NP Rank:
Oregon Man Murders His Sister
One day during the first week of November, Joseph F. Rockwood killed his adoring sister, Theresa. He stabbed her to death. Theresa's body was found in Joseph's apartment on November 7, after a friend of Theresa's asked police to do a welfare check on the apartment around noon. Theresa's brother suffers from a severe, chronic case of schizophrenia, but 54-year-old Joseph does not know that he is sick. He has a condition that is very common among psychiatric patients called "anosognosia," and that is why Theresa died.
Joseph discontinued cooperating with his social worker at Cascadia Behavioral Healthcare about a year ago and discontinued his medications. Theresa watched her brother's mental state spiral downward while she and her husband made repeated attempts to get help for Joseph. He was delusional and living in filth. Despite their pleas to authorities, the system had no answers for this family in crisis.
As with rural Chinese peasant families, Americans are regularly abandoned by the system and left to deal with their own dangerous mentally ill relatives. Many families struggle to prevent their sick relatives from killing their neighbors, as happened with the Chinese man the article at the link below. Wang Guocheng's family finally built him a cage where he lived for three years in their living room, but eventually, he escaped his confinement and killed his mother. http://my.nowpublic.com/health/mentally-ill-citizens-caged-china-and-america-mary-neal
Like Theresa and her husband, parents of Seung-Hui Cho had no legal remedy when their 17-year-old son discontinued his psychiatric treatments. On April 16, 2007, Cho opened fire on his classmates and instructors at Virginia Tech, killing 32 people before committing suicide. He wounded many others.
Oregon News reports that Cascadia Behavioral Healthcare declined to comment regarding Joseph murdering Theresa. Chris Bouneff, director of marketing and development for DePaul Treatment Centers and president of the National Alliance on Mental Illness of Oregon spoke with Oregon News reporter, Don Colburn, and explained, "We have a system that's chronically underfunded."
With Theresa's death, the system has come up with a very expensive answer for Joseph: On November 10, Joseph was arraigned for murder. As a result, Oregon taxpayers will now pay untold amounts of money to criminalize Joseph for his mental illness, including attorneys' fees, court costs, incarceration fees, and for psychiatric tests to determine Joseph's ability to stand trial. After that, the State of Oregon may pay over $100,000 per year for Joseph to join the 1.25 million other mental patients already incarcerated in America's prisons. That number accounts for more than half of the nation's 2.3 million incarcerated persons, costing taxpayers $185 BILLION per annum. Under court-ordered provisions for California's imprisoned mental patients, taxpayers will pay approximately $230,000 per year, per mental patient warehoused in prison. And that expenditure comes after taxpayers spend $8 BILLION to build and equip seven new prison hospital facilities that will undoubtedly offer excellent care - behind bars.
Do you think the taxpayers in Oregon and California might prefer to pay for Joseph's social worker to make a home visit in response to Theresa's anguished pleas for help, and to simply purchase a $40 bottle of pills? But if Joseph refused to resume his medications for his social worker, do you think taxpayers would rather have had authorities simply force Joseph to open his mouth and swollow the pills as in inpatient, at least until he was stabilized? Do you believe Theresa's husband would have preferred that? Once Joseph goes to prison and receives psychiatric treatment in preparation for trial, poor Joseph will come to realize what he has done. How will he feel then? Will Joseph wish someone had helped him regain control of his faculties through enforced psychiatric treatment before he murdered his own sweet sister, who loved him so much?
In the matter of State of Oregon v. Joseph F. Rockwood, who loses? Theresa lost her life; her husband lost his wife. Joseph lost his loving sister, who was his support system. He also lost any chance of finding peace in a lucid state facing the tragic reality that he killed Theresa. Oregon's taxpayers lose the difference between a $40 bottle of pills versus the cost of imprisoning Joseph for the remaining 20+years of his life expectancy. Who wins? In many cases where the mentally ill are criminalized, the only winners are private prison owners - those who profit off the nations' staggering incarceration rate, by far the highest of any nation on earth.
Below is a blog by Treatment Advocacy Center which explains the common health condition that blinded Joseph to the fact that he needed psychiatric help. One gorgeous autumn day, while deprived of his psychiatric medications, Joseph decided that stabbing his sister to death was a good idea at the time.
