NP Rank:
Food Scam - 25% of fish labelled incorrectly
This is a very high percentage that can't be explained by random error. Looks like inspectors are not doing a very good job. I can see how restaurants can get away with it but supermarkets? That really surprises me.
Study: 25% of fish samples labelled incorrectly
By THE CANADIAN PRESS
GUELPH, Ont. - A team of New York City high school students and researchers at the University of Guelph have teamed up to determine that fish sold at stores and restaurants is often mislabelled.
The students joined forces with Guelph researchers, who used their DNA testing facilities to examine 100 different samples of fish purchased at markets and restaurants in Toronto, New York and Guelph.
They found fully one-quarter of the samples had been labelled incorrectly, usually as a species that was either more expensive or otherwise more desirable.
"Many fish are hard to tell apart once they've been filleted and packaged," 17-year-old Trinity School student Louisa Strauss said in a release.
"We hope our work lights the way to getting mislabelled and endangered fish species out of grocery store refrigerators and frying pans."
The students say authorities should use DNA "bar-coding" technology to protect consumers from fraud and ensure endangered species aren't sold illegally.
Guelph researcher Robert Hanner says people with allergies to certain species could face danger if they eat mislabelled fish.
"This not only raises concerns of consumer fraud, but also public health," Hanner said in a release.
The most commonly mislabelled fish was red snapper. The study also found endangered species were labelled as fish that are considered eco-friendly.
"We are not certain where the mislabelling occurs, but it seems it is not the fishermen, since the mislabelled fish are from completely different parts of the world," Strauss and 18-year-old classmate Kate Stoeckle write in an article to be published next month in the U.S. journal Pacific Fishing.
"Perhaps the mislabelling occurs somewhere in the middle, when the fish are filleted and no longer easily identifiable."
The journal of Food Research International is scheduled to publish the Guelph findings next week.
Crowd Power
-
mcshots
el segundo, California, United States -
malyousif
Jannusan, Bahrain -
ThatClaw
Hong Kong -
lorenzodom
New York City, New York, United States -
ario_j
Redmond, Washington, United States -
Squeezyboy
Ipswich, SFK, -
denn
Hong Kong -
eileen216
Alhambra, California, United States -
Eva Marieville
San Francisco, California, United States -
squishies
Liverpool, New South Wales, Australia -
davidorban
Bergamo, Bergamo, Italy -
Sean Stayte
Haywards Heath, WSX, -
cwalker
Beijing, China -
eastvanray
vancouver, British Columbia, Canada -
rpkrajewski
Arlington, Massachusetts, United States -
nofrills
Japan -
happyrach
New Zealand -
your neighborhood librarian
Baltimore, Maryland, United States -
maistora
Reading, Berkshire, -
misterchinaski
Denver, United States -
alanaplin
Lee-on-the-Solent, Hampshire, United Kingdom -
trixiebedlam
New York, New York, United States -
vostok71
Berrien Springs, Michigan, United States -
LFL16
Fremont, California, United States -
CharleyMarley
Kona, Hawaii, United States -
amyjosmile
Indonesia -
Peggie Scott
Taiwan -
specialkrb
New York, New York, United States -
Lori Greig
Houston, Texas, United States -
pittaya
Thailand -
vapour trail
London, London, United Kingdom -
shad_41
United States -
René Seindal
Venice, Italy -
northmanimages
Finland -
juliov23
Sacramento, California, United States -
nobuojp
Japan -
jmvnoos
France -
bjorngabrielsen
Norway -
anahita avalos
Mexico -
lutrasimilis
New York, New York, United States -
eltonllin
San Jose, California, United States -
Chaiyo82
Durham, North Carolina, United States -
JR In Kingston
Canada -
The Seiuchi
Raleigh, North Carolina, United States -
teamsullyca
Stevenson Ranch, California, United States -
oakley.adam
Portland, Oregon, United States -
kristinmenzie
United States -
Banias Oubai
Syria -
amataiclaudius
Jamaica -
