Japan's environmental dilemma.

by Uwe Paschen | November 14, 2008 at 06:13 am
1769 views | 68 Recommendations | 35 comments

Photos

We aren't particularly worried about particulate pollution

We aren't particularly worried about particulate pollution

see larger image

uploaded by katakanadian

By, Uwe Paschen.

In Japan we do have an environmental dilemma of sorts.

We have laws and regulation in place here that are suppose to help the environment and some of those Laws are rather harsh and other are very good and appropriate. 

We do even have inspectors, an environmental Police of sorts that makes sure those laws and regulations are being followed and obeyed.

The dilemma though is that it does not work, or at least only in part. What works in the Cities may not work in the Country and vice versa.

The government has invested substantially in education, awareness program and Environmental self praising messages as well as recycling plants and collection facilities. All that sound and looks great at first, however it does have a great many flaws and makes the whole efforts almost point less and counter productive.

Some of those problems are small and could easily be rectified with minor changes or amendments to the existing Laws and regulation, That however can not happen, for two simple reason. 

One, our Government here is a minority Government that should call elections and so it is demanded by the opposition, however they do not for they still hope a miracle may happen and bring them back up in the polls, wish is rather unlikely since they keep on falling for now four consecutive years in row. This situation has paralysed the Government for now two years to the point that absolutely nothing is happening since the opposition does block every bill regardless of what it may be, the hole thing resembles more and more a farce and puppet show rather then responsible governing and wise politician being in charge.

The second problem are our Bureaucrats, here in Japan they are the real power and they are refereed to by as the new samurais of modern time, only no longer terrorizing every one with a sword they now do it with a pen in hand, and this very effectively and with great agility I may add.

One of the main problems this day that people complain about is the burning of plastic, wish is illegal here. However still practice to the point that it can at times suffocate you. 

In Cities this is mostly under control and does not happen any longer, since garbage has to be separated and is being collected weekly and because garbage fees are automatically deducted with the rent or the Condominium fees, so the problem is non existing in the large Cities due to sound policies and to many nabbers watching.

However in the country this is a totally different story, since people here are suppose to be more self reliable and responsible and bring their Garbage to the collection facilities and pay the fee there in accordance to the amount broth.

Why most Farmers here burn all the plastic they used on the fields for their potatoes and other vegetable in stead of recycling it. Now you may ask why not build in the fee directly into the purchasing price with an extra they would get back for each and every Kilogram of plastic they return. It would be a brilliant Idea and simple enough solution to fix the hole dilemma once and for all.

However this wont happen even though people complain about it and inspector tour the country site, yet those inspectors work 9 to 17 and only from Monday to Friday, this of course the Farmers do know as well and why the burning starts at 17 hours sharp and stops at about 6 in the morning and on weekends, well it goes on all day.

So until our Political crisis is resolved and the Bureaucrats become a wee bit more flexible we will have to put up with the plastic burning and may as well smoke our self to death for that would be healthier in a way.

It is to bad though that the Farmers and I am one my self can not be more conscious of them self, maybe it is because Money is involved and the fact that they wont see the harm they inflict not only on the environment at large, but directly to them self and especially to young children and elderly, since those are the once ending up in Hospital with major respiratory problems.

NHK, the Japanese main TV Channel here does only report the positive aspects of the environmental laws and the recycling plant not the fact that the law is not being followed because it has to many flaws.

How nice would it be if we where more responsible and did not need more government but could self regulate our selfs wisely, however this may just remain an illusion.  

Advertisement
recommend Sign In or Join to post comments
0
reno_fog

Great work... a necessary piece of work.  well done

3
Barbara McPherson

The burning of plastic is sometimes a problem here too.  There is little in the way of programs to recycle bailing twine or the big white plastic bags that hold the silage.  I think that a combination of education and recycling facilities would help our farmers a great deal.

0
Uwe Paschen

Thank you Barbara for the comment, Yes, the bail twine and silage bags are in the same  category. Thank you for bringing this up here.

1
Amy Judd

Great piece. It seems like Japan has a similarity to other countries and their environmental efforts - it is mostly a facade and while it all appears to be good; it's really not.

1
les

this may sound silly ,  anyway when i was a kid , i could get around 5p for returning a pop bottle back to the shop ,,,   subsiquently both myself and all my amegoes would go far and wide colecting pop bottles ,even in the small river near our den ,,,   so wy dont they have something similar for the plastic , and if they do it right  the kids would sort it all out ,,,,,,,,,   i dont advocate child labour ,,,,   but kids learning and having fun ,and doing some good and earning some pocket money is cool  ...   so imagin if their was a return price on the plastic .   and imagin being a kid ,   , , a cheaky kid ,, a good kid , ,, so are you going to stand by and watch as your adult nabours bur the plastic  ,  mmmm    grassing em up is wrong , burning it is wrong ,, but nickin the lot from em and colecting the monny from them .. , i could go on and on with the sanario but the point is this . if a similar idea is taken up . .    ,, as long as it dosnt turn man against man it cant be bad ....  and with some realy clever people in power over their your bound to come up with the answers , i wish you luck   ..........

0
okiokinl

photo taken in Osaka. not teh cleanest japanese city, but overall, japan is pretty clean, for sure when you compare it to other asian countries.

okiokinl has contributed a photo to this story.

0
158

Good article.,

1
TheJbot

Well done. Good luck.

TheJbot has contributed a photo to this story.

2
SOLARLIFE

The buraucrats replaced the sword by a pen. Not only valid for Japan. But already the japanese Miti innovation bureaucrats missed all great inventions. Thanks for Japan report

2
varmazis

It's amazing in a megalopolis like Tokyo that it's not MORE smoggy (like Hong Kong). I think it's a testament to Japan's environmental ethos that things aren't as bad as they could be. Still in this age of prevalent combustion engines and trash burning, the smog in Tokyo can be quite bad sometimes. On hot and hazy summer days, people with asthma can have serious problems (I lived with a host family whose son was asthmatic... days like this --photographed-- in Japan, the kid was in a lot of pain.)

varmazis has contributed a photo to this story.