**********************
From: <eNews@TreatmentAdvocacyCenter.org>
RESTORING REASON TO TREATING MENTAL ILLNESS
Battling Obstacles: Anosognosia
Nov. 14, 2008
Families of people with severe mental illness are all too familiar with the struggle involved in caring for a person who very well may not even realize they are sick. It is a medical condition known as anosognosia.
News this week brought this little known medical term home. Blogs and news stories covered the struggle that Theresa Rockwood faced. Her 54-year-old brother, Joseph F. Rockwood, suffers from schizophrenia. He is now charged with her murder.
Theresa's fight to help her brother is not unlike the plight of others who care for someone with a severe mental illness, only to find that the state's laws act as a barrier to treatment.
Anosognosia is a major problem because it is the single largest reason why individuals with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder do not take their medications. It is caused by damage to specific parts of the brain, especially the right hemisphere. It affects approximately 50 percent of individuals with schizophrenia and 40 percent of individuals with bipolar disorder. When taking medications, awareness of illness improves in some patients.
Impaired awareness of illness is a strange thing. It is difficult to understand how a person who is sick would not know it. Impaired awareness of illness is very difficult for other people to comprehend. To other people, a person's psychiatric symptoms seem so obvious that it's hard to believe the person is not aware he/she is ill. Oliver Sacks, in his book The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat, noted this problem:
It is not only difficult, it is impossible for patients with certain right-hemisphere syndromes to know their own problems ...And it is singularly difficult, for even the most sensitive observer, to picture the inner state, the 'situation' of such patients, for this is almost unimaginably remote from anything he himself has ever known.
"It's not uncommon for family members to struggle with trying to get care for their loved ones," says Chris Bouneff, director of marketing and development for DePaul Treatment Centers and president of the National Alliance on Mental Illness of Oregon.
"It doesn't work to say to them, 'Why don't you just get help?' Their frame of reference will never be that they need help," Bouneff told the Oregonian newspaper.
You can help raise awareness the importance of improving timely and effective treatment for people with severe mental illnesses. Take a few mintues to spread the word to some friends.
**********************
WHATEVER REASON this nation has to criminalize mental illness, it is not in order to save taxpayers money or save families suffering. What is the real reason to withhold treatment from mental patients until there is a smoking gun or dripping knife? Open-book quiz: Who wins?
One group feels that it has the answer, and recently launched the petition at the link below. One can view the petition language without signing and read petitioners' comments at the "view signatures" link provided thereon:
PETITION TO END PRIVATE PRISONS:
http://www.petitiononline.com/gufree2/petition.html
In a country where treatment facilities for mental illness are "chronically underfunded," no expense is spared to ensure that psychiatric patients like Joseph Rockwood are punished for the rest of their lives for committing the despicable crime of being mentally ill in America. (Please substitute mentally ill with any politically correct term you prefer. There is no intention to offend - only to render Assistance to the Incarcerated Mentally Ill.)
**********************
Website: http://wrongfuldeathoflarryneal.com
Arthor's page http://www.care2.com/c2c/people/profile.html?pid=513396753
AIMI: http://www.care2.com/c2c/group/AIMI
Articles: http://my.nowpublic.com/search?fulltext=1&type=story&keys=mary+neal
Crowd Power
-
duo
Stone Mountain, Georgia, United States
Recommendations (19)

Anonymous users (3)
-
wearealldoingtime
San Bruno, California, United States -
mairead1984
Rosendale, New York, United States -
Uwe Paschen
Narita, Chiba, Japan -
reno_fog
Reno, Nevada, United States -
Jennings David L
Baltimore, Maryland, United States







Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (12)
at 08:20 on November 16th, 2008
duo, a very informative piece on the state of government help for patients with mental disorders. One of the worst crimes on society was when government released mentally ill patients for lack of money. The cost of this transfer of responsibility is now more costly than when help was provided.
at 16:02 on November 16th, 2008
Thank you for your comments, David. You are right - taxpayers are only led to believe mental hospitals were closed to save the expense. Actually, criminalizing mental illness is substantially more costly, not to mention being mean as hell. See this article:
Enforced Treatment v. Prison for Acute Mental Patients
http://my.nowpublic.com/health/enforced-treatment-vs-prison-acute-mental-patients-and-updates-mary-neal
at 09:29 on November 16th, 2008
A great piece of reporting... It's easier to incarcerate the to treat. Sad but true
at 16:10 on November 16th, 2008
Hello, Reno_fog. Thank you for your comments. Actually, it is not easier to imprison than treat. You see, jails and prisons are still legally bound to treat sick inmates. So it is not an either/or situation. Unless prisons completely ignore the law, as sometimes happens, criminalizing mental illness actually doubles taxpayers' responsibility: taxpayers are required to punish their neighbors for being sick plus treat their illness.
