Save Sgt. Russel Petition Launched by AIMI

by duo | May 22, 2009 at 07:15 am
519 views | 2 Recommendations | 11 comments

Thumbnails



WAR ON TERROR AND SOLDIERS WITH PTSD


SGT. JOHN RUSSEL, an American soldier near the end of his third consecutive tour of duty in the War on Terror, allegedly walked into a Baghdad combat stress clinic and opened fire on his comrades, killing five.  It was the most tragic PTSD-related event on military record. Sgt. Russel was charged with murder. On May 21, Assistance to the Incarcerated Mentally Ill ("AIMI") launched a petition requesting that murder charges against Sgt. John Russel be dropped.  AIMI is an grass roots organization that advocates online to decriminalize mental illness. 

PETITION TO SAVE SGT. RUSSEL
Hospitals, Not Prison for Sick Soldiers & Vets!

http://www.thepetitionsite.com/1/Save-Sgt-Russel

Sgt. Russel is a 44-year-old Texan who has many years in the U.S. Army.  He suffers from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD).  When his superiors noticed his deteriorating mental health, Sgt. Russel was ordered into therapy for stress.  The sick soldier suffered a psychotic episode while at Camp Liberty's stress clinic in Baghdad and left under armed guard. Sgt. Russel allegedly overpowered a guard during the drive away from the clinic, took a weapon, then returned into the clinic and killed five men.



Update 6/3/09 - Some people may wonder how Sgt. Russel's family feel about former Vice President Dick Cheney's June 1 interview with FOX News wherein he stated there was no evidence linking Iraq to America's 9/11 attack.  Many soldiers enlisted and others re-enlisted believing that Iraq was behind the terrorist attacks (see the VIDEO at the link below).

Former VP Cheney Admits There Was NEVER Any Evidence Tying Iraq to 9/11 http://my.nowpublic.com/world/never-any-evidence-tying-iraq-9-11-says-former-vp-cheney



"While soldiers killing their own is rare in Iraq, Russel's shooting was not the first.  In September, a soldier killed two of his superiors at a base south of Baghdad. And another soldier was sentenced to death for killing two officers in Kuwait just before the 2003 invasion" wrote  Stephanie Gaskell, Daily News Staff Writer (May 12).  

AIMI strongly objects to any stressed-out soldier like Sgt. Russel spending his life as a POW or being eligible for execution.  "Approximately 1.25 million mentally ill persons are presently imprisoned in America, including thousands of veterans who were severely traumatized by war experiences from Korea to Afghanistan," said AIMI's founder, Mary Neal.  "Homelessness, prison and death must cease being America's answers to mental illness, particularly for vets who get sick serving their country." 

Neal, who writes articles centered around justice issues,  published the following article in March:  "What About Our Soldiers? A Discussion on PTSD, by Mary Neal” at http://www.care2.com/c2c/share/detail/1090358

"Soldiers who are amputees or otherwise handicapped during wars are eligible for lifetime benefits and are afforded all of the allowances that society willingly makes to ensure the inclusion of physically handicapped persons in society:  wheelchair ramps, reserved parking, special services for the blind or hearing-impaired, and more.  But a soldier like Sgt. Russel who loses his mind instead of a limb is eligible for prison or execution?  That is wrong!"  Neal asserted.

Between the stars below is the language on the Petition to Save Sgt. Russel.  The actual petiton can be opened and the signator's comments reviewed without the necessity of signing the petition at this link:  http://www.thepetitionsite.com/1/Save-Sgt-Russel

***************************************

PETITION TO SAVE SGT. RUSSEL ~ Hospitals, Not Prison for Sick Soldiers & Vets!
http://www.thepetitionsite.com/1/Save-Sgt-Russel

Target:  President Obama, Commander in Chief

Sponsored by:  Assistance to the Incarcerated Mentally Ill ("AIMI")

Sgt. JOHN M. RUSSELL is a 44-year-old communication specialist from Sherman, Texas who served 11 years in the U.S. Army.  Sgt. Russel was near the end of his third tour in Iraq when he allegedly gunned down five fellow service members at a Baghdad combat stress clinic.  Sgt. Russel has been charged with murder.  This sick soldier is no cold-blooded killer. 