1
hussain

Well done. I think most parts of Asia are facing some sort of environmental issues as well as lack of implementation of laws in this regard.

1
DiscoWeasel

Pic was taken near my house in Yokohama on a clear sunny afternoon.

Wonderful article. One thing should be noted though, "One of the main problems this day that people complain about is the burning of plastic." & "In Cities this is mostly under control and does not happen any longer, since garbage has to be separated and is being collected weekly"

While this is true, a friend who lives in Tokyo Ward told me that, just last month, he was notified that they should put plastic WITH burnable trash from now on. This is because "burnable" trash goes in a incinerator which doubles as a power plant. This is common practice throughout Japan. In Yokohama, my area anyway, we still seperate our trash between burnable and "plastics." But, in an "advanced urban area" like Tokyo it seems they've taken a step back in terms of policy.

0
Uwe Paschen

Thank you for the comment, I was not yet aware of this. I will have to look into it.

1
okiokinl

japan does make an effort, i think. the seperating of garbage everywhere is a god example yea. 

i travelled to taiwan after japan, and the difference was huge, taiwan is seriously polluted, sadly.. japans cities have exellent train systems, which helps a lot i think. in taiwan, the second largest city hardly even has a bus system, everybody drives scooter bikes. sometimes it was hard to breath... 

yet the near size of japan and its populaiton density, means that theres still lots of pollution. lets hope teh authorities will continue to work on it.





0
Uwe Paschen

Yes in deed okiokini, Japan does make many efforts and does invest as well, however some of those efforts are point less because the regulation or laws put in place have flaws as describe here in the above article for instance. Flaws I may add that could easily be rectified with some minor changes.  

1
A. Tran

It's a good article with thoughtful views.  

I would be interested to know how Japanese seafood industry balances between preservation of fisheries and a high demand of seafood consumption in Japan? It's a concern that Japanese whaling hunt remains an annual outing off the coast of Antarctica. 

0
Uwe Paschen

Good point Pythian1, Well Japan is rather woried about the fish stocks and does invest massively into research and preservation and well as into aid program to other Asian countries to stop or reduce their pollution of the sea and regulate the fishery.

Most problems today are not the over fishing it self, more so the way we fish, in rather wasteful and destructive way, if we could get all countries to obey by certain fishing methods we would save a great deal of the oceans Fish stocks.

1
mick62

This picture was taken in Ishikawa. It was enlarged and cropped to focus on the farmer. Outside the frame, in the background, is the Sea of Japan. The picture was taken at the side of a relatively busy highway. So the rice paddy is exposed to car exhaust. Along the highway are businesses. Ishikawa is rather rural but the urban areas are creeping in, just as they have in the larger Japanese cities. You can often see a rice paddy in the middle of an urban area, including residential and commercial areas.

mick62 has contributed a photo to this story.

1
mick62

Thanks Uwe for this great article. Thanks too to the people who added photos to the story. The photos really add to the story. I think though that I need to clarify something about the photos of Japanese wearing surgical masks. I think it's highly unlikely that these people are wearing the masks to protect themselves from pollution. Japanese wear these masks as a courtesy to others when they have a cold. Some who have pollen allergies wear the masks in spring. I have never met a Japanese who wore a mask to protect themselves from air pollution. I think that point needs to be made. The photos as they are now give the false impression that Japan is so polluted that Japanese must wera masks in order to cope. I have lived in Japan for nearly 12 years and I have never worn a mask. I live in Tokyo and the air quality is much better than other places I've been.

Having said all that, I very glad that Uwe has shed light on the issue and I learned a few things I didn't know before.

Cheers!


0
Uwe Paschen

Great Comment mick62, thank you. I glad you pointed out the surgical masks, They are in deed worn as a courtesy to others in flue season as well as allergy season and they would not protect one any how against air pollution.

The Plastic burning is a seasonal problem at harvest time, from October till December.

I just saw all the pics added my self and thank you to all for your generosity and for putting pictures up that go with the story. Many thanks in deed.

1
gerrypopplestone

Great work, Paschen!  Once people start discarding things so easily it is difficult to get them to act more responsibly!

0
Uwe Paschen

Very true Gerry! Very difficult in deed.

1
gerrypopplestone

What I say is:

Burn the bureaucrats!

1
angelica_77777777

Good Story!  And scary indeed!

0
clownhunter69

This photo was taken during one of the routine trips I made in a US Army UH-60A Blackhawk, between Zama and Yokohama, while I was stationed in Japan.

clownhunter69 has contributed a photo to this story.

0
Uwe Paschen

Thank you for addition of Pictures.

0
Donnoir

I took this photo while passing through Harajuku in March 2007.

Donnoir has contributed a photo to this story.

0
Uwe Paschen

Thank you for Pictures to all that have contributed some here on this story. Much appreciated.

0
jaylancast

Japan's dilemma is an issue in most modernized countries.  The cities do not allow burning of trash but it is still allowed in the country and small towns.  Thus creating pollution that blows into the city, adding to the automobile and factory pollution.  The inspectors should do their jobs in a "garbage truck" and collect the plastic from the farmers and people and reward them for their donation. Education is the key to successful change. 

0
Uwe Paschen

Thanks for the comment here, however the burning is not allowed in neither the City or the Country, it is taken place illegally.


What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

deleted_user_241632
First Flagged at 6:29 AM, Nov 14, 2008 by deleted_user_241632
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (68)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from