Russian TV's polar ploy James Cameron "Titanic" Finnish teen exposes the fraud

by merrie | August 19, 2007 at 04:06 am
1364 views | 5 Recommendations | 7 comments

Photos

Finnish teen sinks Russian TV's polar ploy James Cameron Titanic

Finnish teen sinks Russian TV's polar ploy James Cameron Titanic

see larger image

uploaded by merrie

UNEARTHLY blue lights played across the ocean floor four kilometres below the North Pole as the heroic Russian explorers descended in mini-submarines to plant a metre-high flag.

That's what the Russian state television company, Rossiya, wanted us to believe. The truth was rather different.

In an apparent attempt to "sex up" a news program, the TV station has been caught passing off footage from the 1997 Hollywood blockbuster Titanic as a real-life report on the Kremlin's recent attempt to stake its claim to the riches of the Arctic Ocean.

Rossiya's images were distributed around the world, appearing on television news, websites and as "screen grabs" in newspapers.

It took an alert teenager in Finland with a Titanic DVD to spot the sham. Waltteri Seretin, 13, recognised the images in the national daily, Ilta-Sanomat.

"I was looking at the photo of the Russian sub expedition and I noticed immediately that there was something familiar about the picture," he told the paper.

"I checked it with my DVD and there it was, right there in the beginning of the movie; exactly the same image of the submersibles approaching the ship."

James Cameron's film about the 1912 disaster opens with a scene of mini-subs diving to inspect the wreck of the Titanic. In the Russian report, expedition images from the movie were inserted into real footage and bore an on-screen caption reading "northern Arctic Ocean".

As the Titanic images were shown, a correspondent said: "When the mini-submarine got to 300 metres, the unloading of the second sub began."

In fact, a Finnish company made the mini-subs the Russians used and Cameron used them in his film. But it is thought the scene from the movie shown on Russian TV was originally filmed using models in a studio.

Rossiya is one of two state-controlled channels that have been turned into propaganda tools under President Vladimir Putin and it is the second time in two weeks that the Vesti news program has faked a broadcast.

Ten days ago, it mocked up a copy of The Times newspaper to make it appear as though the paper had run a critical article about London-based businessman Boris Berezovsky on its front page. The article actually appeared in the comment section.

Rossiya refused to comment on the polar footage, but the boy who identified it gave a damning indictment of the show. "I have heard that they don't always tell the truth in Russia but I didn't think they could have screwed it up that badly," he said.

Moscow trumpeted the polar expedition as a PR coup in its effort to prove the Arctic is Russian, and veteran explorer Artur Chilingarov and his team returned to a heroes' welcome.

The TV fiasco adds fresh controversy to the expedition, which caused resentment among northern hemisphere nations seeking their share of the Arctic's energy riches - at least 10 billion tonnes of hydrocarbons.

Alexei Simonov, of the Glasnost Defence Foundation, said the channel had attempted to dupe viewers. "This is a sign of the sheer unprofessionalism that reigns when television is turned into a pawn of the authorities," he said

recommend This comment thread is now closed
SthPacific
SthPacific
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 06:28 on August 19th, 2007

merrie, I like this story. It's good stuff. I am surprised that the Finns would really care about
this after the Russian Kicked out the US bidders from the Barents Sea
gas deal and gave it to Finnland under the pretence of "America's poor
enviornmental record". The Russian first claimed this Area under Peter
the Great in 1733-42 ?  and settled any disputes over this territory 75
years ago. No North American country will get a look at any contract in
the Arctic for two main reasons. 1 No north American company has the
technology to exploity the resources. 2 Russia has recently kicked out
all western Energy interests from Russia, they dominate the worlds
energy reserves, so why would they hand them back to some greedy
corrupt Oil Barrons from Texas. Royal Dutch Shell has admitted that
there is no surplus supply and that there will not ever be again, so
why would the Canadians want to fight the Russians for the Scraps of
the Hydro-Carbon reserves. They should be investing in alternatives,
and if there are no alternatives, then they will just have to make do
with what they have. They could start with cutting off the Gas they
virtually give to the USA and keeping it for themselves and future
generations of Canadians, The Americans use Far to much energy and need
to be stopped by absolutly any means, even if it means doing them great
harm. Why should Canadians freeze so US cits can drive Humvee's ??

