Hydroxycut recall as FDA says one person died from liver failure

by Amy Judd | May 1, 2009 at 10:09 am
1817 views | 54 Recommendations | 15 comments

The diet pill Hydroxycut has been recalled today as the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) says one person has died from liver failure after taking the weight loss supplement.

Health officials are saying that anyone taking the supplement should immediately as it could cause liver failure and in this one case, death. The FDA has received reports of 23 people suffering from liver problems, from jaundice to liver transplant.

Videos

MuscleTech Hydroxycut Hardcore

see larger video

sourced by JeffHuang

MuscleTech Hydroxycut Hardcore

Canada's lovate Health Sciences Inc, the maker of Hydroxycut has agreed to recall 14 of their products.

"The FDA urges consumers to discontinue use of Hydroxycut products in order to avoid any undue risk. Adverse events are rare, but exist," said Linda Katz, interim chief medical officer of the FDA's Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition.

Hydroxycut says that it will help with weight loss, water loss, and will burn fat while providing more energy.

The products Hydroxycut Cleanse and Hoodia products are not included in the recall however.

Photos

Hydroxycut

Hydroxycut

see larger image

uploaded by Newbirth

It is not yet known what ingredients could have caused this liver damage, and although it is rare, the patients who have reported problems, have taken the recommended dose on the bottle.

Some other health issues that have been reported include seizures, cardiovascular disorders and rhabdomyolysis (a kind of muscle damage).

recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
sara star

Goodness gracious! People dying to get thin.

0
Amy Judd

Yes, it's really not worth it at all.

0
Torf

My sister has spent the last 24 hours in the hospital due to liver damage from Garcinia Cambogia, vomiting blood and in severe pain, along with other symptoms.  Alcohol causes liver damage over a period of time....yes but for 25% of people GC causes it so quickly and severely.   


2
Roy C

I don't agree that Hydroxycut is dangerous. What evidence is there that this "liver failure" was caused by using the product?

The main ingredient, hydroxycitric acid, is an extract of an Indian fruit, Garcinia Cambogia, and all it does is slow carbohydrate absorption and keep insulin levels down. The fruit has been used as part of traditional Indian medicine for centuries.

The other ingredient, gymnema sylvestre, is also well-tolerated and I can't see how it would have caused liver failure.

The formula includes green teas and other ingredients such as aspirin. I will go through the whole list in a later post.

Frankly, I think that is a a lot of over-reaction, typical of the FDA when it comes to unregulated products.

I ask you: how much liver failure has been caused by alcohol?

0
Tina Kells

I completely agree.  In a world that still allows cigarettes and alcohol to be sold this seems like reactionary overkill!

1
Roy C

Literally millions of boxes of Hydroxycut have been sold. I do wonder about this one case of "liver failure".

This is a look at one of the main ingredients of the product: gymnema sylvestre.


Gymnema Sylvestre

Another promising supplement is an extract of gymnema sylvestre, a woody climber that grows in tropical forests of the central and southern parts of India.

Although this product has been used for the treatment of diabetes in India over many centuries, the first scientific demonstration of its anti-diabetic properties in humans was made about 70 years ago when it was observed that leaves of gymnema sylvestre reduced glycosuria (glucose in urine) in individuals with diabetes.

(3) Although in vitro studies to examine the effect of this extract on insulin secretion remain to be performed, gymnema sylvestre use appears to enhance insulin secretion and the functional viability of the endocrine pancreas in vivo.

This supplement represents a unique and interesting product because it is one of those few agents that may have beneficial effects on both type 1 and type 2 diabetes.

(4) Gymnema sylvestre extract appears to be particularly effective when administered as an adjunct to oral antidiabetic agents. For instance, in a study in India, gymnema sylvestre extract (called GS4) was administered as an adjunct to conventional oral agents at a dose of 400 mg. per day in 22 type 2 diabetic patients for 18-20 months. During the GS4 supplementation, the patients had the dosage of their conventional drugs reduced and still showed a reduction in blood glucose, glycosylated hemoglobin and other proteins. Five of the 22 patients were able to discontinue their conventional drugs and maintain adequate blood glucose control on the GS4 supplement action alone.(5)
1
Roy C

This is about the efficacy of hydroxycitric acid. "Traditional Indian medicine" is Ayurvedic medicine. Israeli Agent has informed me that "veda" means knowledge and "Ayur-" here means life.


May 18, 2005

HCA slows glucose uptake

A sudy published in the June 2005 issue of the American Journal of Physiology-Gastrointestinal and Liver Physiology (http://ajpgi.physiology.org/) revealed that hydroxycitric acid (HCA), the active ingredient in the fruit Garcinia cambogia used in traditional Indian medicine, helps slow glucose uptake after a meal, which reduces insulin output.

Researchers in the Netherlands administered HCA to rats before infusing sugar into their stomachs to mimic a meal. A control group of rats received no HCA before the infusion. The rats that received HCA were found to experience a much slower elevation in blood glucose after the sugar infusion than rats that did not receive the compound. HCA was also found to lower the rise in glucose following sugar administration after the compound was administered directly into the stomach or small intestine, which excluded the possibility that HCA had effected gastric emptying.

Lead author Peter Y. Wielinga elaborated, "Sugar that is normally absorbed rather quickly -- within about 20 minutes -- took over 2 hours after HCA ingestion. This delay is good because it reduces the high peaks of glucose, which otherwise would require the body to produce a lot of insulin to deal with the 'meal."

