Why are Americans so afraid about Health Care Reform?

by elvisjj | January 20, 2010 at 07:12 pm
2514 views | 46 Recommendations | 8 comments

Why are Americans so afraid about Health Care Reform? You mention the word Health Care Reform and it’s like the spawn of Satan; that all hell will break loose if Health Care Reform is adopted.


It will cost too much, my taxes will go through the roof, we can’t trust big government to run health care but meanwhile we can trust the HMO’s, (Health maintenance organizations for those of you who don’t know what an HMO is) those over sized health care insurance companies who are making record profits each year on the back of the sick, we can surely trust them. There our friends, there sole purpose is to protect us from big government and high taxes and they are there for us when we’re sick and need to be taken care of medical wise. If you believe all that? Well then sonny I got a bridge to sell you and it’s a big one, it’s called the Brooklyn Bridge and it’s for sale you know? Good piece of real estate to nab in this ever growing market of confusion and dismay.


Health Care Reform is nothing new it’s been attempted by Americans many times over and now President Obama has given it a shot in the arm and right now looks like he’s on the losing side of the coin. This mostly do to fear amongst average Americans that Health Care Reform will become like this beast of burden, a demon that will suck up their lives and take away what little they have. Or that it will change Medicare and that it will change the way Americans live. These are all scare tactics and the newly elected Republican Senator Scott Brown played on these fears that most Americans have. It’s like the fear we have that Al Qaeda will strike again with the same blow and effect that 911 had. That’s why we increased our airport security to the point it’s no longer a pleasure to fly but a burden in itself. Fear is what makes human beings act irrational and believe that the world is out to get them. That same fear has been installed into any mention of Health Care Reform let alone Universal Health Care which so many countries already have for their citizens. Only the United States of America, a country as rich and as powerful lacks behind in the world when it comes to health care and providing affordable universal health care to all their citizens not just the elite group of people who can afford it or the very poor that are entitled to Medicare. That leaves a wide gap with the middle class and the average worker who doesn’t have the means or the resources to get health care and what happens when they get sick? In many cases they could lose their homes, all their income, everything over the fact that they merely did the human thing which is get sick and getting sick is something none of us humans have any control over.


In Canada we have Universal Health Care and as much as I support the Americans and I’m a Republican or Conservative which ever one you wish to label me as, but I’m still for Universal Health Care and that every human being regardless of race, color or gender has the right to decent, proper and reliable universal health care. And HMO, these so called giant insurance companies have no rights to turn down a person just because of a premedical condition, or suddenly drop their coverage when they become too expensive for them and they lose valuable profits of that individual. These are just some of the principles that President Obama is fighting to change and their noble ones. Americans themselves should really check out what Health Care Reform really is all about, before jumping on the band wagon and declaring it a bad thing or something evil that is being rammed down their throats by the Obama government and the Democrats.


The real issue lies with what is really Health Care Reform. Too some like newly elected Senator Scott Brown it’s a bad thing. Senator Brown feels the urgency to kill the Health Care Reform bill as he believes that the plans to slash Medicare and raise taxes isn’t his cup of tea or the cup of tea of the people of Massachusetts. Who have been known to throw a really good Boston tea party now and now they wish to do the same with President Obama’s Health Care Reform.


The health care system in Canada was hit hard by the American media saying a lot of things that quite simply wasn’t true. Canada’s health care system isn’t perfect. There can be long wait times for certain medical procedures and surgery or getting a new kidney or a heart there is a waiting list or even if you have to go to the emergency. The wait times could be long, sometimes brutally long. But from a writers stand point I’m had the unfortunate pleasure of checking out the American system and for all it’s worth it doesn’t fair that much better then the Canadian health care system except when it comes down to the bill. In the U.S. you either have health insurance or you’re paying it out of your pocket. Even if you have health insurance in many cases you have to pay a deductable that you pay out of your pocket or your health insurance company could refuse to even cover your medical treatment completely leaving you with the hospital or doctors bill to pay on your own. While in Canada there’s no bill whatsoever, the majority of medical services including any trips to the emergency ward is free to all Canadian citizens. Now mind you there is far better health care in the United States for the elite, upper class who can afford the best health care money can buy. But that makes up only a tiny fraction of the United State population. The bottom line is Americans have build their health care system around those who can afford it and those who can’t and I can’t even estimate how many Americans out there are without health care and are forced to suffer needlessly cause they can’t afford to see a doctor let alone go to the emergency department if they have a serious illness or life threatening emergency cause there afraid they’ll be turned away by the hospital if they don’t have proper health insurance to cover their medical illness.


