NP Rank:
Canadian healthcare killed Natasha Richardson?: NEW YORK POST!
Barry Artiste Op.Ed
Well isn't this a Kick in the Slats for Canada, when those in the US who are anti Canadian Healthcare publish Fear Mongering to the Masses slandering Canadian Healthcare which is one of the best in the world. Point being, Ms. Richardson refuses medical treatment, plain and simple. If she has listened to those who tried to help her, we would not be having this conversation, because Ms. Richardson would have been alive. Goes to show whose bread the New York Post is buttered on The Medical and Pharamceutical Establishment. Wonder what Michael Moore would have to say about this? Or even President Obama. One thing for sure it will be interesting to read Readers Comments from the New York Post!
MONTREAL — Some Montreal doctors added a dose of realism Saturday to the fiery debate south of the border that asked if Canada’s “socialized medicine” killed actress Natasha Richardson after she hit her head skiing on Mont Tremblant March 16.
“Canadacare may have killed Natasha,” screamed a headline in the New York Post. “Was Canada’s healthcare the problem?”asked another in the Chicago Tribune.
The implication “is totally unjustified,” said Paul Saba, an emergency room doctor at Lachine Hospital and co-president of the Coalition of Physicians for Social Justice.
He flatly rejected the notion that a lack of funding for overall public health care contributes to fatal head injuries like the one that claimed the life of Richardson, the wife of actor Liam Neeson and the daughter of legendary actress Vanessa Redgrave.
Crowd Power
-
Barry ORegan
Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada -
Fred Miller
Friendswood, Texas, United States
Recommendations (91)
-
Barbara McPherson
Nanaimo, Canada -
René
New Orleans, Louisiana, United States -
Yuliya Talmazan
Burnaby, Canada -
RoryKearney
Manhattan, New York, United States
-
Uwe Paschen
Narita, Chiba, Japan -
Mary Richard
Toronto, Canada -
wleng
San Bernardino, California, United States




-1.jpg)
Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (24)
at 08:02 on March 29th, 2009
Thanks General and Sara, goes to show Rumour and Innuendo is Prime when it comes to selling media to the masses
at 08:24 on March 29th, 2009
That's why the Gossip mags are thriving while traditional reporting in major newspapers is crumbling.
at 21:51 on March 29th, 2009
Actually, Fred, I think much of the majors turned into pandering gossip rags, that's why they're failing. They lost the trust of readers, their readership and then lost ad revenue.
along with the TV news shows and channels.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpokeat 08:06 on March 29th, 2009
Incredible that prestigious newspapers could report such trash. The para medics were there within seconds and wanted her to go get checked out. Her ski instructor insisted on it. She felt she was fine and turned them away. Whatever may be wrong with our health care system, this is not it. Shame on the New York Post and Chicago Tribune. Such trash.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpokeat 08:42 on March 29th, 2009
Granted Fred, but I think those major news agencies have an obligation to get it right. The information regarding this case was readily available. If we have come to a point where the only thing that counts is the headlines, we.re in deep trouble. thanks for your comments.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
jack mowatt (not verified)at 08:24 on March 29th, 2009
please don't refuse help when it shows up to help
at 08:28 on March 29th, 2009
It's pure silliness. It doesn't matter if it's the best service in the world, or something out of Hellraiser if medical care is refused.
at 08:35 on March 29th, 2009
thanks everyone for your comments
at 09:42 on March 29th, 2009
Thanks Fred and Rory for the recommendations
- Sign In or Join to post comments
Daro (not verified)at 14:29 on March 29th, 2009
Pharma isn't the only issue on which the NY Post is a sly fox serving a hidden master. Basically ignore them for everything except their celebrity gossip columns. I don't want to be labelled anti-semitic so I'll refrain mentioning what other (zionistic) issues they bend over on... if you catch my drift.
at 14:35 on March 29th, 2009
Living here in the US and having lived in Canada most of my life, I would say the US health care system is close to failure. The New York Post is just another Trash Magazine along the same lines as some cable channels like Fox News.
at 17:32 on March 29th, 2009
Thanks everyone for your comments, much appreciated
at 17:53 on March 29th, 2009
This article in today's Gazette is worth a read...
"And with all due to respect to the Americans, we don't need any lessons from them about health care," Paul Brunet (President, Council for the Protection of Patients) says. Canada doesn't "have 50 million people without health care like they do."
at 01:12 on March 30th, 2009
Any/All publications in which Rupert Murdoch has a stake, you can wipe your bottom with them and afterwards your bum will still be dirty.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
Bill Blebb (not verified)at 14:10 on March 30th, 2009
Gee, isn't it typical of the USA to blame Canada again!
They blamed us for the terrorists that "came through Canada" before the US Customs allowed them to enter the USA.