I suppose the double responsibility resulting from criminalizing mental illness is the reason why inmates in the general prison population usually costs taxpayers around $50,000 for each and every inmate annually (2/3 of whom are jailed on non-violent offenses), but every sick prisoner costs at least twice that. California's new plan under court order will charge taxpayers $230,000 per year, per sick person - more money than the average family of four earns in five years!
Of course, sometimes correctional institutions simply ignore their legal duty to treat sick prisoners. I have read horrible accounts of inmates dying of cancer being denied pain meds for their excruciating pain, for example. My mentally ill brother, who was kept under secret arrest in Shelby County Jail 18 days until death, had a heart condition that needed prescription drugs. Since the jail denied having him, naturally, he could not have been getting prescription heart drugs.
The problem is that when correctional facilities ignore the necessity of treating sick prisoners, the taxpayers then often face the additional cost of paying big lawsuits. That will probably happen in Mr. Horton's case. He was kept nine months in solitary confinement, naked and in filth, and denied any exercise, baths, or doctor's visits: http://my.nowpublic.com/health/prison-torture-mentally-ill-american-nine-months-solitary-confinement-filth-and-naked
In other words, there is absolutely no monetary reason to throw sick people in jail. Criminalizing mental illness is a much more expensive exercise than treatment in a hospital, and certainly more expensive than community care (under mandatory treatment provisions to prevent patients from dropping out of treatment).
I know most taxpayers think there is some good reason for the system jailing folks rather than treating them in hospitals or their communities, and there is: Criminalizing mental illness is BIG BUSINESS.
Thanks for responding!
at 17:12 on November 16th, 2008
Response dated 11/16/08 from an AIMI member to the problem of folks not knowing they are sick:
Mary, my Mother a Paranoid Schizophrenic with Anosognosia would not take her medicine. Sometimes she would think it was poison, sometimes she just didn't think she needed it because she didn't believe there was anything wrong with her. As anyone with experience with the mentally ill knows, their meds are their lifeline. Without them, they cannot survive. What her doctor and I ended up doing was to give her her meds in injection form. Many drugs for Schizophrenia can be given in injection form once a month. I would take her once a month to the clinic to get what she thought was a vitamin shot. No more worry about whether she had taken her meds. that day or any day thereafter. Most people do not know that the pills can be replaced with a once-a-month injection. This discovery came after many years of struggle getting her to take her meds orally. This was a lifesaver for me as well as her.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
wearealldoingtimeat 02:00 on November 17th, 2008
Great Information Mary~`Here is additonal information to add ~~
Humanitarian Prison Crisis Must Be Solved - A Call to Stand Up
http://newsblaze.com/story/20081116235412zzzz.nb/topstory.html
Theresa Vaughn, Loving Mother of the late Timothy Souders (mentally challenged in prison) will be flying in from Michigan for this important rally,she comes in solidarity, in support of families with loved ones in prison~~below is Timmy's story~~
http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=2458916n
at 03:09 on November 17th, 2008
Thank you, WeAreAllDoingTime! If you speak to Theresa, please tell her that my situation regarding those who would seek to control what I publish are working overtime, as I am. However, they cannot change the truth of the message, and neither can they control me. Here is why: I decided to get up, stand up! Stand up for my rights!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m0NglnPkglU
My mother celebrated her 86th birthday yesterday, and I want to invite all of you to celebrate with us. Come to this link! It is on! http://www.care2.com/c2c/share/detail/954174
When Larry died under secret arrest as a mentally ill heart patient in Shelby County Jail, Memphis, TN, and the Johnnie Cochran Firm made fools of us when we depended on that firm to be our wrongful death attorney, my mother recognized her limitations. She was already 80. Like any mother would, she wants justice for her "special" child. Her children promised that we will do what needs to be done, and our justice quest began with my efforts. Along the way, it became not just a quest for justice regarding the wrongful death of Larry Neal, but a determination to bring Assistance to the Incarcerated Mentally Ill all over America. What a battle! But I know the battle is ALREADY WON. God never sends His children to fight until He has already gone before them and slayed the enemy. Like a flower is dead when it is cut but keeps looking and smelling healthy for a week, so is the system already dead that criminalizes mental illness. It is over, but they continue fight not realizing the futility of the struggle. It may take years to actually end this practice, but as more voters become aware of it, it will definitely end.
