Big Pharm Funding Anti-E-Cigarette Campaigners

by inijames | March 26, 2009 at 05:16 am
1197 views | 32 Recommendations | 9 comments

A coalition of public health campaigners are asking the FDA to remove the Electronic Cigarette from US shop shelves.

They all have one thing in common - funding from the big drug companies whose nicotine replacement therapies, with their side effects and low success rates, are under threat from the new drug.

Senator Lautenberg, who wrote to the FDA demanding that the device be removed from shelves, received $126,000 in funding from the pharmecutical companies during his election campaign.

And members of an anti e-smoking coalition who have issued a press release in support of the senator have also received millions in funds from the pharmecutical industry, much of it from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, a foundation with  shares in Johnson and Johnson worth over 700 million dollars.

The money was originally paid to the organisations such as the American Lung Association to lobby against smoking and smokers and for a smoking ban, and it is not clear if there is also pressure to lobby against the electronic cigarette.

What is clear is that the industry is watching the electronic cigarette closely, with a section in one industry report entitled: E-Cigarettes Will Revolutionise the Face of Tobacco Smoking and Could Pose a Threat to the Smoking Cessation Market.

As most attempts to quit using cessation aids fail - according to Michael Siegel, proffessor of professor in the Social and Behavioral Sciences Department, Boston University School of Public Health, the success rate is less than ten percent - the $3 billion market in cessation aids is vulnerable to new and safer smoking alternatives. 

And with those who claim to care about smokers' health lobbying against a safer alternative to a habit that kills 1 in 2 of long term smokers, the motivation of public health campaigners is bound to fall under suspicion.

recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
sara star

Thanks for bringing this up.

FDA officials have been quoted numerous times in many publications during the past few weeks saying that e-cigarettes are "new drugs," which require prior approval from the FDA before they are allowed to be sold. Without this approval, e-cigarettes are illegal to market or sell. Despite these statements, no action has been taken to remove e-cigarettes from the market.

0
sara star

 So kids can buy this?

  E-cigarettes are also being marketed towards young people, who can purchase them in fruit flavors and online, without having to verify their ages.

2
Jean Rasbridge

I am a supplier and I would like you to look at our site, http://www.ecigarettedirect.co.uk - we have no intention of targeting young people - our market is the unfortunate smoker who cannot smoke in his local pub or at work, or who neither wishes to  pollute the atmosphere in his home, nor inflict passive smoking on those around him.

 

Reports to date have shown that the e cigarette is far less harmful than a tobacco product, - see Dr. Laugessen's assessment from Health New Zealand, and the comments of the Tobacco Harm Reduction department at the University of Alberta amongst others.  Where is the evidence that this is more dangerous than a cup of coffee?

1
inijames

 So kids can buy this?

If a child had a credit card and sufficient funds and were willing to break the law! Children generally manage to get their hands on most things they want, and most smokers start when they are underage. When I was growing up young teenagers smoked, drank and took drugs - rules and regulations never stop that. Part of the allure is that it is forbidden/dangerous/illegal/rebellion. All of which hardly provides sufficient cause to ban the e-cigarette. If you have the kind of child who is going to break the law and smoke addictive substances, at least they are smoking something which has had all but one of its harmful substances removed rather than something which will kill one in two of its users.


3
Abigail Harman

E-cigarettes are an ingenious solution to people who are completely addicted to cigarette smoking and would like to smoke in pubs while having a relaxing drink without inflicting obnoxious fumes on others. It would be good to try the e-cigarette before condemning it.

2
John H

It looks and feels like a real cigarette.

The electronic cigarette a revolutionary device that acts much the same way an ordinary tobacco cigarette would, but rather than toxic smoke, it produces vapor. The e-cigarette is all the fun of nicotine without the toxins found in tobacco cigarettes. At last you can quit inhaling tar and other noxious substances yet keep the satisfaction of smoking. The 'smoke' is completely odourless and evaporates quickly in the air.

It's good to have choice.

0
Marlin

    Money is why they are attacking e cigarettes, nothing more. I am a retailer, and user of the e cig, and have tried for 20 years out of the 25 I have smoked to quit, and this is the only thing that helps, I have been smoke free for almost 75 days now. It really does help you quit no matter what they say, and obviously they "Know" it also because of this statement :

What is clear is that the industry is watching the electronic cigarette closely, with a section in one industry report entitled: E-Cigarettes Will Revolutionise the Face of Tobacco Smoking and Could Pose a Threat to the Smoking Cessation Market.

 

That is proof in itself that we are dealing with criminals that would rather get their 3 billion a year and let 30 million smokers die in the US on this day (more as time goes on). This is a criminal act and agenda that makes Hitler look like Mary Poppins, and George Bush as Innocent as a newborn!

0
dinocione

Well Marlin, as a retailer, how is business ?

Do you think that these poor addicted smokers are getting a good deal when they buy these e-cigs ?  How about the longevity of the parts ? 

How long do batteries last ?  How about atomizers ?   What's the mark up ? What about all of the defective parts and cartridges that are sold ? Do you think $79, which is pretty cheap,  plus postage is a fair price for a starter kit ? 

0
Marlinj

Yes I do believe they are better off, it cuts their smoking expenses in half, defective parts are replaces, and even after a year, they will be cutting the cost in half at normal parts replacements.

 

Not only that, there are several levels of nicotine, and you can gradually ween yourself down to ZERO~

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

sara star
First Flagged at 6:41 AM, Mar 26, 2009 by sara star

Related Stories

Recommendations (32)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from