Spain approves 'human rights' for apes

by julianw | June 26, 2008 at 09:56 am
538 views | 10 Recommendations | 1 comment

Photos

Bali Monkeys

Bali Monkeys

see larger image

uploaded by NP_1_740623

In a resolution passed earlier today, the Spanish parliament gave basic "human rights" to all of the species in the Great ape family.

Great apes should have the right to life and freedom, according to a resolution passed in the Spanish parliament, in what could become landmark legislation to enshrine human rights for chimpanzees, gorillas, orang-utans and bonobos.

The environmental committee in the Spanish parliament has approved resolutions urging the country to comply with the Great Apes Project, founded in 1993, which argues that "non-human hominids" should enjoy the right to life, freedom and not to be tortured.

Ape-rights have been a popular conversation topic in the blogosphere, and responses to Spain's decision are wide ranging. Over at "A Catholic View" (A Secular World, A Catholic Perspective), bloggers are shocked and appalled:
Please tell me I didn't read this. Please tell me that Spain, who recently liberalized their abortion rights (except, of course, the baby's rights) to kill unborn human babies, is actually going to put an ape on the same level as humans, and give them rights that are denied to HUMAN babies...
R.W. Ridely has some interesting philosophical thoughts:

’m not necessarily against this, but it rings kind of hollow when they won’t be releasing Apes from the 70 or so zoos in Spain. Kind of goes against the whole “freedom” thing. And since when do humans have the power to grant “life.” Isn’t that really a function of nature and the universe?
Folks at "The Virtuous Republic" are angry about life:
In the U.S., currently the left cares more about “mother earth” than they do about human suffering. Thus their opposition to more oil drilling and the exploitation of oil shale.

But in Spain, the left has gone one step further. The Spanish parliament is about to extended human rights to great apes.

What is somewhat humorous, is that the same leftist government wasn’t too concerned with the “human rights” of Iraqis when it ran like scared little girls from Iraq. Once again, the left cares more about everything else than they do about you.

Don’t get me wrong, I don’t want to see the great Apes wiped out. Protect their habitat, ban the use of their body parts for tribal medicines, but give them human rights?

And Paul Pardi at the "Philosophy News" is troubled:
I have two thoughts on this. The first is that while I’m all for measures to prevent torture of any kind–anyone who finds joy in torture where the pain and suffering of some other creature is the only end is deeply disturbed and should be dealt with (though I’ll admit I’m not prepared to answer how)–I fear the result of this measure will do less to increase the value of apes and do more to devalue human life.

Second, I’ve held that the theory of evolution ought to have an impact on our ethics. I’m setting aside here whether that impact will be for the positive or negative. I’m claiming only that it ought to influence the way we do our ethics. When I’ve mentioned this to colleagues, I’ve been resoundly rebuffed time after time. “Evolution says nothing about how we ought to behave” is the claim. I strongly disagree. This move tends to support the position that, like it or not, belief in evolution does in fact impact the way we think about the ethics of ourselves and other biological life forms.

Advertisement
recommend This comment thread is now closed
Uwe Paschen
Uwe Paschen
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 23:59 on July 10th, 2008

julianw, I like this story. It's good stuff. Hum!!

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

NowPublic on Facebook

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Uwe Paschen
First Flagged at 11:59 PM, Jul 10, 2008 by Uwe Paschen
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in Environment

 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from