Organic Certified, Misleading labelling.

by Paschen | November 20, 2008 at 05:17 pm
983 views | 108 Recommendations | 65 comments

Photos

bluejeanorganic

bluejeanorganic

see larger image

uploaded by zarinmedia

By, Uwe Paschen.

Many of us do buy Organic Food, and many more Would like to, yet can not afford it. Sadly most of us do not actually know what Organic food is nor how it is regulated or where it does all come from and why should we have to either, should we not be able to trust the label? Sadly no. Now even though I support Organic Farming and practice it my self on our Farm, the reality of it all looks rather bad, since most off it is not much different then other foods that are not Organic certified. Why? Well, Organic Food products come from all over the Globe and are being shipped by Plane, Ship, Truck and Vans around the world. Yet we know little more about the Foods Origin and production, packaging and sale methods other then the fact it is labelled Organic-Certified.

For some reason consumers through out the World and especially the Industrialized World still trust the Organic Label with out ever questioning it nor even asking the obvious questions, such Who does actually control all this and what are the regulation...? Should we not be able to trust those labels? Unfortunately no.

For one, a big surprise it may be for some readers and consumers the fact that Organic does not mean, Pesticide Free, nor does it mean Herbicide Free or GMO free, or being used... Surprised? Organic certification of any product varies greatly not only from Country to Country, but also from one Province, State, Department or Prefecture to another one. To the point that what is permitted in Texas US, may be outlawed in California US and what may be Okay in Ontario is not so in Quebec, same for what is allowed in the US over all may be out lawed in China and so forth.

For instance some States and Provinces allow the use of up to 15% GMO products in any Organic cereal or other food and still be certified Organic and sold as such to the consumer. Some areas ask Farmers for buffer zones for Organically grown crops so they may not get contaminated by pesticides or GMO's, however other Areas do not care about that and do even allow Farmers to do both, GMO and Organic Beans side by side on the same farm and sale the lot as Organic.

It does get more interesting though, In Japan for instance, In the prefecture of Nagano Kent, farmers are allowed to use Herbicides yet not Pesticides on their organic Crops, where as in Chiba Prefecture Farmers are not allowed to use either for their Organic Crops. Not a Japanese problem alone, it is world wide, Quebec demands Buffer Zones and zero GMO cross contamination, where as Ontario allows GMO cross contamination for up to 15% and no buffer zones are needed. 

What does this mean? Well your Organic cereal is most likely no different or only little to none compared to the other none organic cereal, other then the price tag of course. If you add to this, transportation cost and pollution caused by the transportation then the Organic Rice or cereal you just both is actually in some cases worth then the generic or brand name product. This being said buying big brand food is usually the worth product. 

However the best way to go seems to be local food. It seems that buying locally does not  only make sense from and energy consumption point of view but it does seem to make Farmers and processors more responsible as well, since now their product is no longer shipped around the Globe to some stranger but rather to the next door nabber and who does want to harm or upset once nabber?

Some have been advocating this philosophy for some time now, such as Canada's David Suzuky, a well known environmentalist and Organic supporter, is now advocating to buy local rather then Organic for two main reasons as said earlier, one the productions certification is highly questionable and varies greatly from one place to another, even with in one Country and Two, buying Organic Potatoes from France in the USA or Organic Oranges from the USA in France does not make any sense at all and is environmentally counter productive for it causes great pollution to ship all this back and forth.

There for to buy Locally and better yet, skipping the middle man when ever you can and going directly to the Farmer seems to be the best and most responsible way to shop. At least then you know where your food really comes from and how it is produced.

recommend Add a comment
0
matte

organic is just a scam = lower production per hectare than by controlling weeds and pests using a few chemicals

0
Paschen

I see you do really know a lot about it. And sound science and facts wont help most likely to debate this here. Thanks for the visit matte, much appreciate.

0
matte

yes i work in ag science area and know that often organic production is in also all cases more environmentally unsustainable than using modern agricultural techniques.

Soil fertility decline is just one critical aspect. It is virtually impossible to get enough nutrient into the ground through mulching and spreading animal waste.

0
Paschen

Great matte, then you may be interested in this Post as well.

http://my.nowpublic.com/environment/farming-out-drugs-and-pesticides-possible

I have been doing this for a very long time and if you like we can debate this respectfully and based on Science and studies.

Thank you for the comment.

0
matte

I wish I had the time.


Organic might be possible for subsistence, but there are too many mouths to feed.....


0
Paschen

With our modern methods we fail to feed all people not because we could not do so, more so because of politics and restrictions. I read a some where on the UN web page how much food we waist for every house hold and how much raw food is being destroyed directly on the farm or collection facilities, in some cases just to maintain the prises due to our over production. We could feed another World with those amounts.

0
mofiac

In Canada, if the food grown does not look right in shape or color (carrot having second root, english cucumber not straight), then it is discarded. However, the nutrient content doesn't seem to matter......nor does the flavour.

0
poolparty

Great post Paschen!

0
Paschen

Thank you for the visit here and comment, Much appreciated.

