incredible reefs to snorkel, if you go to the right spots.
As for the water waste and trash, you're right to a point. The wasted water is a joke. The large resorts are not concerned about the water shortage, and government is short-sighted in allowing for huge growth in areas that are not prepared for it. As for the trash, it isn't as bad as some other resort destinations. I just got back from Indonesia. The locals don't care at all about trashing their country their. Relatively, Maui is ultra-clean.
Many locals are indifferent due to ignorance and lack of education. Though many locals care deeply for the island and put in much more of an effort than most mainland residents do for their own states.
As for forfeiting your next vacation: why?? There are plenty of groups that do volunteer vacations. You can come to Maui and help plant inidigenous plants on Kaholawe or help clean up areas (while meeting some amazing locals.) That would be more beneficial and fun than not coming. Also, think twice before tossing your money at the Pacific Whale Foundation. They do a great job as far as educating the public, but I think their "Non-Profit" is questionable. Plus, they're one of the few companies to strike and kill whales in the last few years.
Thanks, Sam. Don't give up on Maui!
at 13:30 on May 9th, 2009
I don't see what all the big fuss is about. For one, I don't really care if the people on any of these islands hate tourists. Tourists bring them money. If there weren't tourist there wouldn't even be a "paved" road to Hana, yet among other things. These ferries just provide a faster and more convenient method of travel. Yes, they go fast, because they can get from island to island in an efficient way. If they went slower, would that stop the complaints? Do you think if they just had a ferry that transported people instead of cars that would stop the complaints? I don't think so. It's more a situation of the locals not wanting a lot of tourists around, sharing the landscape, etc. I have to agree that having more cars can be a pain. Who likes traffic? But when it becomes a situation of someone not wanting more tourist on their land, tell them to take note from the Caribbean Islands. They profit from tourists and live amongst them just fine. It seems really stuck-up and self-centered for you people to deny ferry service so people can easily, and more excitedly enjoy all the islands.
at 13:08 on May 13th, 2009
You have some good points, Brice. But increased traffic isn't the only reason that I pointed out above. Whale killings are a major part of the issue as well as environmental impact. If you've gone snorkeling 10 years ago and again today, you'd see how we're destroying the reefs among other things.
I do agree, though, that general local sentiment towards tourists in Hawaii is all wrong. Other tourist locations that are just burgeoning around the world welcome tourism with open arms, warm genuine smiles, and much more aloha than the common local Hawaiian. Maybe that will change with the next generation, as it has with our latest Hawaiian generations.
at 18:42 on May 20th, 2009
Did someone who owns an airline write this?