Nanaimo Pushes Urban Sprawl To The Limits

by Barbara McPherson | September 9, 2008 at 11:06 am
461 views | 32 Recommendations | 4 comments

Photos

Nanaimo Pushes Urban Sprawl To The Limits

Nanaimo Pushes Urban Sprawl To The Limits

see larger image

uploaded by Barbara McPherson

Videos

Nanaimo Pushes Urban Sprawl To The Limits

see larger video

sourced by Barbara McPherson

Nanaimo Pushes Urban Sprawl To The Limits

My Opinion:Vancouver Island, Canada is an area of stunning natural beauty.

Unfortunately many who reside in Nanaimo take the gifts of nature for granted.  Land developers purchased a large tract of formerly forested land to subdivide and put in 2 hectare(5 acre approx.) lots.  Locals didn't oppose the move much but when the first plans were presented to the public, 20 story towers, a golf course, big shopping area and more than 1000 dwelling units were on the table.  That's when the controversy really started. Densification is the newest wisdom for helping preserve our increasingly fragile climate balance so what is the problem?  This tract of land is 17 km from the city centre.  It is surrounded by rural residential and agricultural  land. Some of this land is in a neighbouring jurisdiction and to accommodate the developers' plans, the City applied to annex  land because it wasn't zoned for dense development.  The people most affected by the annexation had no voice, but nearly 8 000 people who live in Nanaimo took the time to vote the annexation down. This area has no public transit and is unlikely to see any in the next few years.

 

Most climate scientists point to rising carbon-dioxide levels from burning coal, oil, and gas as the main driver behind global warming. But the international team says that fighting ozone, soot, and other pollutants, which also can warm the atmosphere, could allow CO2 levels to rise a little higher without reaching the tipping point.

"This is good news," notes Gavin Schmidt, a member of the research team and a scientist at NASA's Goddard Institute for Space Studies (GISS), in an e-mail. "There is scope for effective action, even though it will fall short of stopping human-caused climate change completely."

Yet this more comprehensive approach to curbing emissions is unlikely to remain an option for too long, according to James Hansen, a climate scientist also at GISS and lead author of the study. If global CO2 emissions continue on their current "business as usual" path for another 10 years, he notes, "it becomes impractical to achieve the alternative scenario." The business-as-usual approach allows too many fossil-fuel intensive power plants and factories to be built – investments designed to last for decades, he adds.

The notion of "dangerous" climate change is somewhat subjective, the team acknowledges. But looking back at climate patterns since the last warm spell – between ice ages more than 75,000 years ago – the researchers say patterns in the climate's actual behavior suggest that a change in global average temperatures higher than 1 degree Celsius above the level in 2000 would begin to push the climate into the "dangerous" category. That category involves changes, such as sea-level rise, that are outside the local range of experience, the study says.

Holding temperature increases to less than 1 degree over 2000 levels would be likely to hold global average temperatures at a level at least occasionally experienced today.

Such targets represent "advisory speed limits," according to Dr. Schmidt. But they come strongly advised: "What should be the target for mugging old ladies? You want to minimize the number, regardless."

So, it would seem that we do have some time to make changes.  The Nanaimo City Council held a public hearing this week to hear interested parties speak about rezoning this large tract of land to a resort designation.  As the following letter says it more eloquently than I, the speakers were divided along mainly two lines.  One impassioned speaker presented a different twist to the proposed Cable Bay Development.  She begged the developers to not put residential housing in the area because of probable pollution nasties -- methyl mercury, lead -- on the land from exposure to pulp mill discharges. (The mill is an old one and has since cleaned up a lot, but 50 years ago pollution was not relevant here.)

Re: 'Resort hearing draws big crowd' (Daily News, Sept. 5).

You report how Mayor Gary Korpan "made it clear council was only interested in genuine concerns about the land use application" and "the topic you're discussing is very important but that's not what we're here to talk about tonight, Korpan told Jordan Ellis".

Indeed, I was duly admonished by his worship.

Most of the 60 % or so who spoke in favour of Cable Bay addressed only the single issue of the possible economic benefits of such a development.

I was trying to speak to more global and frankly about more important issues concerning this development.

Apparently, the "100 months to tipping point" research was not on topic to the mayor. But, when considering such a project, what could be more important than the overall planetary issues of climate change and global warming and the concomitant ones of water shortage, food production, species extinction, etc. that globally face all of us? All political parties are beginning to give climate change some consideration. Civic government should be no less responsible.

Cable Bay may create significant greenhouse gas emissions, add a large "carbon footprint," deleteriously affect many local resources and impact the immediate local area and its present rural lifestyle of choice.

The city has, with this application a golden opportunity to demonstrate compassionate, understanding leadership to the world about how to handle such challenging global issues when local new development is proposed.

I guess I'll have to ask his worship when would be the right occasion to be allowed to express my opinion.

Jordan Ellis, Nanaimo

Monday night, the Mayor and Council passed their new Official Community Plan which pushes their Urban Containment Boundary to the city limits, opening up this former forest reserve land to intensive building.  It looks like business-as-usual in Nanaimo.  No development the city leaders didn't like.  It's not a coincidence that the statue gracing the harbour side park is one of a real estate developer clothed in a pirate suit.

Advertisement
recommend Sign In or Join to post comments
Amy Judd
Amy Judd
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 11:19 on September 9th, 2008

Barbara McPherson, I like this story. It's good stuff.

Great piece - I reaaly enjoyed reading it

travel_photography
travel_photography
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 15:17 on September 9th, 2008

Barbara McPherson, I like this story. It's good stuff.


We live another 4 hours further North - unfortunately the way you describe it is pretty typical for Vancouver Island, maybe even for BC. Most people don't care till it is too late.

Great that you post your opinion on this - maybe it wakes up some people for the future. WE DO HAVE A VOICE! But people have to use it too!!

Christina 123
Christina 123
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 15:27 on September 9th, 2008

Barbara McPherson, I like this story. It's good stuff.  Good investigative journalism!

Barry ORegan
Barry ORegan
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 04:54 on September 10th, 2008

Barbara McPherson, I like this story. It's good stuff.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Amy Judd
First Flagged at 11:19 AM, Sep 9, 2008 by Amy Judd
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in Environment

 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from