1
amyjudd

Very interesting - I had no idea about half of this. I try to buy organic whenever I can, but sometimes it is too expensive for me. Maybe I need to ask for a pay raise... ;)

0
moonwolf

Shhhh!  The "boss" might be listening! (:D)

0
amyjudd

You're right - I take that back... :)

0
Paschen

Thank you Amy, Very much appreciated and yes it is in a way a scam and miss leading consumers as well as stealing money from consumers since we know people try to do their best and it is being exploited shamelessly.

1
moonwolf

Once upon a time I used to buy anything marked "Organic" with complete faith that I was buying what I naively believed with complete faith to be truly natural foods grown like they were 200 years ago.

I was wrong then, and now buying food has become a nightmare of research to try and discern through the veil of smoke and mirrors what is even close to "Organic"!


0
Paschen

So did I Wolf, in a way it is frustrating that we have to and can no longer trust any think nor believe any label any longer. It is in a way a crime and steeling from people by using their good faith and good intentions to make a high profit by selling us snake oil rather then what we are actually paying for.

0
pinkberry143

I agree to you with the fear of buying marked "ORGANIC" when its not really "ORGANIC" but in our area, farmers when they mean organic, its really mean pesticide free but costs much higher because its production is limited..^^

When its freshly harvested and unprocessed, its really clean but it varies with the method of handling and distributions to the local markets.. some sprays something to stay fresh for hours till it reach the destination, and then it will be packed somehow but it will be sealed with another artificial substance to make it look good...

JUST like TUNA ( another example..^^) from the fishing boat, it will be freshly catch, then to the plant where it will be prepared for packing.. but there are two method, for US EXPORT GRADE, before it will be packed, they will spray a "SMOKE" -US patented, to make it look great and fresh for JAPAN and KOREA, its prohibited to use that "SMOKE" because it may contaminate the meat of the fish...

0
Rhonda J Mangus

Very interesting, Paschen! Thanks!

0
Paschen

Thank you Rhonda. Much appreciated.

1
Panoctopi

Are you referencing the lack of a global 'Organic' standard?  My understanding is that 'Organic' in the U.S. has very specific standards, regarding the growth of produce, raising cattle, as well as 'processed' foods. 

Care to comment about the USDA standards for 'Organic' passed in 2002 (I think that's the righ year)?



0
Paschen

There is a and are standards with in each and every country as well as state or Provinces, however their are variable and no uniformity, we do not have international standards nor do we have sound controls of the existing standards. If a product is certified in one place and then sold to another place where it is mixed with another product that was certified as well yet some where else and then sold to the consumer in yet another State, Country or province where yet other standards apply the consumer has no idea any longer nor can verify if this product he just bot is actually Organic or just certified Organic yet contains GMO and may be produced in a way he or she would not realize nor assume. 

In some cases By laws have been passed or amendment to allowing up to 15% GMO to the existing regulations. This the consumer does not know nor realize and is there for miss lead and in a way it is fraudulent, there for criminal. Yet legal.

0
Panoctopi

Indeed, there should be more uniform global standards and greater accountability in the accreditation process.  Still, I find that the current situation (at least in the U.S.) isn't completely useless, and I would make the point that though it make have its flaws it still serves to deliver what it promises in the majority of the cases.  But sure, unfortunately as greater and bigger corporate entities become involved in this process, it becomes more difficult to uphold the current standards, much less improve them.  More than likely we will have to focus on fighting the battle on not allowing any further loosening of the current standards.



1
sara star

Thanks for the wake up call. It makes sense. Locally grown is something to consider. Like the 100 mile diet.

0
Paschen

I think this was started in the UK in the 80th if i recall this correctly, It is actually a great Idea and well worth practising. It does pay off to since we get to know the people that do the work and produce the product. I do this when ever I can for all things even the Mechanic or parts and when ever possible. Thank you Sara for the Visit and comment.

1
Jarrett Martineau

Great post, Paschen. You're absolutely right, there is simply no global consensus on standards for organic products — and local food, if it's available, does appear to be the best option in terms of health and environmental benefits.

0
Paschen

That is a good way to practice it, I think, When ever available affordable and doable. Thank you Jarrett for the visit and comment here.


1
rumana husain

my son and daughter-in-law are partial to organic and are looking for organic foods here in china too. i also supported the idea...that is until i read your post paschen. thanks.

0
Paschen

Thank you for the visit and comment here Rumana I do appreciate it.

1
Emilio Lizardo

If you want it done right you gotta do it yourself !

0
Paschen

Seem to be true in this case, sadly so though. Thank you for the read and comment here Emilio.

0
Barbara McPherson

Thanks for alerting people.  My faith in the organic label was shaken this year when I found garlic from China labelled organic.  I can't believe that their organic is my organic -- pesticide, herbicide, fungicide, air pollution free produce and animals. We joke that we try the hundred foot diet.  That's the distance from the house to our garden.

Add a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Crowd Power

poolparty
First Flagged at 5:41 PM, Nov 20, 2008 by poolparty
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (108)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from