Six Holiday Myths Exposed

by Blue Crush | December 19, 2008 at 10:37 am
474 views | 61 Recommendations | 9 comments

Photos

85/365=Bundled Up Or Just Stealthy?

85/365=Bundled Up Or Just Stealthy?

see larger image

uploaded by tybeaver

The holiday season is upon us.  But as we rush to finish up our holiday errands, make sure you wear a hat while outside, find that perfect hangover cure, be careful to curb the late night snacks, and keep the kiddies away from all those sugary products, as well as the  poinsettias.

Or are those myths?  Such myths have "hit the dust" in the Christmas issue of the British Medical Journal.  They've asked two physicians to take a look at some of those old adages that everyone repeats each holiday season.  The doctors found that some might have reasons behind them, but found no solid backing after a large number of studies.

Sugar Makes Kids Hyperactive - at least 12 studies have shown that there is no evidence to support this belief – sugar is not to blame for out of control kids.  "While sugar can give a quick burst of energy, " says Keith Ayoob, a registered dietitian, "it doesn't cause hyperactivity and there are tons of studies to show this."

Suicides increase over the holidays - Researchers find that suicides actually tend to come in the warmer months of the year, and among youth, rates are at the highest at the end of a school year.  But while suicides are not an annual epidemic around the holidays, Mark Kaplan, a professor of community health at Portland State University and a member of the Suicide Prevention Action Network USA's National Scientific Advisory Council notes that this year may be a bit different, because of the economic downtrend. 

Poinsettia Toxicity - Despite hundreds of thousands of calls to poison control centers over poinsettia poisonings, no one has ever died from ingesting them, most did not even need medical treatment.

Excess Heat Loss in the Hatless - There's a strongly held belief that we lose 40-50% of our body heat through our head.  Not so.  If it's cold outside, it makes sense to wrap up warm, but covering your head doesn't make a big difference.

Eating a Lot at Night Will Make You Fat - They noted that people gain weight because they take in more calories overall than they burn up.  Most heavy night eaters are heavy eaters at all times of the day.  They say that skipping breakfast, however, may lead to weight gain, since it leads people to overeat at other meals.

You Can Cure a Hangover - The good news, said Carroll and Vreeman, is that hangovers are completely preventable.  "The most effective way to avoid a hangover is to consume alcohol only in moderation or not at all," she writes.  They say the only way to end a hangover is to wait it out, with time and fluids.  There is no scientific evidence to support any cure or effective prevention for alcohol hangovers

So What? - The message of these myths, say the authors of the article, is that people should be more inquisitive when they hear these kinds of statements, whether from a parent, teacher or doctor.  "If a doctor doesn't have a good answer, they should go find out why," said Aaron Carroll, director of the Center for Health Policy and Professionalism Research at the Indiana University School of Medicine.  "We're trying to illustrate that you should ask why. It's always a good idea to ask why. I guess we're trying to promote a healthy scepticism, especially when it comes to health and medical issues."

This was the second straight year that Carroll and his colleague, Dr. Rachel C. Vreeman, took a look at some holiday myths for the journal.  

recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
Amy Judd

I'm surprised about the eating at night issue - I would have thought that would have been true for sure.

0
Terri Potratz

Myths debunked!  This will be fun to talk about over the Christmas dinner table.

0
harringtola

I always thought that pets (cats especially) are more susceptible to expiring after partaking of the poinsettia plant. I guess that is also a myth. Very interesting and good news really.

0
Rachel Nixon

I'm sceptical about the hat thing. Still, if it means I can now go hatless and avoid the dreaded hat hair, that can only be good.

0
politisite

I think that there is an issue with new borns.  My ex who worked in a NICU and all the babies had head covering.

0
politisite

Well done. 

Suicides increase over the holidays- while depression increases during the holidays and many folks consider suicide they tend not have the energy to pull it off.  The suicide rate spikes in early Spring when depressed folks begin to get better.

 In therapy it is very important to remember this as anti-depressants take effect the chance of suicide increases initially.  While many general practitioners begin to terminate treatment, it is probably the worst time to do so.

When I worked in Alaska, our suicide rate was higher in April not Jan or Feb.  this was because those who suffered from Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD) would begin to come out of the funk following the Equinox.

Thanks for the great work and good read.

0
dunkelberg

As a recovering professional reporter, I can tell you that assignment editors hold these myths to be dear.

Once the myth about suicides increasing over the holidays was debunked, that story was replaced by the story saying the old story about suicides increasing over the holidays was a myth. 

Thus, the myth and the story count are maintained.

It doesn't matter, really.  So often truths and science are cast aside in favor of "there's this guy I knew who ..." and other anectdotal garbage that fits more comfortably in some mindsets.

0
politisite

I agree with you as I held to that belief as well.  In real practice in Alaska I found out what was real and a wives tale.  Very well put.  No Wonder. Now I know you had pro experience.

0
kanniduba

kanniduba has contributed a photo to this story.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Amy Judd
First Flagged at 11:11 AM, Dec 19, 2008 by Amy Judd
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (61)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from