NP Rank:
Mayor May Tread on Civil Liberties to Force Homeless Indoors
"Vancouver's mayor says letting people who can't take care of themselves die in the street is immoral, and something needs to be done, even if it means treading on their civil rights."
Vancouver Police already have the power under the Mental Health Act via "Car 87", a police car carrying an armed constable and a psych nurse, to apprehend people who are at imminent risk of harming themselves. That is, if it's used as it was intended. And that's a big IF.
There is evidence that police -- both the VPD in Vancouver and the RCMP at UBC -- in conjunction with psych nurses, have been perverting such power for political ends such as intimidating whistle blowers who are embarrassing United Way, the Vancouver School Board, or CUPE Local 116.
Not all the homeless are mentally ill though. According to Tenant Assistant Program Coordinator Judy Graves, who walks the streets and helps the homeless get a place to stay, some homeless people won't go to shelters because they can't take their shopping carts or their pets.



Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (3)
at 11:54 on December 20th, 2008
Interesting commentary JR. What do you think the solution is?
at 18:02 on December 20th, 2008
You can't (and shouldn't) force people to accept help as long as they are not mentally ill. Informed consent should always be the guiding principle and not elites forcing people to do what they thinks is in someone else's interest.
at 21:45 on December 20th, 2008
when you take away choice you fundamentally taken away what little self determination the homeless have. It should be a choice to come in. Imagine what horrid experiences would drive someone to refuse to survive. Then, taken from understanding those experiences, make it better, win back trust so they come in out of the cold.