Dr Wielinga stated that the next step is to discover HCA's mechanism of action. He speculated, "If we can reduce the peaks and valleys of insulin with HCA, then it might have some application in diabetes, both in slowing progression to diabetes 2 and since these people have an obesity problem, it could potentially have an additional benefit in the therapeutic field. "

Dr Wielinga, who will be conducting research at the University of Zurich, also plans to investigate HCA's effect on reducing food intake, a phenomenon that has been observed in rodents.

1
Roy C

If there is a problem from the ingredients of Hydroxycut, it would have to be the ephedra. I recommend the hydroxycut without caffeine and without other stimulants to my friends and family.

If you stick with garcinia cambogia and gymnema sylvestre and the decaffeinated green teas in the product I have used, you can't get any liver damage unless there is something wrong with your liver in the first place.

I have to wonder if some of these people exceeded the recommended dosages.

Now, as far as ephedra is concerned, millions and millions of pseudo-ephedrine doses, a similar product to ephedra, are taken every year in the millions and millions of doses of cold and allergy remedies.

That is why I am so skeptical about this action.

The recall is voluntary, by the way.

Fighting For Health Freedom Worldwide:
A Report From the Battlefield

Challenges to the public's freedom to seek out and buy health care products of their own choosing are under attack around the world. The crisis is particularly acute in the U.S. and Canada.

The United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has just done us all a huge "favor" by openly announcing its intention to "harmonize" U.S. domestic law with the international reference standards expected to be set by the United Nation's Codex Alimentarius Commission (Codex). This represents a significant threat to free access to high-potency dietary supplements. With this announcement, consumers in the U.S. and abroad need to band together to fight back.

The FDA's announcement was posted on the agency's website, http://www.fda.gov/ola/319.htm. It should be viewed against the backdrop of the FDA's June 2 proposal for strict dosage limits for the herb ma huang (which contains natural ephedra), but not for synthetic ephedrine drugs.

A Medline search shows no deaths attributed to ephedra/ma huang, and 57 deaths attributed to OTC drugs containing ephedrine. This proposal is an example of the double standard the FDA is applying to the regulation of nutrients and herbs.

The FDA's harmonization efforts also can be seen in its Commission on Dietary Supplement Labels draft report, in which it advocates OTC drug status for herbs and botanicals. This report threatens to undermine the gains made through the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act (DSHEA). While this report does not carry the force of law, it could be used as a prelude to legislation.

These FDA actions are part of an international movement. Moving with deliberate, almost glacial slowness, which makes it hard for consumers to catch on, the trans-national pharmaceutical industry is working through the Codex Committee on Nutrition and Foods for Special Dietary Use to attempt to restrict our access to dietary supplements.

An International Movement To Restrict Access To Dietary Supplements

There is, for example, a German proposal that threatens to reduce consumer access to dietary supplements to no higher than recommended daily allowance levels, as well as a Canadian proposal that threatens to ban the international sale of many safe herbs.

It is through herbal products, which do not have RDAs, that the pharmaceutical industry is making its biggest takeover bid. The Canadian Codex proposal to create a negative list of herbs for the purpose of banning their sale from international commerce was first proposed at a North America/Southwest Pacific meeting in Vancouver in 1994, but it is still on the table. Mary Cheney of the Canadian Health Protection Branch (HPB) initially agreed to back off from the proposal in deference to public opinion, but later reversed her position at the Codex meeting in Bonn, Germany, last October.

Currently the HPB has a list of more than 104 herbs it intends to ban, and people all over the world had better take notice.

The German Codex proposal could be enacted by September 1998. This may seem like a long time from now, but given what we must do to stop it, it's not! In addition to the long-range threat posed by this proposal, immediate efforts are being made worldwide by drug companies to take over the natural supplement market. Consider the efforts of German pharmaceutical companies in the U.S. and Canada:

0
Barbara McPherson

Some really interesting information here, both the post and subsequent comments.

0
Blue Crush

I agree, very interesting info here, thanks.  I've never tried it, but before today, I wouldn't have thought twice about using it. 

0
Amy Judd

Thanks for the extra information here Roy, really helpful and helps us understand the story more. I for one agree that it's the ephedra that could cause most of the problems and I'm sure that some people taking it must have exceeded the recommended dosage because there can be that thinking that 'if I just take two instead of one today, that will make things work quicker', which is never the way to go.

0
Eph

Wow, liver failure?

Drink water and lots of it!

Learn how to take care of your body

0
aj17

what about the other health issues claimed to be reported? As in, Seizures, cardiovascular disorders and Rhabdomylosis...

0
clarenash

I think there are a lot of good alternatives that can help you lose weight, be it diet and exercise or a better weight loss supplement.  I think extensive weight loss research helps us understand how we can achieve our goals. I have heard about this drug before and as said above about seizures and cardio disorders it is a scary product to take

0
Cynthia111

Be careful with Hydroxycut. If you have been or are currently using Hydroxycut supplements to diet or get in shape, you should know it's been recalled and is apparently very dangerous. This site has a lot of good information on its problems: http://www.hydroxycut-liver-damage-lawyer.com/.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

sara star
First Flagged at 12:42 PM, May 1, 2009 by sara star
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in Health

Recommendations (54)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from