Is it not true that Natasha declined medical treatment after her fall, but then later required it?
That hardly says that the Canadian medical is at fault for her death.
She is responsible for her own death by her actions of declining a medical examination after her fall.
at 17:27 on March 30th, 2009
Thanks Tina, excellent input, much appreciated.
at 21:14 on March 30th, 2009
It all comes down to what you as an individual choose to do with your life.
We don't know enough about the dynamics of Natasha Richardson's marriage, her life relationships or status as a Celebrity. But we do know that many of us have dreams of doing something more with our lives, often before we reach the age of 50. Some people even have an unconscious 'Bucket List' of things to do before they die. It seems that Ms. Richardson may have been doing something similar, like those who say, 'I've always wanted to ski !' or 'I'd love to climb Mt. Everest !' or 'I'd love to go Bungee Jumping !' However, not everyone gets to make the final decision in such cases, due to lack of resources, work situations, parental, or spousal permissions, etc. Natasha chose the trip for whatever reasons, accompanied by whom I'm not sure. The point is, she chose to put herself first in disregard of others who loved and cared about her.
Whether it's climbing Mt. Everest or Bungee Jumping off Victoria Falls, even the best Physician in the world can only do so much with what's available at the immediate location. The more remote and inaccessible the location, the lesser the chances of the individual surviving. Her reason for choosing a somewhat remote location is understandable, as she thought she would go unrecognized. But she could have chosen a ski resort with medical and other facilities more in keeping with her status as a famous person of means (a rich Celeb).
She should have worn a helmet. She should have been accompanied by a health/trip advisor whose advice could have made a difference all-round. She refused help, which can be overlooked since the cold air was probably already affecting her as a beginner. Falling in the snow and regaining one's faculties may take seconds or minutes or more depending on the individual. Refusing a helmet...well that could be the daredevil impulse or a novice's notion of some 'extreme' action.
The recent Niagara Falls Jumper also resisted help. His miraculous rescue and recovery were only possible due to the presence and heroic efforts of the highly-trained and equipped professionals in that busy tourist area.
Natasha did what she wanted to do, where she wanted to, on her own terms. She had her way, she had her say, she got her wish. But she lost. And Death won. I could go deeper into all this but enough, let her R.I.P.
It all comes down to what you as an individual choose to do with your life.
No need for political spins and spats.
at 19:23 on April 4th, 2009
You takes yer chances, thats what I always say
- Sign In or Join to post comments
elfie (not verified)at 23:41 on March 30th, 2009
Oh, for heavens sake...wasn't it bad enough that she died from a head injury? I would not think twice about being medically treated in Canada. This is pure ignorance. Also, neither Natasha or her husband were Americans. What brought this on??
- Sign In or Join to post comments
D. Martin (not verified)at 18:14 on March 31st, 2009
This accident is so unfortunate. With no disrepect to the deceased, hundreds of people die every year in the same manner that Ms. Richardson did. If I had been skiing at Mont Tremblant when I learned to ski, I would have brushed off the spill in the same manner. Who takes ski lessons with epidural hematomas in the back of their mind. If we did, we would not hit the slopes. We wipe out, we get up, brush the snow off and keep going, providing of course that we can.
Ms. Richardson's demise could have happened in the U.S., Austria or anywhere for that matter and who can, conclusively say, the outcome would have been any different. Those first couple of hours after her fall were so important.
There are a myriad of lessons to be learned from Ms. Richardson's death -I don't believe her death was meant to be in vain. Let`s start with awareness and helmet use.
For any newspaper or journalist who chooses to jump to conclusions and start the blame game is nothing more, in my mind, irresponsible. Canada's health system may not be the best however I believe we try to improve it daily.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
hckxnmwi hdkcfby (not verified)at 21:45 on April 4th, 2009
wavgqmpdh vwgbnikf wzlkqsnpy mysfj vuawhfyl csdztp tmfhin
- Sign In or Join to post comments
Chris from Canada (not verified)at 18:37 on April 6th, 2009
Actually, the local hospital at Mont Tremblant has a CT Scanner. If medical treatment had not been refused...twice...I think that the story may have unfortunately been different. I also note that the author failed to mention that Natasha Richardson had some form of medical coverage, unlike 50 million Americans. ALL Canadians universally have basic health care coverage. I think that is the most important of all.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
John G. (not verified)at 04:33 on April 10th, 2009
Canadian healthcare kills many Canadians .... death by waiting lists (which by the way does not mean care.) I am Canadian and can say that Canadian healthcare sucks, it's collapsing, and unsustainable.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
John_Mayer (not verified)at 02:27 on April 17th, 2009
If you are uninsured and does not have insurance, you should check out the website http://UninsuredAmerica.blogspot.com - John Mayer, California