NP Rank:
Scientists Use Their Own Children as Test Subjects
Scientific researchers in the US are resorting to using their own children as test subjects in response to a shortage of available volunteers.
Massachusetts Institute of Technology researchers Pawan Sinha and Deb Roy also have used their children to fuel their research ambitions.
Sinha attached a camera to his newborn child's head to capture the child's point of view for an experiment, while Roy placed video cameras and microphones throughout his home to follow his son's daily activities.
Center for Research Integrity Director Robert M. Nelson told the Times such research actions are questionable at best as they can bring about an "unpredictable" situation.
"Once that parent becomes an investigator, it sets up an immediate potential conflict of interest," said Nelson, whose center is located at the Children's Hospital in Philadelphia. "And it potentially takes the parent-child relationship and distorts it in ways that are unpredictable."
The ethics surrounding this practice are debated; the line between unobtrusive observation and potentially harmful testing is about as clear as a line drawn through mud. Not only is it difficult to extricate yourself as a parent from the child and be an objective researcher, but long-term effects might be difficult to accurately forsee.
One researcher concocted an experiment which sounds straight out of The Truman Show:
Deb Roy, at M.I.T., embedded 11 video cameras and 14 microphones in ceilings throughout his house, recording 70 percent of his son’s waking hours for his first three years, amassing 250,000 hours of tape for a language development study he calls the Human Speechome Project.
And what about researchers throughout history - there have been some cases that would not be permissible today:
Jonas Salk injected his children with his polio vaccine. Clarence Leuba, a psychologist, wondering if laughter in response to tickling was learned or innate, forbade tickling of his infant son and daughter, except when he tickled them, wearing a mask to hide his expression.






Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (2)
at 13:16 on January 19th, 2009
Wow..while finding enough money for scientific research is tricky, using own children for scientific tests is a violation of children's rights, in my opinion.
at 13:19 on January 19th, 2009
At least you know the scientists will(hopefully) have the child's best interests in mind. I find it somewhat reassuring.