NP Rank:
"No table scraps" for dogs is a myth!
A couple of days ago, while I was upstairs on the computer, my 50 lbs. pitbull decided to eat the rest of my chicken that was left on the counter, bones and all. As I began to freak out, I frantically searched the internet for answers. Was my dog going to be OK? Would she get sick? The questions began to eat up at me. Well it turns out she would be fine (I had to feed her a bunch of white bread to “soften up” what was in her belly) but it also raised a very interesting question I have been wondering about for years. Why can’t dogs eat table scraps, or “regular food”? Didn’t they used to eat meat and bones (or whatever was around) before they were domesticated? Is feeding them “real food” really that bad? Dog food as we know it wasn’t even created until the early 1900’s, so what did they eat before that?
MEAT, MEAT, AND MORE MEAT
I decided to do some research. It turns out that ever since dogs have been domesticated, dogs have gradually turned away from the strictly carnivorous diet of their wild ancestors and adopted the diet provided by humans. Dogs' environments and their diets have differed through the years according to the day and age and to the uses to which the dogs were put. It turns out that the first documented domesticated dog was in 14,000 BC!
Until the 19th century, hunting dogs were often fed essentially on bread made with various grains (barley, wheat or rye); meat (offal) was fed only rarely, when the quarry was given to the hounds or on a temporary basis to strengthen "weak" dogs.
Meat was long considered to be an "optional" part of the canine diet, with some exceptions (coursing dogs hunting large game and war dogs were readily given meat, which was said to give them strength; sled dogs were traditionally fed seal meat, walrus meat or pemmican). However, we can guess that the fairly independent lifestyle of dogs in rural environments allowed them to supplement their daily ration of moistened bread with various other sorts of meat. As the human standard of living rose, meat was more frequently included in dogs' diets, replacing bread and grains (much as people switched from "earning their bread" to "bringing home the bacon"). By the 19th century, meat had become the symbol of high living and was thought to be a nutritional cure-all for dogs, which people had re-defined as strict carnivores.
OUR VIEWS BEGIN TO CHANGE
The change in attitudes occurred in the context of a large shift in the dog's status at this time. Departing from their exclusively functional role (hunting, guarding, defense), dogs assumed a more social, even sociological, role as they became incorporated into the family, which no longer considered them as utilitarian objects but as living beings worthy of love and respect. It was at this very time that we began to feed dogs “commercial food” other than meat.
MY FINAL THOUGHTS
If dogs did not begin to each “dog food” until about 100 years ago, and ate pretty much whatever was out there for thousands of years before that, isn’t it OK for dogs to eat meat? Don’t you think the old Veterinarian saying “don’t feed your dog table scraps” doesn’t make sense and may somehow be driven by large dog food corporations? I definitely do.
For other articles, visit here
Crowd Power
Recommendations (7)

Anonymous users (3)



Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (9)
at 12:17 on July 19th, 2007
What does a 50lb pit bull eat? Whatever she wants!
at 20:00 on July 19th, 2007
I once drove past a dog that was eating out of a dead deer on the road like a pig at a trough. And it was in the dead heat of summer here in the South. Though the deer looked pretty "ripe," I doubt the dog had even a trace of indigestion.
So, I suppose the effect of the scraps you feed your dog depends on the quality of the scraps. Feed a dog nothing but fat, and it will put on weight. I've been tempted to take my own beagle off canned food after the Chinese ingredients scare -- but I'm still undecided. Add a couple of pro and con medical summaries and help me to decide.
at 03:42 on July 20th, 2007
Donofat, your argument makes sense, but you have to consider what those table scraps are made out of -- are we talking meat and vegetables or Cheetos and gummi bears?
- Sign In or Join to post comments
Donofatat 09:18 on July 20th, 2007
Obviously I wasn't talking about cheetos and gummi bears. I don't like to feed myself that stuff. I was referring more to meat. I also just posted a pic of my pitbull. Check it out above.
at 15:43 on July 20th, 2007
He doesn't look like the cheetos and gummi bear type. My beagle, on the other hand, is fond of those greasy soup noodles you get in Chinese takeout. Now THOSE are table scraps! You can actually light those fried noodles and burn them like tapers.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
geckogranny (not verified)at 13:42 on February 4th, 2009
We have a new 1 year old Shi-tzu. Does nearly everyone feed their dogs a few table scraps along with regular dog food? This little guy hangs around the kitchen and pantry sniffing. I made some gravy (with beef seasoning) this morning and poured some over his dry food which he previously would turn away from. He eventually ate the whole thing.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
kittiecrazie (not verified)at 17:23 on March 29th, 2009
Donofat,
I hate to tell ya but your dog is overweight. Probably from feeding him "table scraps". It takes many, many years of research and knowledge to prepare a correct diet for our DOMESTICATED dogs and cats. Yeah, they used to be "wild" and eat meat and such. That was BEFORE humans decided to domesticate them and change their daily needs! I am a vet tech, have been for a really long time. I have seen so many dogs/cats die from eating what they shouldn't. Rather it be from pancreatitis or getting a chicken bone lodged in their stomachs, getting blocked (not able to pass the chicken bone), and then the owner not having enough money to pay for the surgery to save their dogs life. If you love you pet as much as you say you do, feed him/her a good balanced diet. No, this does not include storebrand kibble either people!
- Sign In or Join to post comments
mikeshinn (not verified)at 13:16 on April 8th, 2009
hey donofat what you are saying is like meat and carrots,corn from are table is a fair diet for are dogs
- Sign In or Join to post comments
lofto (not verified)at 19:54 on June 29th, 2009
hey donofat, what you are saying is that because they did it a certain way a long time ago it must still be acceptable today? I'm afraid that your logic is a bit off. You see if you had provided some kind of statistic as to the average life expectancy of a dog back then and compared it to the A.L.E of a dog nowadays your entire argument might vary well have been disproved. Also, a dog back in the days was a disposable animal. Used and then thrown away. with not much thought as to its future. While I understand what you are getting at the fact is that we have developed an entirely new way to sustain our dogs and now that we know the effects of table scraps can effectively say that the dog is better off without it.