It's Time To Choose America

by moonwolf | October 25, 2007 at 03:41 pm | 516 views | 6 comments

This is the sanest, briefest, clearest, and shortest political editorial I have yet to read describing America's current quandry and suggesting a simple clear path for the USA to extricate herself from the incredibly expensive and intrusive global empire she has created, and move into a responsible prosperous future.

Most politicians, when they talk about reducing spending, chatter on about cutting waste and fraud. That's OK, but it's a mere nick on the federal budget. If you really want to reduce spending, you must dismantle the overseas empire.

Excluding Iraq, Afghanistan and the other facilities in the Gulf states that have been built since the Republican war, the Pentagon lists 702 overseas bases in 130 foreign countries on which are stationed more than 250,000 uniformed troops. There are also dependents and civilian employees on many of those bases.

One of the oldest military clichés is that the generals always want to fight the last war over again. Well, there's some truth to that. In fact, though, we will never again fight World War II, so why in the heck do we have bases still in Germany, Italy, Japan, Guam and South Korea?

Just whom do we expect to fight from these bases? How do they contribute to the defense of the U.S.? They don't. They are, frankly, a residue of World War II and a reminder that the military is, after all, a bureaucracy and hates the very idea of "losing" any facilities and billets. We don't need to have troops permanently stationed in any of these countries. Nor do we need to maintain our membership in the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, which is a residue from the Cold War.

I don't wish to disillusion anyone, but Asia and Europe are not our responsibilities. If there is any need for defense, it is the responsibility of the countries on those continents. We know from personal experience that Japan and Germany can field large and competent armies if they should decide they need them. They do not need our protection.

At the present, there are only two countries in the world that have the capability of waging war against us. Those are China and Russia. In both cases, the war would be fought with intercontinental ballistic missiles. We are never going to see a land war with either of those countries. It should be the No. 1 priority of our foreign-policy establishment to see that we never have a war at all with either of these countries.

Wars start when empires wish to expand. That was the cause of the Spanish-American War, World War I and World War II. The Korean and Vietnam wars were civil wars in which our politicians involved us. The wars against Afghanistan and Iraq are again wars of an empire trying to expand. In these cases, we are the empire, and you might as well face the ugly truth that our invasions of both countries were no different from the Nazi invasions that led to World War II. Neither Afghanistan nor Iraq had attacked us or were even capable of attacking us.

In Afghanistan, we could have gone after al-Qaeda without overthrowing the Taliban government. In the case of Iraq, like Adolf Hitler did with Poland, we simply published a pack of lies to justify our invasion.

Americans need to realize that we are not the police force of the world. It is not our responsibility to overthrow dictators or effect regime change in other people's countries. It is not our responsibility to stop slaughters such as seem to be a permanent feature of Africa.

If we could only learn to mind our own business and see to the needs of our own people, we could lead a peaceful, prosperous and happy existence. As for the terrorists, they are mainly a problem for intelligence and police. If any military force is necessary, one company of Rangers or Marines would be enough.

You can't have a free republic and an empire. It is time to choose.

Add a comment Comments (6)

Barry Artiste
good stuff:

moonwolf, Good stuff.

Holy Crap MW , 702 overseas bases? Damn, even I didn't think to check that out and me a world authourity on postal rates.  Granted my friend what a friggin waste of money and resources, no wonder our dollar is up.  That's unbelievable,  you would think taxpayers would be outraged, I know I would be.  Thank god Canada keep mainly in Canada, the last overseas Canadian bases to close overseas were Lahr and Soest in the mid 70's, the British and Belgian Army took it over. Now the cold war is over, guess they should go back to Germany. I put it this way, if countries overseas want  US bases on their soil they should pay the US to maintain them.

Good story Moonwolf 

moonwolf

Thanks Barry.

I actually think there are two reasons they don't "ask them to go".

They are frightened of the American response should they make that request, and the money the US taxpayers pour into the host country is a gravy train that is just too hard to give up.  Too bad US citizen's kids and their kid's kids ad infinitum will be paying for it! 

Interestingly that number will drop to 701 shortly as Ecuador refuses to renew the USA's lease to the only US military base in South America.

Presidenté Rafael Correa of that country said that he would gladly renew the US lease for its base if Ecuador could have a military base in Florida.  Good point!

juan114

Why so worried about America? Don't worry, we are the most vigorous economy in the world. We waste money because we we produce wealth and spend lots of it. We donate 10 times the money of any other country in the world. We are not a country of atheists. We are a country of faith. In less than 300 years we have achieved the greatest wealth and progress of any civilization EVER>...Some who have been here tens of thousands of years,,, Americas Quandry? prosperous future?

Barry Artiste

Hey Juan,. I am in no way saying America is in a quandary, what I am saying is holy tap dancin christ, that's a whackload of money spent on overseas bases.  Imagine the savings the US taxpayer could realise? Hell you could even afford free healthcare like here in Canada with the money spent on overseas bases, with a little left over to brew a decent 12% alcohol beer in quart bottles, like we have in Quebec called Brador Beer, you drink four of those, and you can take a trip without ever leaving the comfort of your car.

juan114

Barry I agree with you. I was commenting on the little opinion at the top of the article. We have defended the world since ww2 and all we get is crap from countries who take America for granted. You see how many think WE are the evil in the world. but without us they would be freaking out asking the US to fight the battle.

Barry Artiste

HAHAHA Friggin Hilarious MW, Ecuador certainly has a great sense of humour.  True as you say as well MW, it can be an economic boon to countries which have US military bases. In Canada as in the US, our Military bases (Except air forces bases) due to real estate costs are normally in small towns, for without our bases, they would be hard pressed economically to survive, but then the Military personnel need the town just as much, though bases are normally self sufficient anyway.

Sometimes the younger twenty something troopers just need to get off bases, away from prying eyes, cause the available civilian men and ladies on the bases may be married or worse  belong to a higher ranking  parent.

Add a comment

October 25, 2007 at 03:41 pm by moonwolf, 516 views, 6 comments

Crowd Power

Barry Artiste
First Flagged at 10:14 PM, Oct 25, 2007 by Barry Artiste
These members have powered this story:
 

is reporting from

closeSign in to NowPublic