0
Jordan Yerman

This is a brilliant find, merrie. Still, I'd like to hear more from you personally: what made you post this? Do you have anything more to add to it in terms of commentary/additional coverage/Titanic trivia?

0
merrie

 

Hi Jordan,

I thought it enlightening just how much of American history is finally coming out through media, so when I read Cliff Kincaids rebut of Russia's claim to the North Pole, I shows how much erroneous information we've been bombarded with from the MSM!

The mini-subs in the movie "Titanic" were actually Finnish: 

But it has now emerged that the footage actually showed two
Finnish-made Mir submersibles that were employed on location filming at
the scene of the wreck of the RMS Titanic ship in the north Atlantic
some 10 years ago.  

http://www.rathergate.com/?p=3230  h/t  rathergate.com

The North Pole is Ours, Not Russia's

While the Russians are claiming to have traveled to the Arctic Ocean
floor at the North Pole in a submarine and planted their flag on August
2, the Nautilus reached the geographic North Pole almost 50 years ago.
A second submarine, the Skate, actually surfaced at the Pole.

Before the Nautilus, of course, two American explorers, Dr.
Frederick Cook and Robert E. Peary, a U.S. Navy commander, led missions
that reportedly reached the Pole in 1908 and 1909. On the Peary
mission, it was his aide, Matthew Henson, a black explorer, who planted
the American flag in the ice. A website in his honor refers to him as the co-discoverer of the North Pole and a U.S. postage stamp recognized their achievement.

Henson’s important role
in this mission was recognized by President Reagan, who granted a
petition to move Henson’s remains to Arlington National Cemetery near
Washington, D.C. In 1996, a Navy ship, the USNS Henson, was named for
him and he remains a role model for and hero to African-American young people.

http://www.aim.org/special_report/5658_0_8_0_C/   h/t aim.org

Matthew A Henson Co-Discoverer of North Pole Peary April 6, 1909

Aviaq Henson is studying
to be a teacher.
She lives with her family in Nuuk, Greenland.


Aviaq is traveling to Qaanaaq in north
western Greenland. This is the area
where Henson & Peary collected men &
supplies for their expeditions 100 years
ago. Your class can
send

email or even mail letters to Aviaq
Henson.

http://www.matthewhenson.com/

Cliff Kincaid of Accuracy in Media (aim.org) has been an astute observer, along with Judicial Watch, as watchdog organizations, to probe truthful media reporting.

I hope the links provide the missing information regarding the silly Russian Arctic claim.

Regards,

merrie 

 

  

0
SthPacific

@ merrie Sadly , and I wish they did, But no they dont. The area claimed by Russia is under all laws I know of since the signing of the Magna Carta, Russian. If the Australian Government can claim vast tracts of the Sea floor Like the Nth West Shelf, The Timor Sea and the Huge areas Around Antarctica, then Russia has a legitimate claim to this Spit of land that is in contention, and it is this undersea ridge that is in Question and where most of the Oil and Gas is.

The USA and Canada have no such Geographical links to this part of the Arctic and Therefore no claim. Planting a Flag on the Ice Cap is not recognised as it is  constantly moving. So the teritory can not be mapped. 

0
ScienceDave

This on YouTube, a comparison between the images and the movie:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jn-3owpFb5I

0
merrie

Hi nouseforadave,

Great video, it shows the exact same film, which there is no plausible deniability as to the source. Kudos for

that!!! The still photo really doesn't show that the images were stolen!

Thanks,

merrie

P.S. I'm curious as to what the Russians explanation for their silly hoax is. 

 

0
merrie

 

Glory & Honor

More on Mathew Henson's and Robert Peary's 1909 exploration of the North Pole

1998 movie "Glory & Honor"

This film pays tribute to Mathew Henson which is at last recognized along
with Robert Peary as the first two explorers to reach North Pole. Henson's
contribution was recognized in 1988 by the National Geographic Society. His
skin color (black), prevented his name to appear side-by-side to Peary's
for
a long time

merrie 

 

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

SthPacific
First Flagged at 6:28 AM, Aug 19, 2007 by SthPacific
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in World

Recommendations (5)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from