'Natural' Diet Pills may contain Illegal Drugs

by Karenke4 | February 10, 2009 at 03:46 pm
1609 views | 13 Recommendations | 16 comments

Photos

Take ur pills fat boy.

Take ur pills fat boy.

see larger image

uploaded by felpa.sonico

Recent announcements by the FDA claim that popular “natural” diet pills for sale in the US may contain illegal substances. Furthermore, these unapproved pharmaceuticals may cause mild to severe health problems ranging from high blood pressure to heart palpitations and seizures. Many people who take these supplements often do not tell their doctors which can lead to harmful misdiagnosis.

Many of the diet pills under scrutiny contain the chemical bumetenide which is also (illegally) used to mask steroid use in athletes by diluting their urine. The FDA has so far identified supplements including StarCaps, Sliminate, SlimUp, Body Creator and SuperFat Burner among many others, as containing ingredients that are either unlisted or illegal.

“A large percentage of these products either contain dangerous undeclared ingredients or they might be outright fraudulent on the ingredients and have no effect at all,” said Michael Levy, the director of the F.D.A.’s division of New Drugs and Labeling Compliance. “We don’t think consumers should be using these products.”

These results are alarming, especially in the wake of the recent peanut recalls. Just what is the FDA protecting us from, if not illegal substances and contaminated foods? Why are these products on the shelves of super markets and health food stores? Why is there no warning?

Unfortunately as the law stands, the FDA does not have jurisdiction over diet pills until they are placed on the shelves. Then, and only then do they have the authority to test for illegal substances. With more and more products available each day, and access available to foreign supplements over the internet, their job is not getting any easier.

Enacted in 1994, the main law on dietary supplements gives the F.D.A. jurisdiction only after the products go on the market. Rather than reviewing the supplements and approving them for sale, as the agency does with drugs, the F.D.A. is limited to spot-checking manufacturers and distributors, and testing products already on store shelves. Even the F.D.A. acknowledges there may be hundreds of other drug-contaminated weight-loss supplements for sale that the agency does not have the resources to identify.

When they do check these products, and they do find illegal substances, the FDA still does not have the immediate authority to take the products off of their shelves. They must go through more red tape, asking the distributors to recall the products before taking the issue to the courts.

But even when the agency identifies contaminated products, it does not have the ability to remove the pills from stores, because it is initially up to companies to issue a recall. Eventually, though, if contaminated products stay on the market, the F.D.A. can seek injunctions, seize products or file criminal charges.
While the FDA has taken steps to limit harmful weight loss supplements, including a ban of ephedra in 2004, many doctors do not think they are doing enough. Aside from the fact that most weight loss drugs do not actually prevent long term weight gain, many of these supplements also do not have the long term research that would guarantee no serious side effects.
Dr. Sidney M. Wolfe, director of the health research division of the consumer advocacy group Public Citizen, said the regulations did not go far enough. Just because something is uncontaminated does not mean it is safe, he said.
Unlike vitamins, which NP editor Terri Potratz recently reported to have no effect on decreasing heart disease or cancer risks, they also do not pose a threat to a person's health. Diet pills have no such assurance. For now, I would advise you to just stay away.

recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
Amy Judd

I wouldn't trust anything that is supposed to help you lose weight. There is no shortcut to losing weight except eating less and exercising.

0
felpa.sonico

Read my comment :)

1
Roy C

Well, see, there was this problem.

There was, for example, the case of Dr. Don Donsbach, a slightly pudgy and one-time very successful vitamin seller.

The FDA, in those days, could just come in and lock all your stuff up and put you out of business like a bunch of Nazis/Bolsheviks. You couldn't really defend yourself because you had no money because your business was instantly killed the moment that the FDA targeted you. You had no chance to defend yourself.

Now, you may not know this but a decade ago or two there was a commercial for a "light" mayonnaise that had less fat.

The problem is that if you have less fat than what the FDA prescribes, it is actually illegal to call the spread "mayonnaise", even if it is indistinguishable except for the fat content. So, Kraft made  commercial and said in the commercial that "We aren't allowed to call this light spread 'mayonnaise', but you can..." and the FDA went ballistic. Kraft had to drop the commercial.

Violation of Free Speech.

Now, I am going to be publishing some articles about how the FDA tried to suppress vitamins companies from making perfectly legitimate claims such as "Folic acid supplements help prevent spinal bifidy in infants" even though all the research that was done was done with pills of folic acid and the results were beyond conclusive.

So, that is why the FDA finds itself a bit hamstrung today. They had been out of line and they had some of their powers taken away.

I say good.

Now, let's find out if those chemicals are present in microscopic quantites because the machine that mixed the pills hadn't been cleaned properly and trace amounts of chemical got included in the next batch, which is what I think actually happened.

The gov't doesn't like the family farm much either: Mad Sheep: The True Story Behind the USDA’s War on a Family Farm

0
felpa.sonico

Nice story and I feel honored for the photo.

To tell you the truth weight management pills are not bad IMO

The problem with fat people is that well, they don't do anything to help themselves and if the do they will BLINDLY buy some weight management pills, go on a diet and exercise for a week hoping SUPER GREAT results and when that's not achieved well, they get mad and blame everything and everyone but themselves.