Sgt. Russel was himself the first of six victims of his bout with PTSD, for which he was receiving treatment.  Sgt. Russel's breakdown should have been recognized sooner, and he should have been sent home. 

"We've never, I don't believe, had a force that we've put through seven years of continuous combat like this, where such a large percentage of the force is going on these multiple deployments," said Gen. Peter Chiarelli, the Army's vice chief of staff and point man on mental health issues.

"They broke him," Sgt. Russel's father, Wilburn Russell said, wiping away tears.  Before the shooting, Russell had e-mailed his wife to tell her "his life was over," his father said.

The undersigned demand that murder charges against Sgt. Russel be dropped.  He deserves care and support, not prison.  We protest American military personnel coming home to America and becoming PRISONERS OF WAR after serving their country and breaking under the strain of repeated combat missions.

DECRIMINALIZE MENTAL ILLNESS.  No one can be punished or rehabilitated into a state of mental health.

NO MAN LEFT BEHIND!

     ~  
A 2007 Army survey of soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan showed that soldiers' mental health deteriorates significantly each time they go to war.

     ~   Overall, the Army's suicide rate reached a record level in 2008 and is still climbing.

     ~   More than 27%of the noncommissioned officers surveyed on their third or fourth deployment reported depression, anxiety or acute stress -- compared with 18% of those on their second deployment and 11% on their first tour.






Better security should have been in place.  During a psychotic episode, Sgt. Russel was being escorted from the mental health clinic at Camp Liberty when he overpowered a guard and took his weapon. "They escorted him out with a guy with a gun," Wilburn Russell said. "That was the worst thing they could have done.

Many veterans from Viet Nam, Desert Storm, Iraq and Afghanistan are imprisoned today for inappropriate behavior caused by PTSD, along with 1.25 million other mentally challenged people.  Psychiatric patients should be either be committed to quality mental hospitals or released under an Assisted Outpatient Treatment program, depending on their offenses. 

We demand that Sgt. Russel not join the ranks of America's incarcerated mentally ill, none of whom should be imprisoned, but treated instead!

HOMELESSNESS, PRISON, AND DEATH MUST CEASE BEING AMERICA's ANSWER TO MENTAL ILLNESS.

NO MAN LEFT BEHIND!

_______________
Factual content for this petition is from Washington Post at http://www.washingtonpost.com/  and  USA Today at http://www.usatoday.com/news  

***********************************************

AIMI members hope that many military families and other concerned people will agree that Sgt. Russel is not a criminal, but a career soldier who was wounded serving his country and now deserves treatment and support like any wounded soldier, not prison.

This link carries an important  VIDEO called  "Gratitude": 
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MSfFYxSdKdo&feature=player_embedded 

AIMI members sympathize with the five families whose loved ones so tragically died.  The fact that Sgt. Russel's doctors and supervisors did not recognize it was time to relieve him of active duty and send him home is indeed unfortunate. It was common knowledge around the base that Sgt. Russel had lost his reasoning skills.  According to a NY Daily News.com report, one of the sick soldier's  victims told his mom about Sgt. Russel’s mental meltdown during a phone call on Mother’s Day.  www.nydailynews.com/news/us_world/2009/05/12/2009-05-12_army_broke_him_says_dad_of_sgt_in_kill_spree.html 

Mary Neal began advocating on behalf of imprisoned mentally ill prisoners after her 54-year-old brother, Larry Neal, died on August 1, 2003, after 18 days of secret arrest in Shelby County Jail in Memphis, Tennessee.  Larry was a lifelong mental patient who was diagnosed as being paranoid schizophrenic at eight years of age and spent over 20 years as an inpatient in a mental institution until many mental hospitals closed in the 1970's.  More information about Larry and AIMI's origin is available at this website:  http://wrongfuldeathoflarryneal.com

