Facebook acknowledges Arab LBTG ban hoax

by Kaitlin | May 1, 2007 at 09:43 am
2144 views | 10 Recommendations | 4 comments

Photos

Arab LBGT Facebook page

Arab LBGT Facebook page

see larger image

uploaded by Kaitlin

UPDATE 3:12pm: I have just spoken with the Admin of the Arab LBTG group, and she cleared up what happened. In essence, it boils down to good(ish) intentions gone wrong--the faux Facebook employee was trying to prevent Saudi Arabia from blocking Facebook by getting rid of the group. Our own Actual News Guy calls it a classic agent provocateur move...with a twist:

"Adminstrator josh" provided us with a petition forum that was meant to increase the number of petitioners to prevent saudi arabia from blocking facebook's server. I belive this "adminstrator josh" thought that this group's presense would increase the chance of saudi arabia blocking facebook server by june. And therefore this hoax was extended a week long since facebook did not complete the investigation till yesterday. Again, i am asked by facebook to clear any misrepresntation and i would like if u would state in the article that boing boing article was misinformation. Since the author did not infrom the reader of the real problem and misread the group's infromation provided.

UPDATE 10:13am: Boing Boing has pulled the story from their main page...perhaps because they discovered the hoax?

Yesterday Boing Boing reported on Facebook's apparent shutdown of an Arab LBTG (Lesbian, Bisexual, Trangendered and Gay) group. Apparently a Facebook employee going by "Adminstrator Josh" contacted the groups' admins and requested the group be removed in order to comply with requests from nations like Saudi Arabia and Egypt who cited the group's affront of Islam. When the group didn't reply, Facebook reportedly shut it down on their own.

Facebook bowing to a government's request? Sounds awfully like Google and the Chinese gov't, doesn't it? Yep. Except, not really, because it was a hoax:

Dear members:

I am here to deliver news that is actually amazing in one way, but upsetting for me and has put me in a state of awe. I would like to first thank you all for ur infinite support, for this group.

It has proven to us that we can all come together, and build a community that can conquore any act of opression that impedes our free speech. Many have been asking for verification of the violation of terms that we received from "adminstartor josh." Contacting facebook long ago, they finally replied to me with a conclusive investigational report saying that this account is in no way affiliated with the facebook team. Therefore,' we have been fooled and duped by this certain invidiudal(or individuals).

So apparently the request that supposedly came from Facebook higher ups was just from some dude with a desire to vanquish a group that threatened his (or her) sensibilities in some way. Facebook has issued a statement to Arab LBTG's petition group explaining what happened:



It appears that you have been contacted by a user with the name"Adminstrator Josh" about a group you created on our site. This person was posing as a Facebook employee and is in no way affiliated with the company.

We have not been contacted by any governments about your group, and we will not remove it unless it violates one of our standard guidelines for abuse on
the site, which it appears it does not.


We have disabled the account of the person who contacted you. In addition,however, we ask that you issue a retraction on the page for your group "The
official Petition to prevent Arab LBTG from being shut down" and remove anycontent from the group or your profile that misrepresents Facebook in any way. Thanks in advance for your understanding and cooperation on this, and please let me know if you have any questions.


I have some questions, Facebook. Boing Boing reported that you shut the group down, but if Facebook didn't send the warning, who shut it down? (There is currently no Arab LBTG group, just the petition page.) Also, as a Facebook user I'm concerned about this...can anyone impersonate a Facebook employee? Could I be duped into giving away info I don't want to give away? What's Facebook's process for handling things like this? I'll keep investigating and update the story as I find out more...



recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
Kaitlin

Kaitlin, thanks for getting this story out so quickly. It will now show up on the home page for four hours. If new developments justify it, I'll renew this flag for another cycle.

0
babblingdweeb

Kaitlin, thanks for updating us and breaking the story! At least the story has a positive twst.

babblingdweeb
babblingdweeb
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 14:34 on May 1st, 2007

Good stuff! Good scoop on facebook!

0
Delphinna

GOOD SCOOP !!!

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from