Americans are decent people who care about justice and about their fellow human beings. The only way to have American taxpayers facilitate such an evil system that punishes vulnerable, sick people for being sick is by withholding the information from them and spreading disinformation. Taxpayers did not realize that it costs three times as much to imprison mental patients than to treat them. But this is over now, thanks to the efforts of people like you. The truth is being told widely, and many are demanding CHANGE.
I appreciate your valuable comments.
Mary
- Sign In or Join to post comments
wearealldoingtimeat 02:13 on November 17th, 2008
The guards bring in any drug or contraband the prisoners want. Prisons are giving us little or no value for our taxpayer dollar and they are not healing places.
We have known for ten years that a prisoner dies every day but records have been withheld, distorted, destroyed and the corruption and cronyism within the society of the punishers who control our state has even excluded the media.
What we don't know is how many prisoners die in the hospitals, die shortly after release from long-neglected chronic ailments. We do not know many are maimed and sustain permanent disabilities due to careless double-celling decisions of the mentally disordered happening more frequently than ever.
The California Department of Corrections (no rehab is deserved here in this title), has passed another unlawful underground regulation that gives custody the power to overrule mental health professionals on double-celling issues. The wardens and administrators think that this underground regulation will protect them from coming legal actions and complaints filed with American Disabilities, but it won't hold up in a federal court.
Title 18 of the USC (US Civil Code) Sections 241 and 242, as well as California Penal Code 2652, 2653(a) clearly stipulate that custody does not have legal authority to over rule a mental health professional.
Our jailhouse lawyers have already challenged two of the CDCr underground regulations and won, so it is time to rally together and file another legal action on this outrageous practice.
There are some mental health professionals who have prostituted the ethics of their profession. CDCr will simply transfer an inmate to an institution where the psychologists will declare former recommendations invalid. We have one such prostitute in the form of Dr. Rusty Otto at Sierra Conservation Center who in collaboration with Warden Ivan Clay, is about to put a prisoner who was declared to be in need of single cell status by 30 doctors at five prisons no longer eligible.
This type of deliberate indifference is inexcusable and will be dealt with in every legal manner possible~~more
at 08:30 on November 17th, 2008
Thanks for your comments. I don't know much about Calif. penal system, but I was struck by what you wrote:
"We have known for ten years that a prisoner dies every day but records have been withheld, distorted, destroyed and the corruption and cronyism within the society of the punishers who control our state has even excluded the media."
This seems to be what occurred in the wrongful death of Larry Neal, my brother, but I had no idea it was such a widespread problem. I noticed none of the authorities I contacted seemed particularly surprised or incensed about the injustice, and I guess the fact that such things are usual and ordinary for our most vulnerable citizens is why. Well, I am real amazed at the cruelty, the lack of judicial process, the absolute in-your-face denial of citizens' civil rights, which they did not lose the day they lost their reasoning skills. Many other people are and will be amazed, also. Let us keep telling the taxpayers until things CHANGE!
See http://wrongfuldeathoflarryneal.com
Mary
at 11:08 on November 17th, 2008
This story just made Care2News Network's Front Page. Thanks again, NowPublic.com for use of this forum to publicize the plight of our vulnerable citizens.
Congratulations! The Care2 Community has promoted your submission to
the Care2 News Network Front Page.
In recognition for this outstanding achievement, you've
also been awarded a "Golden Note".
Thank you for contributing to the Care2 Community!
- Sign In or Join to post comments
Jenny Dooley (not verified)at 18:35 on November 17th, 2008
Congratulations on making the front page of Care2 News Network!
Congratulations on your excellent reporting!
at 19:37 on November 17th, 2008
Thank you, Jenny! And thanks again establishing a presence for Assistance to the Incarcerated Mentally Ill at Ellen's Community Network! Now, many more taxpayers will learn what is really happening with their tax dollars. The mentally ill were never deinstitutionalized, as most of us believed. They were merely relocated from hospital environments promoting healing and long-term care to prisons, at a much greater cost to taxpayers.
Check out A.I.M.I. on The Ellen DeGeneres Network:
http://community.ellentv.com/group/aimi