AIMI has over 200 members who are mostly Americans working together to raise public awareness about their perceived  injustice of imprisoning people for being sick and secondly, to help destroy the stigma associated with mental illness that is frequently a barrier to treatment.  They regularly petition lawmakers to decriminalize that health condition. AIMI has a presence on several online networks, including Prison Hearts, the Ellen Degeneres Show network.  AIMI's main site is at Care2 at this link: http://www.Care2.com/c2c/groups/AIMI

AIMI is also known as the Dorothea Dix Group. Dorothea Lynde Dix (April 4, 1802 - July 17, 1887) was a human rights advocate who worked diligently to decriminalize mental illness in the 1800's.  As the daughter of a mentally ill man, Dix sympathized with sick people and their families.  She visited jails and prisons across America and parts of Europe and wrote reports to lawmakers detailing the cruel circumstances under which the mentally ill lived.  During her prison visits, Dix frequently observed mentally challenged inmates brutally beaten while chained to prison walls, naked and living in filth.  She successfully lobbied state legislatures, and 30 public psychiatric hospitals were created.  In 1880, 40 years after she began her efforts, a census taken in U.S. jails found that only 0.7% of inmates suffered from mental illness.  More information about Dorothy Dix is available at these links:  http://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/cgi/content/full/160/7/1245 
and
http://www.care2.com/c2c/share/detail/865865.

****************************

MARY'S COMMENTARY

What happened was either the Army's fault or nobody's, but don't blame that sick soldier.  That would not be fair. 
Who keeps loaded guns around psychotic people?  We are lucky Sgt. Russel did not pick up a grenade instead of a handgun!  The man should have been secured someplace on base until he could be shipped out.  Everyone knew his condition, including his superiors.  But as usual, the higher-ups want to shift blame and put another person in bonds for life or even execute him.  That is wrong. 

If we don’t put the responsibility for this tragedy where it belongs, the tragedy could repeat again soon, and next time it could be a grenade!  There are many sick soldiers in Iraq.  Furthermore, they will be transitioning back home to a mall near you real soon.  It is time for America to Change.  Mandatory treatment and hospitalization must be allowed more easily.  More inpatient and community mental health facilities need to be built or refurbished right now to prepare for the expected increase in sick Americans that the War on Terror caused.  Or do prison profiteers plan to eventually arrest half of our vets and make money off them, too? 

War and prison profiteers do not belong in government office.  They should get out of judicial robes and congressional chairs right now, because they unnecessarily endanger active duty military servicepersons and veterans who many believe were sent to fight a senseless war.  Our communities are endangered, too, by not doing what is needed for mentally ill offenders, including  hospital commitment for violent offenders, like Sgt. Russel.  Sick people should not be imprisoned or executed.  Enforced treatment and subsistance assistance programs are needed for non-violent mentally ill offenders to help them live safely in their communities and avoid homelessness, prison, and death.  War and prison profiteers should go home and count their lovers – Ben Franklins!

Acute mental patients must not be left untreated until they kill somebody so that prison investors can multiply $50,000 annually times the expected lifespans of offenders."

Sgt. Russel's father reported that the career soldier felt persecuted and rejected when his superiors ordered him into treatment at Camp Liberty stress clinic.  The sargent's son said that his father is a non-violent man.  The family is baffled and hurt by what happened to Sgt. Russel and to his comrades.  Soldiers who are obviously suffering PTSD should not be escorted AWAY from psychiatric help like Sgt. Russel was.  Sgt. Russel's erratic behavior at the stress clinic demonstrated his need for someone responsible to step in and restrain him, which would have saved Sgt. Russel and five others.

No one who commits murder should go free, but violent mentally ill offenders like Sgt. Russel should serve at least the minimum sentence for their offenses in mental hospitals, not prison.  No early release by their psychiatrists should be possible. Treatment in mental hospitals costs no more than treatment while imprisoned for offenses mentally ill people either could not understand or lacked the wherewithal to avoid.  Sgt. Russel's case demonstrates once again that waiting until there are dead bodies before enforcing treatment is a mistake.

