is reporting from
Member
NP Rank:
NP Rank:
Save the planet, get a headache?
Some U.K. health experts say energy-saving light bulbs may trigger migraines in people prone to the condition, according to a report in Britain's Daily Mail.
British government officials have been inundated with complaints about energy-saving fluorescent bulbs, which will be mandated for use in homes within four years.
Advocates want the government to allow people with health problems to continue using conventional incandescent bulbs with a filament and say eco-friendly bulbs can trigger dizziness, loss of focus and discomfort among people with epilepsy.
There have also been complaints from people with lupus — an auto-immune disease causing many symptoms including pain.
Energy-saving light bulbs could trigger migraines, say campaigners.The Migraine Action Association says members have told them how fluorescent bulbs have led to attacks.
The government is set to prevent the sale of conventional light bulbs within the next four years in a bid to cut carbon dioxide emissions.
Concerns have already been raised by epilepsy charities about an increased risk of seizures from energy-saving bulbs.
The charity's Paul Jansen said: "For some people a migraine attack can be triggered by fluorescent lights, video screens, stroboscopic effects and flashing lights.
"Most of the currently available low energy light bulbs are based on fluorescent light technology.
"We hope that the Government will allow regular light bulbs still to be available to those who need them.'
The Government has acknowledged low energy bulbs could pose a problem.
In a written parliamentary answer, Health Minister Ivan Lewis said: "It is known some people with epilepsy may be affected by energy saving light bulbs."
The Lighting Association denied that flicker was a problem with modern energy saving bulbs.
"Compact fluorescent lamps give a constant, flicker-free, nonstroboscopic light," said spokesman Jo Jackson.
She warned against poor quality, cheap lamps, saying: "A small number of cases have been reported by people who suffer from reactions to certain types of linear (straight line) fluorescent lamps.
"These were almost certainly triggered by old technology."
A spokesman for the Energy Saving Trust said: "The technology has changed massively over the last few years. We would advise people to only buy bulbs with the Energy Saving Recommended - SR - logo."
patgarcia
La Paz, Mexico
Anonymous users (2)
Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (2)
at 09:08 on July 27th, 2009
My office in the U.S. recently installed energy efficient bulbs in our lunch area. I tried to sit under the lights and immediately started feeling sick to my stomach and started getting a headache. I had to leave the lunch area right away and instead eat at my desk, where we have regular fluorescent lighting.
I did a random search over the Internet to see if there could be a reason for this and came across this article on your site. I've never been diagnosed with lupus but do have some light sensitivity issues.
at 02:43 on August 1st, 2009
I put the CFLS right over and next to my head in my kitchen for four to six months initially and have taken them out four times over the past 12 months to see if the problems which unexpectedly arose for me were due to the lights or perhaps something else. The lights in my house are low down and in the kitchen they are above a white bench and not covered by a light shade. I have also tried the envelope type but still have problems. It started first with balance problems which went away when I took out the lights. Then when I put them back I got headaches and nausea. After the last trial with the envelope style only in for 48 hours I suffered a permanent headache for seven weeks finally overcome by wearing wraparound sunglasses everywhere all day. The headaches have now largely disappeared after that but now I am experiencing non loss of consciousness seizure type events which are very scary and don't fit the pattern of panic attacks. I also become irritable and unwell when in the shopping centres and other public places which have any sort of fluorescents and I can no longer watch TV without adverse effects. I am under a neurologist who so far has not found anything else wrong and it is actually very difficult to prove epilepsy anyway as most eeg's are negative. I have also found my long term allergies have come back out of control after 25 years of minimal problems and nothing else in my life has changed. The worst part is trying to get anyone to accept that all this has anything to do with the new lights but from personal experience I believe there can be no other explanation. I can use halogen in my home but when I go out, even to doctor's surgeries, there are all the lights on full display, often low down and uncovered. I also find if I take allergy desensitizing drops and other anti histamines I can abort bad attacks but even though there have been some reputable studies at Great Ormond Hospital for children in the 1980's which suggested a connection the neurologist does not believe that either.
Thank you for this opportunity to comment. I hope it will help change this legislation back!