Steer euthanized after Calgary Stampede Rodeo

by Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke | July 10, 2009 at 03:51 am
491 views | 60 Recommendations | 16 comments

Photos

Another animal has died at the Calgary Stampede. A steer was used for the Steer Wrestling Competition and apparently suffered soft tissue injuries.

The animal was sedated and later euthanized.  This is the second animal since the start of the competition on July 3rd.  Earlier this week a horse suffered a heart attack after competing in a Chuckwagon Race.

Steer Wrestling is a competition, where the steer is released from a chute to run down the arena.  A cowboy on horseback chases it, slides off his horse when he is alongside the steer and wrestles it to the ground.

In most cases this event is more dangerous to the cowboy than it is for the steer.  Animals seldom get hurt during this competition.

The Calgary Stampede and specifically Rodeo have been under attack by animal rights advocates.  This will not help rodeo's case.

Another animal has died at the Calgary Stampede.

A steer suffered a soft tissue injury during the steer wrestling event and was euthanized.

The steer was sedated and given medication to reduce swelling, but was later euthanized.

It happened during Thursday's steer wrestling competition.

Cowboy Joey Bell Jr. from Athens, Texas took the steer down, but as the crowd looked on in horror, it did not get up.

The steer was then taken out on a stretcher and moved to a covered area for treatment.

recommend This comment thread is now closed
1
Luciano Galasso

I think the idea of the rodeo is a great and fun idea and an amazing Calgary tradition. I just wish there was some way we could avoid hurting the animals. The problem with large animals like horses and steer are that they cannot survive if damage is done to one of their legs because they would not be able to get around. I remember watching a horse race recently where the winning horse had broken its leg nearing the end of the race and was euthanized right there on the spot. Terribly sad.

-- Luciano Galasso

1
Amy Judd

This is exactly why I don't agree with rodeos, I know they are not all like this and I'm not sure what fate would befall the animal otherwise, but I will never attend one of these events for due to stories like this one here.

0
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

Thanks for this Luciano.  I agree.  It is not clear what happened to the steer.  I suspect it was a broken neck because of the way they are taken down in steer wrestling.

1
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

Thank you for the recommendation Amy. I respect your opinion on this. Although I have attended rodeos in the past and have seen them as fun events, I am also having second thoughts. Any event that animals are being used in, including horse racing, carry a certain amount of risk. I also see a lot of abuse in the cattle industry, with the SPCA being totally helpless.

2
pinktadpoles

It saddens me greatly to read this sort of news. I have never been witness to such but can only imagine. Many may not agree with me but possibly it happened for a greater purpose. Animals, all animals were given to man as a resource. And while we have dominion over them it is foolish to think we will always have this resource. How dare people take animals for such fun, sorry, "sport". Hopefully one day SPCA and other organizations will be able to change this.

0
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

Thank you for your comments pinktadpoles. 

1
Barbara McPherson

I worry more about the horses used in the chuckwagon races as they are thoroughbreds that can't make it on the track.  In the past these horses were basically 'throwaways' and many suffered horrendous injuries, but from what I understand, they are now much more valued and looked after better.  One of the really great things about the rodeo is that it focusses attention on the plight of animals in general.  So many people indulge in eating meat, eggs, dairy and putting steer manure on their 'green' gardens and never think about the source.  It's unfortunate that a steer had to be put down, but compared to the thousands put down in the meat industry it's insignificant.

0
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

Thank  you for this Barbara:)

0
Edmund Jenks


1
Roy C

Unfortunately, we don't really know what the animal feels.

Steers were destined for slaughter by predators on the wide open grassy plains where they lived.

Surely, compared to being choked to death by lions or ripped to shreds by hyenas, some steer wrestling is almost a walk in the park for them.


0
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

Thanks for this Roy. 

1
ILOVEBEEF

Err.. any of you have leather shoes or have the occasional burger?? I agree, it's too bad what happened to the steer. But please, let's put it into context!! Go visit your local meat processing plant kill floor and you'll know what I mean.


0
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

thank you ILOVEBEEF.

1
J. J.

Growing up in Calgary I attended rodeo events at the Stampede and in surrounding areas. We almost always had seats in the infield and I can tell you it's a great place to see what really happens - the tail twisting, face punches, kicks, etc. Now, if you've got good eyes, you'll spot the electronic devices. The infield is not a place for the squeamish. You'l be treated to the sound of bones crunching and the sight of blood. The truly appalling thing is the cheers and happy faces of onlookers when these things happen. Years ago the Stampede also had horse racing between rodeo events and I remember watching as a  beatiful thoroughbred was driven right through the rail. There it stood screaming in pain, impaled through the chest by the broken rail, hanging half up, half down. People in charge of "taking care of the animals" kicked at it repeatedly in an attempt to get it off the jagged spike. When it was eventually dragged out of sight it was still kicking and screaming in pain. It's a sound I shall never forget. That same day two calves, a steer, and a chuckwagon horse lost their lives. These things still happen; we just don't hear the gunshot anymore as we used to at the smaller rodeos. The people involved in rodeo need to stop saying that injuries happen more often to the cowboys. Then maybe, just maybe, they might gain back a little of my respect. But never another dollar of mine. I will continue to encourage all relatives, friends, and friends of friends to avoid the Stampede and Calgary in general. 

1
Amy Judd

Oh my gosh, this is awful, I am shocked from reading this account, especially of the horse, so sad..

0
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

Thanks for this JJ. 

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

thomps
First Flagged at 4:47 AM, Jul 10, 2009 by thomps
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (60)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from