Most often, mentally dysfunctional people do not go from 20 mph to 140 mph in seconds.  Sgt. Russel practically wore a sign saying, 'Sick Soldier on Base!  HELP!'  Usually neighbors, relatives, co-workers or medical personnel - whoever is around them - will notice changes that mean trouble.  For instance, Seung-Hui Cho, who was responsible for the Virginia Tech massacre was declared mentally ill by a Virginia special justice.[3]  At least one professor had asked him to seek counseling.  Source:  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virginia_Tech_massacre

Acknowledging the responsibility to treat and not punish military personnel who lose their mental health serving the country is to provide REAL support for our troops - support that matters to them and their families and helps keep communities safe.  Whether or not petitioners agree with the war should not matter.  Sgt. Russel laid his life on the line repeatedly and lost his mental stability.  Now he needs us.

**********************************

More AIMI petitions are at these links:

Justice for Jeremy Smith and Other Mentally Ill Americans:   http://www.thepetitionsite.com/1/JusticeForJeremy

Petitions Supported by AIMI
http://www.care2.com/c2c/share/detail/959091  and

Save Andre Thomas and Protest Executions of Mentally Ill Americans!
http://www.thepetitionsite.com/1/No-Executing-Mental-Patients  

Please see more articles by this writer at the Articles link in the signature block below. 

Your feedback is invited in the rich text comments area after the signature block and/or on Sgt. Russel's petition.

Mary Neal  
Radio Interview:
  http://www.blogtalkradio.com/stations/HeadingLeft/wakeupcallshow/2008/01/22/TBA

Articles:
  http://nowPublic.com/duo

Care2 Page:
http://www.care2.com/c2c/people/profile.html?pid=513396753

AIMI Photo Album:  http://www.care2.com/c2c/photos/view/217/513396753/AIMI_Photo_Album/

CONTACT INFORMATION

Mailing Address:
  P.O. Box 7222, Atlanta, GA  30357
e-Mail addresses: marylovesjustice@gmail.com
















Advertisement
recommend This comment thread is now closed
1
Donnie Anderson

Good Article, I would suggest reading this book:

Mental Wards to Blackboards are stories of psychiatric nursing. Some will make you laugh, some will make you cry, but will enrich your understanding of mental health. http://books.trafford.com/08-0191

 

0
duo

Thanks, Donnie.  I appreciate the suggested reading.  I feel encouraged by your doing so.  Did you sign Sgt. Russel's petition?  Please consider standing with a lonely vet who has laid it all on the line for his country and lost everything - even his mind and his freedom.

0
duo

There was never any evidence tying Iraq to 9/11, according to former Vice President Cheney in a recent interview with FOX News.  See the VIDEO at this article:
http://my.nowpublic.com/world/never-any-evidence-tying-iraq-9-11-says-former-vp-cheney

0
duo

SAVE SGT. RUSSEL petition experiences cybersecurity issues.  

FIRST of all, when I opened the petition that is the subject of this article, I tried to use the same petition site that carries our petition DOG JUSTICE FOR THE MENTALLY ILL:
www.petitiononline.com/Neal/petition.html   - I entered all the language on that petition, but it was not allowed to publish.  The censorship force prefer for me to use Care2, because those who have a keystroke virus on my home PC will be able to use my password and delete signatures from Sgt. Russel's petition.  Petitions online are unreliable except as a way to encourage conversation and support around a given issue.

6 of the 10 questions I entered on a PollDaddy survey regarding Sgt. Russel were not allowed to publish.  See the survey at this link:  http://Surveys.polldaddy.com/s/C73BDA71A6A492FF/

*THE QUESTIONS ARE BACK ON THIS PETITION. - 8/1/9

Below are the questions that were deleted from the survey. 

MISSING FROM PAGE 1:
QUESTION 4  -- Are you or do you have an immediate family member who is or was in the military? If so, name the branch of service and your relationship to the person - whether self, spouse, son, daughter, sibling, parent, grandparent, or grandchild.

MISSING FROM PAGE 2:
QUESTION 6 -- Are you or someone you care about mentally ill?

QUESTION 7 -- Have you or a loved one ever been arrested or hospitalized due to a mental health crisis?

