Sewage Sludge On Farmland Can Make You Sick

by Barbara McPherson | September 11, 2008 at 10:30 am
467 views | 0 Recommendations | 2 comments

Videos

Sludge water running

see larger video

sourced by Barbara McPherson

Sludge water running

This is an important topic and I'm pleased to see more awareness of it.  It's not without pitfalls and much of Europe is banning the spread of sludge or  the better sounding "biosolids" on farmland.

Farm Sewage Sludge a Health Threat

Sun Aug 4, 7:05 PM ET

SUNDAY, Aug. 4(HealthScoutNews) -- You may be anything but flush with health if you live near farm fields fertilized with sewage sludge.

Burning and irritated eyes and lungs, skin rashes and other illnesses are among the problems experienced by residents of homes close to land where Class B biosolids -- a byproduct of the human waste treatment process -- are applied, says a recently published University of Georgia study.

The study included 54 people living near 10 biosolid application sites in Alabama, California, Florida, New Hampshire, Pennsylvania, Texas and the province of Ontario in Canada.

Many of the residents had Staphylococcus aureus infections on the skinand in their respiratory tracts. About 25 percent of the people in the study were infected, and two died as the result of septicemia and pneumonia. S. aureus is commonly found in the lower human colon.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency doesn't consider S. aureus to be a significant public health risk, even though it's the leading cause of hospital-acquired infections and is commonly found in sewage, says study co-author David Lewis, a research microbiologist at the university.

Lewis says that chemicals are added when the sludge is being processed. These chemicals can irritate the skin and respiratory tract and make people more susceptible to infection, he said.

In a recent report about biosolids, the National Research Council of the National Academy of Sciences concluded the use of processed sewage sludge as a commercial fertilizer may be a public health risk.

Along with pathogens, sewage sludge can contain household chemicals,heavy metals, pesticides, and synthetic hormones from birth control pills and dioxins.

The disposal of sewage sludge after the wastewater is removed is a big problem.  It sounds like a win win situation to spread it on farmland because it is full of nutrients.  Unfortunately, it often comes packed with less desireable items.

As we saw last week, sewage sludge is the mud-like material that
remains after bacteria have digested the human wastes that flow
from your toilet into your local sewage treatment plant. If
human wastes were the only substances entering the sewage
treatment plant, then sewage sludge would contain only nutrients
and should be returned to the land.

Unfortunately, most sewage treatment plants receive industrial
toxic wastes, which are then mixed with the human wastes,
creating a poorly-understood mixture of nutrients and industrial
poisons. Furthermore, many American cities have built sewage
systems that mix storm water runoff with the regular sewage;
every time a rain storm scours these cities' streets, additional
toxins are added to the sewage sludge.

As a result, sewage sludge contains a strange brew of nutrients
laced with low levels of PCBs [polychlorinated biphenyls];
dioxins and furans; chlorinated pesticides [such as DDT, DDD,
DDE, dieldrin, aldrin, endrin, chlordane, heptachlor, lindane,
mirex, kepone, 2,4,5-T, and 2,4-D]; carcinogenic polynuclear
aromatic hydrocarbons [PAHs]; heavy metals [arsenic, mercury,
lead, selenium, cadmium, etc.]; bacteria, viruses, parasitic
worms, and fungi;[1] industrial solvents; asbestos; petroleum
products, and on and on. American industry uses roughly 70,000
different chemicals and any of these can be found in sewage
sludge --depending on who's pouring what down the drain at any
given time and place. In addition to the original chemicals,
unique metabolites and degradation products develop anew in
sludge. To give but one example: trimethylamine can be converted
to the powerful carcinogen, dimethylnitrosamine.[2]
Now if you've got a super duper sewage treatment plant, you can be pretty sure that the bacteria have been killed.  You can't be so sure about the myriad chemicals that are in the mix.  Don't hold China up as a shining example of recycling poop.  Their rate of Hep A is astronomical.

recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
gerrypopplestone

But anyone knows that merely removing the waste water is irresponsible and not accepted professional practice.  I'm not sure whether that is all that is done usually in the US.  I greatly doubt it!  in Europe the sludge gets heated at a very high temperature to kill off the toxins.  I would have thought that was what is done in the US.

0
Barbara McPherson

I think Europe must be far ahead of N. America in dealing with sewage.  Most of the treatment plants, where there is treatment at all breaks up the bits, chlorinates the rest and sends it to a settling pond for bacteria to break down the muck.  Most of the city sewage systems mix residential and industrial wastes as well.  This is where many of the real nasty chemicals come in and are not removed.  I looked at a Scottish e-site and it mentioned restrictions on crops to be grown where sludge is a fertilizer. I guess, and I'm only guessing that those would be leafy veggies that would normally be eaten raw.  You may recall the big recall of tomatoes and peppers in N. America this spring because of bacterial contamination.  The peppers from Mexico, were eventually named the culprit but not before millions of dollars were lost in destroyed tomatoes.  I'm thinking that in light of the huge meat and cheese recalls going on currently in Canada that we have to be really, really vigilant about our food supply as it becomes more centralized.  Your regulations in Britain may be world class, but most of the world hasn't caught up to that standard yet.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in Environment

 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from