NP Rank:
EU rules ban sale of 'too small' kiwis
In a ridiculous story which comes at a time when everyone is feeling the pinch of rising food costs, a wholesaler in the UK has been banned from selling a consignment of kiwi fruits because EU laws have declared that they are 'too small'.
Tim Down, a market trader for 25 years, said he was not permitted even to give away the 5,000 Chilean fruits, each of which is about the size of a small hen's egg and weighs about 60g.
Mr Down said his family run firm would lose several hundred pounds in sales because of the ban.
"It is bureaucratic nonsense, they are perfectly fit to eat," Mr Down said at his stall at the Wholesale Fruit Centre in Bristol.
Inspectors from the Rural Payments Agency, an executive agency of the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra), made a random check on his stall, and found a number of his kiwis weighed 58g, four grams below the required minimum of 62g.
Mr Down said that 4g in weight was the equivalent of about one millimeter in diameter.
He said: "They (the inspectors) went through a lot of my stock using their own little scales.
"These regulations are enforced in the United Kingdom with a higher level of rigour than is applied in mainland Europe. There is not a level playing field.
He couldn't even give them away and faced a fine if he did.
Mr Down said he was not permitted by law to give away the kiwis to a school or hostel and faced a fine of several thousand pounds if he did.
Barry Stedman, head of the Rural Payments Agency's inspectorate, said the consignment had failed to meet the minimum standards for saleable produce, in contravention of EU grading rules.
"The inspector's decision is consistent with RPA's commitment to protect consumers, who must feel confident that the produce they are buying is of the right quality," he said.
"RPA's role is to work with traders to provide advice and assistance to ensure that this happens and to help traders carry out their business within the law."
Apparently he was given the option to sell them back to the importer, but it is not understood why he declined to do that.
Crowd Power
-
josette8myrick
Albuquerque, New Mexico, United States -
naliha
Germany -
curious_jane
Philippines -
jasminlee
Singapore -
ovendelon
Bulgaria -
filli38
Miami, Florida, United States











Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (2)
at 15:37 on June 28th, 2008
amyjudd, I like this story. It's good stuff. That behavior is so stupid and shortsighted! To waste perfectly good food when it could be given away is -- I don't have the words. A homeless person's shelter is unlikely to be in the market for 62 g kiwis.
at 19:00 on June 28th, 2008
amyjudd, I like this story. It's the same old story o the EU commissioners (or is it the parliament - I'm never sure which) making these rules. Bananas too have to be a certain length even though many naturally grown bananas are much smaller and tastier! The same goes for cucumbers I think. The EU thinks that good government is about adding rules hither and thither!
Gerry