QUESTION 8 -- America incarcerates more people than any other nation in world history - 2.3 million people, and two-thirds of them are imprisoned for non-violent offenses.  Our prison budget is $50 billion annually.  Taxpayers are billed up to $50,000 per year per inmate, and considerably more for mentally ill or dying inmates.  Each death row inmate costs $90,000 more per year than maximum security prisoners serving life without parole sentences.  Do you have ideas for reducing prison costs?

QUESTION 9 -- How important is religion to you when making decisions about where you stand on human rights matters?  (Multiple choice - choose one)
1)  My religion is very important in making decisions about human rights issues.
2)  Religion is irrelevant in making my decisions regarding human rights
3)  Undecided

QUESTION 10 -- Thousands of veterans who served in combat zones from Viet Nam to Iraq are in prison due to inappropriate behavior related to PTSD that resulted from their military service.  Do you have more comments about Sgt. Russel's PTSD episode or mental health matters in general? 

The only questions the censorship force left other than my one mandatory question (multiple choice - prison or hospital for Sgt. Russel) were the questions that would help the monitor the respondents, i.e., their email address, their URL, and an open paragraph to write what they thought about Sgt. Russel's predicament.  The open paragraph space was probably allowed so that the censorship squad could gauge the educational level of respondents and assess whether or not they belong on the first train or second load to the camps.

0
duo

At PollDaddy I was blocked from commenting at my own poll.  Sgt. Russel's poor dad and all the moms and dads of service personnel need to know that only physical wounds are allowed in the U.S. Army.  http://answers.polldaddy.com/poll/1646410/?msg=spam

Military people and others care about veterans' mental as well as physical war wounds, so that is why the SAVE SGT. RUSSEL petition suffers attack. http://www.care2.com/c2c/share/detail/1150061

There is an effort to portray Sgt. Russel not as a wounded American soldier, but as a cold-blooded killer.  Therefore, there is also online resistance against my displaying the photograph of  Sgt. Russel in dress uniform, whereon he looks successful and proud with many medals earned during a long military career displayed on his jacket.

Happy Memorial Day!

0
duo

PsychCentral
Jan. 2008
http://psychcentral.com/news/2008/01/16/ptsd-triples-among-military/1790.html
Self-reported post-traumatic stress disorder has elevated 3-fold among combat-exposed military personnel since 2001, according to a study reported in the British Medical Journal.

0
duo

The Army reports that Sgt. Russel is imprisoned in Kuwait.

Army Times
May 20, 2009
http://www.armytimes.com/news/2009/05/ap_russell_kuwait_051909/

0
McDillon

Wow, what a load of liberal softhearted horsesh@t. I am beyond awe at the complete and utter ignorance displayed in this blog. I suppose one would suggest that the “escort” should have abandoned their weapon in a hostile environment such that they could transport a patient. THEY ARE IN A WAR ZONE. I suppose that NEVER happens in the USA (ask a cop to disarm when transporting a perp, or a confirmed mentally incompetent person between stay-cations for the mentally ill).

Here is the basic fact….if some psycho-sick f@ck whacks 5 people (unarmed people), then he should get the needle, not a hallmark card and a pat on the back. Lets keep in focus about who the victim is (are).

0
duo

I do not suggest that the soldier should have disarmed to transport Sgt. Russel.  I suggest that Sgt. Russel was known to have had a mental meltdown long before any of this happened, and he should have been removed from duty and placed in a mental health facility until transfer back to the States. 

It was obvious to the people on base that Sgt. Russel had lost it.  One of his victims even talked to his mom about the soldier who had a bad case of PTSD during his Mother's Day telephone call with her.  I suggest that it is irresponsible and dangerous for mental ill persons in crisis and people who are in their immediate vacinity to ignore signs of trauma until there are dripping knives and smoking guns and bodies lying here and there.  The sick person is not to be blamed, but the supposedly well people who see the problem and do nothing about it.

Sgt. Russel's mental state was such that he was asked to report to the clinic.  He should have been left no choice when he got there about whether or not to submit to treatment.  He went to the only place on base to help with his illness, and he was SENT AWAY because his erratic behavior proved how much he needed help.  Now you tell me what sense that makes, because I don't get it. 

