Spanking May Lower A Child's IQ

by candice.tsuei | September 25, 2009 at 12:45 pm
873 views | 24 Recommendations | 3 comments

The more a child's is spanked, the lower his or her IQ compared with others, according to a new study by one of North America's foremost child psychology experts.

U.S-based sociologist Professor Murray Straus, who studied the impact of spanking for 40 years, presented at the International Conference on Violence, Abuse and Trauma in San Diego, California, and named it the third major U.S. study released this year demonstrating a correlation between physical discipline and a child's intelligence.

He examined the IQ scores of 1,510 children in two age groups - two to four, and five to nine - and retested the children four years later. He found that "the more spanking, the slower the development of the child's mental ability," because at a young age, children do not yet have the ability to deal with stress and get afraid of being hit. Consequently, the psychological stress slows down the rate of development of mental ability.

The 2- to 4-year-old kids who weren't spanked at all, according to their parents, had IQs that were, on average, about five points higher after four years than the kids who were spanked. The same trend held for 5- to 9-year-olds, though the differences were less pronounced.
"The results of this research have major implications for the well-being of children across the globe," he said. "All parents want smart children. This research shows that avoiding smacking and correcting misbehaviour in other ways can help that."

He said corporal punishment is usually coupled with other negative parenting techniques, such as yelling, the removal of privileges or food, which would also be detrimental to a children's mental and emotional development.

Straus' study took into account other potential factors that may affect a child's mental development, such as the family's socio-economic status and the parents' education levels. From surveys done by nearly 18,000 students in 32 countries, he also found that generally countries with high-national-average IQs are the nations that have banned, or do not socially accept, spanking. The exceptions were the top five countries on the average IQ list: Hong Kong Japan, Korea, Taiwan, and Singapore. Straus attributed the discrepancy to a stronger emphasis in those countries on academic excellence. Around the world, two dozen countries have banned spanking by parents and teachers, including Finland, Norway, and Austria.

"Spanking clearly violates the rights of children as individuals. We know that hitting children is not an effective parenting technique," he said. "Just as you wouldn't hit a spouse or a senior parent or someone else you're caring for, you don't hit the most vulnerable people in society: our children."
Advertisement
recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
Hugh Askew

Quote: "The exceptions were the top five countries on the average IQ list: Hong Kong Japan, Korea, Taiwan, and Singapore."  ??????????????

The study finds that the five countries with the highest IQ's allow spanking, and I'm somehow supposed to believe that spanking lowers the IQ level?

Sorry, i ain't buyin'.

( those countries would rule the world - if they would just leave off that spanking routine!)



1
Mary Richard

Never mind lowing IQ (which I tend to believe), it's just not humane.  And spanking teaches kids that violence is ok, it promotes a vicious circle.

"Just as you wouldn't hit a spouse or a senior parent or someone else you're caring for, you don't hit the most vulnerable people in society: our children."
0
Hugh Askew

Quote: "I think that it may be the other way around."

But no, the author of the study clearly states:

"...he also found that generally countries with high-national-average IQs are the nations that have banned, or do not socially accept, spanking. The exceptions were the top five countries on the average IQ list: Hong Kong Japan, Korea, Taiwan, and Singapore. Straus attributed the discrepancy to a stronger emphasis in those countries on academic excellence."

Using the last statement there, you could perhaps say that countries that allow spanking may be lax in promoting academics, tho that is pretty tenuous.  It seems likely the Professor is pushing an agenda in regards to the issue. Making an excuse for the admitted discrepancy - a huge one, btw - calls his conclusion into question.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from