Sea eagles are not eating lambs

by amyjudd | September 24, 2008 at 09:34 am
789 views | 9 Recommendations | 8 comments

Photos

White tailed Sea Eagle

White tailed Sea Eagle

see larger image

uploaded by Mull birds

As reported yesterday, sea eagles are being blamed for the death of about 200 lambs in the Scottish Highlands.

However, a furious argument has now broken out between crofters and the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds after the society has said the claims are rubbish that eagles are killing lambs.

The farmers want something to be done about it.

They claim that in the past few weeks hundreds of lambs have been killed by the birds, which are being reintroduced gradually to the country after being hunted to extinction in Britain in 1918.

The group of about 30 crofters in Gairloch in Wester Ross claim that their livelihood is being jeopardised by the loss of lambs before the autumn sales.

“It is not viable, with these losses. We can’t see a future in this area with the sheep if the birds keep killing lambs,” said Willie Fraser, chairman of Gairloch and Poolewe branch of the Crofting Foundation. “We’ve seen lambs — strong, heavy animals — that have been caught by sea eagles, caught by their necks and their arteries cut so that they can’t lift their heads. One crofter has lost 50 per cent of her lambs.”

One woman had even seen an eagle killing a lamb, Mr Fraser said. “When she went up towards it, it flew off. But later, when she went back to the field, she saw the bird on top of the lamb.”

He said that vets had examined the lambs’ carcasses and reportedly found talon damage and injuries caused by being dropped from a height. Another crofter described going close to a sea eagle’s nest and finding what he described as a sheep’s graveyard.

The Royal Society for the Protection of Birds described the claims of some crofters as nonsense and said that the birds would have taken only carrion. It said that the birds thrived mainly on a diet of herring gulls, fulmars and fish fed to them by friendly trawlermen.


The debate goes on as the farmers are saying that the RSPB are not seeing them taking the lambs - they are just seeing the carcasses in the nests and that is not a good enough study.

recommend This comment thread is now closed
1
RickH54

This was shot taken on the Derwent River Tasmania during a cruise to Peppermint Bay

RickH54 has contributed a photo to this story.

theunderminer
theunderminer
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 14:29 on September 24th, 2008

amyjudd, save the lambs from the seagulls! Oh, wait...the sea eagles...

0
kenbray54

homer alaska on mud bay

kenbray54 has contributed a photo to this story.

0
catchapman

This is Nikita who is a Steller's Sea Eagle and I took this shot at the Brent Countryside Day which was held on the 21st September 2008. Nikita was stunning and extremely large she certainly gave the crows and the pigeons a bit of a scare! http://www.hawkexperience.co.uk/

catchapman has contributed a photo to this story.

Paschen
Paschen
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 04:39 on September 26th, 2008

amyjudd, I like this story. It's good stuff.

If the Sea Eagle would take the lambs, it would not leave carcasses in there nest nor carry them up there other then meat it self. They are rather good house keeper.

0
TheApertureMan

Sea Eagles are beautiful majestic birds and their re-introduction into Scotland can only be seen as positive.

There will always be protestors, its human nature and certain groups always seem to like complaining, but the RSPB needs to stand their ground on this one. Birds od Prey are an integral part of the food chain, and like the RSPB say they eat carrion.

I think the Crofters sound like British Farmers in that they are always looking for ways to get government subsidies, due to their hard way of life.

I for one am glad to see the eagles flying free in the wild and long may it continue.

TheApertureMan has contributed a photo to this story.

0
Jon Loreche

This is a White-bellied Sea Eagle, locally known as Manaol in the Philippines. I took this photo while visiting Crocolandia, a nature park in Talisay City, Cebu.

Jon Loreche has contributed a photo to this story.

panzerlawyer
panzerlawyer
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 18:39 on September 28th, 2008

amyjudd, I like this story. It's good stuff.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

theunderminer
First Flagged at 2:29 PM, Sep 24, 2008 by theunderminer
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in Environment

 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from