clairelynn
Seaford, New York, United States -
c2s993
Reston, Virginia, United States -
fishey
Japan -
Ali San
Waukee, Iowa, United States -
zari1
Brussels, Belgium -
edsel12
Newport Beach, California, United States -
rizu desu
Portland, Oregon, United States -
sarah.t.nz
New Zealand -
jenninat0r
Canada -
manray3
Orono, Maine, United States -
earlyadopter
San Jose, California, United States -
JustinGreis
Chicago, Illinois, United States -
Transiently permanent
Bouvet Island -
hlchen1220
Singapore -
astoldbymanda
Singapore -
philfromdublin
United States -
Maegan Bellino
Bristolville, Ohio, United States -
japg
Spain -
shu tu
Boston, Massachusetts, United States -
rcfgunkle
Puerto Rico -
sebmouttet
Canada -
jointcookie
Philippines -
serialc
Netherlands -
mdid
Tokyo, Japan -
Kseniya Yarosh
Brooklyn, New York, United States -
creanima
Switzerland (Confoederatio Helvetica) -
mko
Los Angeles, California, United States -
hanamai
Lutz, Florida, United States -
meanshell
Los Angeles, California, United States -
gamemaster366
Sewickley, Pennsylvania, United States -
bezelye
Turkey -
toomanypixels
Canada -
Helena Marc
Brazil -
Brookes pics
New Zealand -
jeremysimms
Japan -
Timbru
France -
carmizvi
Canada -
Tmanto
Israel -
Hamtaro
Singapore -
Marijn9
Netherlands -
ncardoso
Portugal -
hikari
Taiwan -
axiom
Toronto, Canada














Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (18)
at 14:48 on August 22nd, 2008
eastvanray, I like this story. It's good stuff. That is one butt ugly fish there Eastvan
at 15:12 on August 22nd, 2008
Thanks for the GS. Ya I wanted to find a really ugly specimin. Couldn't find the name so I will call it "uglyfish". I bet it tastes good though.
at 19:56 on August 22nd, 2008
Sounds fishy...
at 07:27 on August 25th, 2008
eastvanray, I like this story. It's good stuff. Scary stuff.
at 10:42 on August 25th, 2008
Thanks rpshen.
at 18:25 on August 25th, 2008
thank you rpshen
at 18:30 on August 25th, 2008
eastvanray, I like this story. It's good stuff.
at 18:36 on August 25th, 2008
Thanks Lori,
And for someone like me who LOVES sushi it is particularly upsetting. When I order and pay for toro I want toro damn it! And thanks to all for all the pics.
at 19:15 on August 25th, 2008
eastvanray*
wow, that really makes me think about the fish i buy! good story. and thanks for using my photo.
Maegan Bellino has contributed a photo to this story.
at 20:58 on August 25th, 2008
eastvanray, I like this story. It's good stuff.
Don't surprise me at all. Oceans, rivers, lakes are polluted !!!!
at 21:13 on August 25th, 2008
Thanks for the GS Milieunet. Polution does not really explain misrepresenting food to consumers, though. Thanks again!
at 22:29 on August 25th, 2008
A tunisian supermarket... nap time, I think.
ncardoso has contributed a photo to this story.
at 02:17 on August 26th, 2008
A typical selection in a japanese supermarket-i got chased out of the store taking these, oops!
Brookes pics has contributed a photo to this story.
at 02:34 on August 26th, 2008
This display was in a supermarket in Paris, France. It is difficult to confim the names of the items since they are labelled in French, but basic research indicates that the same seafood is sold under different names in different parts of the country.
ronaldflores has contributed a photo to this story.
at 14:33 on August 26th, 2008
This photo is part of an ongoing series looking at natural food packaged unnaturally.
jeremysimms has contributed a photo to this story.
at 21:07 on August 26th, 2008
Hello! If you could please change the credits to "Eva Richeson" instead of Eva Marieville. Thank you!
I love that you included my photo in this captivating investigation! :)
at 17:49 on August 28th, 2008
Originally published on my blog, Written Inc.:
http://writteninc.blogspot.com/
carmizvi has contributed a photo to this story.
at 16:59 on September 5th, 2008
Well, that's certainly disheartening, yet not surprising. It seems somewhere, someone is always trying to get over on someone else.
hanamai has contributed a photo to this story.