Fisk launches attack on ‘third rate journalism’

by MexicoReporter | November 23, 2007 at 07:30 am
2115 views | 20 Recommendations | 4 comments

Videos

Loading videos...

Photos

Robert Fisk

Robert Fisk

see larger image

uploaded by leeno

Journalists have got to stop ‘kow towing’ down to those in power if
they are to do their job, according to veteran British war
correspondent Robert Fisk.


Fisk launches attack on ‘third rate journalism’

November 23, 2007 · No Comments

Journalists have got to stop ‘kow towing’ down to those in power if they are to do their job, according to veteran British war correspondent Robert Fisk.

Speaking at a meeting of the Frontline Club in New York this week - watch the film here - Fisk launched a scathing attack on what he called third rate journalism, saying: “As long as journalists kow tow to power and sucks at the hind tit of power, wants to be close to power because it wants access, American official sources say, official sources say…as long as it does that your newspapers won’t be read and it doesn’t deserve to be read.”

Fisk, who is the Middle East correspondent for British newspaper the Independent and writes prolifically on politics in the region, picked up a copy of the LATimes and rallied against an article in the newspaper which used ‘several US official sources’ said as source repeatedly.

“As long as this is your journalism….you should not trust your journalists and you shouldn’t,” he said.

Fisk said: “It was that very fine Israeli journalist Amira Hass who made the point to me three years ago, our job is to monitor the centres of power, to challenge power, all the time whatever the cost even if they hate us for it. If we don’t do that our countries will go to war and they’ll lie to you about why they’re going to war as they did to you in this country and as Mr. Blair did to me in my country.

“Because we didn’t do our bloody job.”

Advertisement
recommend Sign In or Join to post comments
Rob Walker
Rob Walker
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 07:39 on November 23rd, 2007

Here here.

As the noted washington correspondent Martha Thomas said in her book: There is a distint lack of courage in journalism today.

Jordan Yerman
Jordan Yerman
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 07:51 on November 23rd, 2007

It's a sad state of affairs. One factor, I suspect, is that the quest for ratings led news outlets to think that they'd draw more readers/viewers by acting as parrots rather than as interlocutors.

0
Rob Walker

Yes, the quest to sell papers overcame the quest to sell news. There's a subtle but all important difference there.

0
MexicoReporter

But the struggle between commerical and editorial forces has existed right from the word go, and exists today. I run my website - mexicoreporter.com - and I get decent traffic but I don't manage to sell all fo the stories I do, although I have managed to sell alot since getting out here. The problem is the pull between the media machine and editorial and what is covers. Do we give people what they want, or tell them what we witness? And are they interested in what we witness?

What Fisk's criticism doesn't address is the fact that if we don't worry about pissing off the powers that be, very often they cut off sources of information. That's not so bad if you're as successful as he is, but here in Mexico writing critically can cost you your life, not just your job.

 

 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from