Yes, guards should have been called when Sgt. Russel started shouting at the clinic personnel, but the guards should have restrained him and a sedative administered. The soldier should have been restrained and transferred to a full-service mental hospital.  Then Sgt. Russel would not be in prison and five people would be alive today.  Punishing a sick person for exhibiting sick behavior is like punishing a baby for cooing when it cannot talk.  The only behavior possible for a person who is undergoing a psychotic crisis is psychotic behavior.  Is that a hard concept to understand?

There is no excuse in most cases when mental patients kill themselves or others for the tragedy to occur.  Sick people don't go from 5 mph to 120 in seconds like cars.  They show plenty of signs of intensifying psychosis before they actually kill anyone.  The Army should have removed the sick soldier from the possibility of harm to himself or others -- not wait until he did something awful.  The same thing happened regarding the Virginia Tech massacre.  I am glad the families are pushing to re-open the case.  Numerous people had reported that Cho was mentally ill and potentially dangerous before his rampage. But no one did anything about it.  His parents had him in mental health treatments until he was 17, but they could not enforce treatment after he reached the age to decide for himself whether to continue psychiatric care.  I suggest that it should be easier to enforce treatment timely.  See the excerpt below.

Parents: Reopen Virginia Tech massacre investigation
USA Today

Families of the Virginia Tech shooting victims want the state to reopen its investigation into the 2007 rampage in which 32 people died, The Roanoke Times and Associated Press report.  The request Tuesday to Gov. Tim Kaine follows the disclosure last week that the mental health records of student gunman Seung Hui Cho had been found in the home of the former director of the university's counseling center.  http://blogs.usatoday.com/ondeadline/2009/07/parents-reopen-virginia-tech-investigation.html

We have many soldiers returning home from repeated tours of combat duty like Sgt. Russel.  Already there are reports of an increase in crimes done by vets. 

When the mentally ill man went to Hillary Clinton's campaign office and took the staff hostage, reports said that the people in town knew he was mentally ill.  But nothing was done until he endangered himself and the campaign workers.

Many need care - enforced treatment if they do not agree to it.  When a mental patient is stabilized, he will thank you for helping him and not waiting until he has killed his family or neighbors before finally enforcing care in prison.  No one asks sick people after a murder if they want care.  We need to stop waiting on deaths to enforce treatment.  That is what I suggest, sir.  And we should stop imprisoning people for being sick.  Some people need long-term hospital care - even decades - and it costs no more than treatment in prisons.

Thanks for writing.  Please see more of my articles by clicking the dogs.  See if they won't help you understand the issue better.

Mary

0
McDillon

Mary,

I am fully versed in sociological and psychological induced stress and trauma. I have had the fortune of providing instruction and patient card/interaction with regards to PTSD. That said, I find it dismal at best, that one could assume that they are intact of all the facts in this case. Regurgitating media induced Dx and jumping on the “lets-help-the-poor-guy-out” mentality would, at best, demonstrate of nonfunctional understanding of the circumstances surrounding this event. How is one capable of deriving the conditions, circumstances, events leading to, clinical evaluations, and care that may/ may not have been provided to Sgt. Russell? Are you even remotely aware of the procedures that could be required to “sedate” (physically incapacitate with chemical means) a soldier in a hostile environment? Was sedation deemed appropriate? Did the soldier exhibit clinical signs consistent with a valid DX? Was the soldier etc…. I would find it hard to believe that you would be cognizant of any of these issues, yet you make some grandiose statement as to the mental state(s) of Sgt. Russel. Again, I am in awe. I look forward to the trial.  After the trial, I will revisit my current views and adjust if needed.

