NP Rank:
Keep the Trees Green This Holiday
Over the years, I've used a variety of Christmas trees. My first tree in my apartment after college was a decorated plant. I had lots of plants at the time to fill an otherwise empty place.
Later I bought an artificial tree that could be put together, decorated, then broken down and stored for another year. I suppose that these trees can be considered green, although I am suspicious of their content. Do these Chinese-made trees contain lead?
As my apartment became an owned condo, I wanted a live tree. I would purchase a small cut tree, not much bigger than the one in Charlie's Brown Christmas. But it was mine and smelled heavenly. After the holidays, our city government collects the discarded trees and grinds them into mulch for trails in the city parks. This can be considered green.
One year, I rented a live tree. The tree was delivered in a container with all its roots intact. After the holidays, the leasing company picked it up. It was still live and still green. The cost was about the same as buying a cut tree at a tree stand. Plus the tree was still living. All was well except for the large amounts of sap that dripped from the tree onto the lights, ornaments and the carpet. Never again, my husband said.
Well, I kind of improvised on the above the following year and bought a tree with the roots intact with the promise to plant it after the holidays in the front yard of our new house. I argued that it would be a great tradition. My parents had often bought trees with roots, used them inside during the holidays, then planted them in the yard.
I kept an eye on the sap problem but found it difficult to plant the tree in the frozen front yard. I planted the tree too low in the ground, and it died ending my tradition of planting the holiday trees in the yard.
After a few years of cut trees that would be mulched after the holidays, we returned to artificial trees. Last year, I refused to put the tree together, as my husband had permitted me alone to put the artificial tree up, decorate and take it down. I found the metal irritating to my skin. Again, what do these trees contain?
Instead, we took all the lights and put them on living shrubs and trees in the front yard. Except for the electricity for the lights, we determined that this is very green. There is no gas involved in transporting the cut, live or artificial trees.
Crowd Power
-
Aoife city womanchile
New York, New York, United States -
cbcastro
San Francisco, California, United States -
naden
Minneapolis, Minnesota, United States -
milissas
Flemington, New Jersey, United States -
josiemitchell
Vancouver, Canada -
cebread
Pacific Palisades, California, United States -
pageypooh
Ann Arbor, Michigan, United States -
mudgirl66
Staunton, Virginia, United States -
Corinne S.
United States -
Flasher T
Estonia -
David Stephensen
Australia -
asia lundun
Chicago, Illinois, United States -
soopushie
East Lansing, Michigan, United States -
nismax95
Maryville, Tennessee, United States -
3Stavs
Falls Church, Virginia, United States -
relliKBORG
Bourbonnais, Illinois, United States -
allisonspicer
Brooklyn, New York, United States
Recommendations (44)
-
Karenke4
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada -
Jarrett Martineau
Vancouver, Canada
-
Amy Judd
Vancouver, Canada -
Uwe Paschen
Narita, Chiba, Japan -
Adam Purple
Portsmouth, New Hampshire, United States -
Rhonda J Mangus
North Tonawanda, New York, United States















Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (7)
at 15:59 on December 2nd, 2008
Great post. Choosing a 'green' tree is indeed a challenge. I didn't realize sap would be such a problem with a live tree!
at 18:07 on December 2nd, 2008
We got a cut tree this year, sorry to report, but thanks for using my photo. The year before the clay pot photo, we did get a live dwarf Alberta Spruce tree for our Christmas tree. I had hoped to keep it as a bonsai but it was not happy when the holidays were over and I moved it outside. It didn't survive to see another Christmas.
at 19:19 on December 2nd, 2008
Once, before we had our own tree, we wanted a live Christmas tree. We went to the nursery and asked if we could hire one. They said no, because they had no business system in place for that. If we bought one and were 'not satisfied' with it we could return it for a refund. We did exactly that. The tree graced our lounge room with decorations and then we returned it at the end of the week for a refund!
And for the rejuvenation story of our current one: http://www.flickr.com/photos/quarrion/76211009/in/set-1500043/
and thanks for using my photo!
at 20:31 on December 2nd, 2008
YEs that is what more and more are doing that have a yard or garden, however those that live in High rises and still want to decorate a tree for the season would have to do a lot more thinking. Unless they do not really care about environmental issues. I would not point the finger to China so quickly and reddely since China is not making all the Plastic trees the US are making about 25% of the World Plastic trees and lead is still used in some States in the US as well even though it is banned in most. and there is an FDA ban as well however reserves and stocks are still there in large amounts and are being used.
You can find some numbers and research on this earlier post about Christmas Trees here.
http://my.nowpublic.com/environment/christmas-tree-or-solstice-tree-and-environment
Good post. Thank you.
at 20:34 on December 2nd, 2008
My parents got a live tree (with roots) one year. We happened to have a pile of dirt in the yard for some reason and as a joke my mom planted the tree there. I survived for several years until something killed it.
We lived in the country and had a wood burning stove as out main souce of heat, so our used trees were firewood when we were done with them.
The photo you chose to include is my attempt at growing a tree. Bought a kit that included soil, seeds and the cute little pot. It's fun watching it grow.
at 19:24 on December 3rd, 2008
Living Christmas Tree...still in dirt. It will take up residence on our patio after the holidays
cebread has contributed a photo to this story.
at 01:03 on December 4th, 2008
Great piece!