Weight Management pills such as Lipo 6 ARE NOT MAGIC PILLS, they help you burn the fat off of you by accelerating your metabolism and pumping you up with energy so you can do extra exercise for the same purpose, but obviously you need 2 exercise and diet properly for months to get results, it's not something that's due overnight and that's another of the main problems, people think that well it's magical and IT'S NOT.

I've been taking them for about a month now and they've helped me a lot, clothes are fitting in more propperly and my back, shoulder and arm muscles are starting to gain shape.

Another issue is "the rebound" when you loose weight but then gain it, well OF COURSE you're gonna do that if you stop dieting and exercising and start eating junk food again and stay all day in front of the tv or the computer.

The truth is that most people won't be honest and they will say things like "they didn't work, those pills are bullshit and a waste of money" or something like that when the truth is they didn't use them propperly or thought they were magic pills or something like that.

On the other hand everyone's body's diffent so the truth is that if someone's planning on buying weight management pills well the first thing they need 2 do is GET INFORMED AND DON'T SHOP BLINDLY.

Find the best pills for you, diet and exercise propperly and you will loose weight.

-Alex

0
Roy C

Normal 0 false false false MicrosoftInternetExplorer4 st1\:*{behavior:url(#ieooui) } /* Style Definitions */ table.MsoNormalTable {mso-style-name:"Table Normal"; mso-tstyle-rowband-size:0; mso-tstyle-colband-size:0; mso-style-noshow:yes; mso-style-parent:""; mso-padding-alt:0in 5.4pt 0in 5.4pt; mso-para-margin:0in; mso-para-margin-bottom:.0001pt; mso-pagination:widow-orphan; font-size:10.0pt; font-family:"Times New Roman"; mso-ansi-language:#0400; mso-fareast-language:#0400; mso-bidi-language:#0400;}

0
Eon34

Eon34 has contributed a photo to this story.

0
Fripouille

This very interesting post begs the question of "Natural" and "Bio" products in general.

France has very stringent controls and content labelling laws. This means that their strict application has uncovered more and more instances of so-called natural and bio products using illegal substances or non-natural substances or practices that mean that they are neither bio or natural. A couple of examples, "Farm-raised fresh-air chickens". They were outside on a farm, sure, but five per square metre. Another tactic is artificial food preservatives or colouring agents, in factory-production scale yogurts.

This can partially be explained in my view by the increasing amounts of money to be made in what started out being an ethical market which wanted to propose genuinely healthy products but has finished up being polluted by those who ditched its standards for easy money by mass-producing product to an extent which precludes the possibility of its being natural at all.

Apart from that, I agree with Amyjudd. Wanna lose weight? Well get out there and use your body and control your eating habits, duh!! :). (This is not, of course, aimed at those who sometimes have other reasons for being overweight..)

1
eastvanray

Chances are that if they DIDN'T contain illegal drugs they wouldn't work.

0
Fripouille

Excellent observation!!!

(And shhhhh. This is the dirty little secret that we are not supposed to know or talk about).

0
Felpa

True =)

0
Barbara McPherson

We should never forget that wonderful combination - fen fen.  Don't buy your special wonder drugs over the net.  You have no idea where they were made.

0
eastvanray

Maybe China!  Or maybe in sweatshops in Canada!

0
Aimzo

 I feel that diet pills wil eventualy turn its user into a anxious and unrealistic human being. I am a media student currently studying the dangers of diet pills

0
tiredofthebull

I grew up with an overweight mother. After I has become an adult and so had my brother and sister she developed a few of health problems because of her weight.  She did start exercising more and eating healthier but eventually she wanted faster results and went through a ton of different diet pills. None of them ever produced the result they promised but she kept spending a ton of money trying. Any weight she lost was simply because of diet and exercise- she never had any dramatic results with any diet pill. After about 2 years of the diet pill roller coaster she had a heart attack and passed away. Her doctor believes all the different diet pills- that her told not to take, but she didn't listen- contributed to the heart attack. I dont know if it was because of illegal drugs but I do think there all several things in those pills that are not intended for people to take for any length of time and since most of them contain similar ingredients, switching from one brand to the next is not much different than taking them for long periods of time. They are definetly bad news for any human body.

0
eastvanray

Sorry to hear about your mother.  The only ingredients in these pills that do anything to help people lose weight are stimulants.  And if you have even seen cocaine or meth addicts then you have seen proof that stimulants DO help people lose weight.  The major problem with diet pills is that they are really only safe to be taken by people with strong, healthy hearts and most people who buy diet pills are obviously over weight and therefore have comprimised heart health.  Hence the heart attacks.

0
Todd29

It is not always easy to do, but eat to live don't live to eat.  Some type of daily regimen is needed by everyone, but stop dieting, your body needs nourishment.  Diets and diet aids do not help anyone.  The only way to successfully lose weight and get the body that you deserve is by using the right information.  This information is in the book Lose Weight Using Four Easy Steps which can be ordered through the website www.bbotw.com  Everyone who has gotten a copy of this book has lost weight and become healthier.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Anonymous
First Flagged at 4:20 PM, Feb 10, 2009 by Anonymous (not verified)
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (13)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from