This never happens to any human beings or citizens of Canada, Britain (the United Kingdom), Spain, and Italy. Even such countries as Trinidad and Tobago have Universal Health Care for all their citizens meaning in short free health care for all their citizens. The Canadian and British system is operated by the government for all of it’s citizens and while it’s not perfect, it does provide the basic health care needs to all it’s citizens including free emergency visits, free doctor visits, free surgery, free follow up and free stays if you are hospitalized with any medical condition not leaving the patient with a medical bill he or she might be paying for, for the rest of his or her life especially if he or she doesn’t have health insurance or their health insurance doesn’t cover it all or suddenly drops them for being a burden on their profit margin.


The World Health Organization ranks Frances as the number one health care system in the world, as France’s system covers everyone and has short wait periods. Meanwhile where does the most powerful and most influential nation in the world the United States of America rank on the list of providing the best health care for its citizens. The United States ranks number 37 to Canada’s 30 and the United Kingdoms 18. And to Colombia’s 22 and Chile’s 33.

Health care should never be a business, it should be about compassion, caring, dignity, and respect and the treatment of getting a human being back on their feet and well again. Not taking them for every penny they have. This is the issue both Democrats and Republicans should consider before they decide to kill Health Care Reform and bury it for another century.

Advertisement
recommend Sign In or Join to post comments
1
Bob Krynstrnovich

You write a very compassionate piece. However, you just don't get it. There is no 'health care' crisis here in America. Anyone can get treated. There are many ways the incumbent politicians could solve what they have touted as a crisis. But their goal is not about health care, it's about power and control. Please do not compare our system with yours or any smaller country in the world. What works for them does not mean it works for us.

1
elvisjj

Right I get you Bob. As I put it, this is about opinion it's also about the hundred of thousands of Americans who don't have health care or proper health care including a friend of mine in Arizona and friends in Los Angeles cause it's expensive to have an HMO and depending on what illness you have they can just easily turn you down. It's like getting car insurance or life insurance if it's not in their favor to insure you, they won't. I was turned down for life insurance right here in Canada for a pre-med condition which is completely under control but that doesn't matter to them. Cause there not taking even the slightest chance on me just because they think I might be more of risk of dying and they can't make their money off me. But if I was perfectly healthy like I was before I'd have no problem getting life insurance. Same with medical insurance. Your system needs change if you want to believe that it doesn't your free to do so. But I don't want to see the people I care for in the U.S. and I have lots of friends there suffer or die because they don't have adequate health insurance that's why I wrote this article and that's why this subject is so personal too me.

0
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

Elvis I agree with your overall premise that every human needs the dignity of adequate health care.  I have written several articles here with regard to the myth and misinformation published about the Canadian Health Care system. 

Having said that, the Health Care Reform bill in front of Congress right now has been so bastardized that, in fact, it changes little from what is the practice now.  Medicare which is coverage for Seniors is being reduced and medicaid still exists.

From my research it has become apparent to me that Medicaid, intended for Americans below the poverty line, will still exist, while those working poor will still be in the same boat.  I think this is the reason the Health Care Reform Bill is being rejected by a majority of Americans.

At the outset there was a lack of leadership on this bill and I believe that the only solution to solve the 21 Million uninsured crisis would have been a public option.

President let Congress set the agenda, where I think he should have been out front and explain what his health care reform should contain at a minium and sold it to the public before Congress even wrote the bill.