And as for the increase in crime post-deployment by soldiers, I can completely agree with you. Not only is there a predisposition for violence, adrenal seeking behavour, lowered social economic class that correlates well with enlisted soldiers, but the soldiers obviously have been exposed to a heightened state of constant stress (kinda sounds like cops and firefighters…hum). However, I would much rather walk the streets after dark in the presence of combat vets, any day over walking in the ghetto. The cases that we hear about are but few and far between, and are glorified by the media. I think the military is providing exceptional mental health care in an unbiased, and INFORMED manner.....McDillon

0
duo

Thanks for the feedback, McDillon.  Sgt. Russel was said to be a "non-violent" man by his son.  Was he ever violent before?  Was there anything at all in his background that would give the Army or anyone else reason to believe he would just start shooting people because he did not like something they said or whatever prompted his actions?  Did he have a criminal record?  If not PTSD, to what do you account the breakdown that led to the worst case of murders on comrades by military personnel that the Army has seen?  You wrote that I "make some grandiose statements as to the mental state(s) of Sgt. Russel."  Your implication is clear.  But, McDillon, if a tree has apples hanging on its branches and dropping on the ground around it, I call it an apple tree.  I don't have to pull a leaf and send it to a botany lab for evaluation first.

You asked, "Are you even remotely aware of the procedures that could be required to “sedate” (physically incapacitate with chemical means) a soldier in a hostile environment?"

Yes, I have an idea that it might take three clerks working non-stop a day or two to fill out all the forms for his supervisors and clinic personnel to request permission from a myriad of parties.  Their request to enforce mental health care for Sgt. Russel might then be reviewed by a conference room full of Army doctors, which would then be reviewed by a number of other officers, and Sgt. Russel's superiors and Camp Liberty might receive a determination within in a month or two as to whether they could restrain Sgt. Russel and enforce mental health treatment.  That is exactly my point, McDillon.  But none of that was necessary to arrest him and charge him with murder, was it?  That was immediate and streamlined.  The same is true in civilian life, and it creates tragic events like this relatively often.  Sometimes the mentally ill person is killed by suicide or police officers, and other times, as the Virginia Tech case proves, dozens are subject to slaughter.

If something is not done about the red tape that is involved in getting help for sick people before tragedies, McDillon, we will keep having avoidable tragedies like the one at Virginia Tech, where numerous teachers and others had complained that Cho was sick and possibly very dangerous, but nothing was done.  His parents had him in treatment, but after he reached age 18, their hands were tied.  Did you know that Cho had been removed from at least one of his classes because the teacher and other students were afraid of him?  Authorities knew about Cho's schizophrenia and that he was going into a mental health crisis, but nothing was done.  

The Army might have more avoidable deaths like Cho's at Virginia Tech and like Sgt. Russel's PTSD caused at Camp Liberty unless changes are made to streamline the process to help sick soldiers before there are dripping knives and smoking guns, McDillon.

When people used to ride passenger trains like in the old movies I watch, there was a procedure for exiting.  One waited until one reached the train stop designated on one's ticket.  When the conductor announced the city of one's destination, the passenger gathered his bags and disembarked from the train.  But there was a cord that could be pulled to make the train stop immediately!  The system in place now works to protect mentally ill people's right to decide their own treatment.  That is fine up to a point.  But there should also be an emergency break that can be pulled to say, "Hey!  This cannot wait for competency hearings.  This cannot wait for days or weeks of deliberation!  This person is sick  - acting weird as heck, so pull the emergency break and let's get him off the train and into a secure environment for his own good and the safety of the other people!"  I have no doubt Sgt. Russel would thank the Army today if he had not been allowed to kill his comrades while in a psychotic crisis.  Instead, five people are dead, and he imprisoned.

Sometimes, red tape gets folks killed.  Truly sick people almost never agree they are sick.

Thanks again for your feedback.  Please give consideration to my point of view, and if you are in a position to help establish a streamlined process for Army officers, especially those in combat zones, to prevent sick soldiers from possibly hurting themselves and/or others, please address this.  The families of the Virginia Tech victims are pushing now to get the panel that investigated the massacre reconvened.  I hope they can do that, because we must equip authorities to safeguard sick people as well as people who are left defenseless without warning when authorities know that someone has lost their sense of reason and might be in danger or is potentially dangerous to others. 

In the meanwhile, let us all praise God that Sgt. Russel did not have granades or a machine gun handy.

Blessings!

Mary

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

NowPublic on Facebook

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Samir Joshi
First Flagged at 9:38 AM, May 22, 2009 by Samir Joshi
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in Health

Recommendations (2)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from