FDA Slams Green Tea! Have They Done Enough Research?

by tellmemore | June 10, 2009 at 05:25 am
196 views | 14 Recommendations | 2 comments

The Orientals have credited Green tea with miracle healing powers for Centuries. Among the powers that were mentioned were such effects as Green Tea’s ability to work as a stimulant, its ability to eliminate indigestion, prevent fatigue, and improve both the urinary function and brain function. Green Tea has also been credited with the ability to stimulate weight loss, reduce cholesterol, prevent cardiovascular disease, improve immune function in Aids victims, Stop Alzheimer’s and even treats arthritis and MS and breast cancer. About the only thing it has not been credited with is the ability to prevent hair loss.

Lately there have been comments plastered all over the media, such as MSNBC, that the FDA does not support these claims. In fact they have stated that the FDA “rejects all Green Tea’s claims of health benefits". They have been quoted as saying “There is no credible evidence to support qualified claims of Green Tea.”

Before we allow these remarks to totally discredit the Proud Chinese people and their beliefs in the healing powers of Green Tea, we need to explore what tests the FDA ran and what were their exact results. What scientific proof does the FDA have to validate their dispute of these health claims?

Actually the FDA has not run any tests. They have not conducted a single scientific experiment to either support or deny these claims. Rather a committee of members of the FDA read 105 articles and publications from major medical companies and universities. These publications were documented results from professionally conducted scientific experiments. After reading these reports they stated that “no credible, evidence could be found.”

Yet these reports were generated from major organizations with medical credibility. The list of institutions include such medical ‘power hitters’ as the National Cancer Society, who published results of tests that showed that Green Tea reduced the risk of Esophageal Cancer, Perdue University, whose researchers concluded that a compound in Green Tea inhibits the growth of Cancer cells and even demonstrates the ability to hinder the growth of Tumors, and the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition who support the claims that Green Tea has shown the ability to assist in weight reduction.

So while the FDA may not support these results or even credit them as being reliable, there is far too many tests that have reliable evidence to support these amazing claims. What we need to understand before discounting Green Teas natural abilities is that the FDA has not denounced these claims but rather has said they that are not convinced, that Green Tea has the abilities it claims. While the FDA can not find enough scientific evidence to endorse these claims, they have not conducted experiments to support the contrary.

We can not allow ourselves to become confused by the media and the mighty name of the FDA and the power that is synonymous with it. We need to understand the language of what the FDA said, and not fall victim to the idea that the health benefits of Green Tea are false. We should not understand the FDA to say that Green Tea does not have medical benefits but rather that they have not seen enough evidence to prove to them that these claims are valid.

I for one will continue to drink several glasses a day and believe that Green Tea is good for me. After all this is not the first time the FDA has doubted ancient medical remedies, remedies that have been supported for centuries and have recent modern technologically assisted proof that they work.

Read the complete story at http://www.warmthoftea.com/blog/does-the-fda-know-better-than-ancient-chinese

recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
Victoria Winston

The FDA does not conduct tests of any kind on any drugs or supplements. That is not their role. Their role is to view the testing done by researchers.  The problem with Green Tea - or any other supplement is not that there are tests showing negative results - it's that there are not many tests validating the health claims. And that is because green tea is a non proprietary ingreidient which cannot be patented, therefore no one wants to spend the money to do the testing. That is not the FDAs fault - they can only review what is submitted to them.

0
Maireid Sullivan

As the saying goes, "follow the money" –and it's been documented that members of the FDA administration move quite freely back and forth from corporate jobs, virtually functioning as lobbyists.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Spydermonkey
First Flagged at 11:48 AM, Jun 10, 2009 by Spydermonkey

Related Stories

Recommendations (14)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from