Americans are sick of back room deals and business as usual in Washington.  I think that was the real reason for yesterday's defeat of the Coakley in MA.  It should also be noted that MA has a universal health care plan that works well for them.

At issue here were the special 60 Billion deal reached with the unions not to tax their cadillac health plans, while taxing the remainder of Americans.  The special Medicaid provision for Nebraska, the LA purchase of 300 Million and other special interest provisions.

The Health Care Reform bill in its present form will not do much for Americans that is not happening now. 

I think you wrote a compassionate article and your basic premise is correct, but the US needs real Health Care Reform, not a bill at any price.


0
Hugh Askew

Most of us opposed to "health care" actually like health care.

What we don't like is government control &/or being taxed to death.

Simple stuff, if you pay attention.


1
nanute

What we don't like is government control &/or being taxed to death. So, the argument is what? We much prefer being told by crony capitalists from the health insurance lobby that we are much better off if they rip us off, and provide lousy coverage, and decide what is and is not medically necessary? And at the end of it all, they'll get to decide if we have to go bankrupt when the money runs out and we are no longer a viably profitable commodity.

If the Democrats learned anything from the election of Scott Brown in Mass., (and I seriously doubt they'll get the message), the health care bill should start over and include the public option, an opt out provision (that way you can convince your State to not let the gov't. tax you to death), expanded Medicare to anyone over age 50, and  allow the importation of drugs from outside the US.

The health care, hospital, pharmaceutical and US Chamber of Commerce lobbyists, will all come out against this type of coverage, which will be a pretty good indication that it is most likely a good deal for the currently insured and the uninsured.

1
pavery007

Right you are!  Us Americans have confused and commingled two concepts we derived from the early colonial history which has become our myopic legacy.  "We the people" and "Taxation without representation".  Our fear, as you precisely noted, has root in opposing anything originating from OUR government because we have this warped notion that "we the people" are better off without the intervention of the "government" (read the British monarchy) because of their unfair and heavy burden of taxation... and so the legacy continues... in our minds its simple "government. - bad" "taxes. - bad" "survival. - everyone on their own".  Which bring me to another philosophical legacy of this country "United we stand, Divided we fall".  Well, my Canadian friend (God bless Canada) we have have become a nation of "Divided we stand, United we fall"Health Care Reform in this country is a third rail because we simply do not have a national conscience, a divided nation we are. On one side we have the lobbyist, rich, industrialist, bankers,uneducated and on the other we have the poor, the jobless, the educated and the advocates.  Pretty much like the early revolutionary period!!Thanks for your comments and honest approach to this subject.  We are so f**ked up in this country.

0
elvisjj

Hi Pavery007,

Nice comments they truly are and your words are so right. I mean I've been spending time in the United States for a very long time as I have lots of friends in Los Angeles and friends in Chicago and friends in Arizona so to me it is personal in a sense that my friends have the same quality health care as I do and don't have to suffer if there sick cause they can't afford to go to the hospital or a doctor. So that's one of the reasons I wrote it.

And government runned health care isn't that bad. Not great, but better then the alternative of having no health care. In Canada we pay higher taxes but we have universal health care for everyone if we get sick we don't get a bill no matter what the illness might be or how ever long you have to be in the hospital there's no bill at all. And your taken care of pretty well and decently. Americans should look into that and not be afraid of government health care and what I have always suggested is that there should be too systems.

One a government health care for those who want it and a private health care for those who prefer that. But health care should be made available to all Americans citizens regardless of who you are.

 

0
wenews

Yeah, I think part of the problem as touched on here is that we Americans associate, and its only natural, higher taxes with less monthly take-home pay, less for providing for our families and so on. And that would be true, if we didn't factor in the $1,000 month or more that most families spend on health insurance, not to mention health care itself. Once that is factored in and subtracted out in a universal health-care country, I'd venture to guess most of us would have as much or more take-home each month, and would live in a society where no one is left out.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Amy Judd
First Flagged at 9:02 PM, Jan 20, 2010 by Amy Judd

Related Stories

Recommendations (46)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from