NP Rank:
Woman locked up by family for 18 years
Seems like there are more and more stories like this everyday. People being locked in the basement for some odd reason, and they are living in ridiculous conditions and often abused. When they are finally found, 20years has gone by already. Can you imagine being locked up in a basement for an extended period of time? I know I can't.
Maria Monaco spent the last 18 years of her life locked in a bare room in a sleepy southern town, fed in tin bowls and watched over by her elderly mother and siblings as she slept in a filthy bed.
Investigators and experts say the case of the woman imprisoned in her family's home in Santa Maria Capua Vetere, near Naples, is only the most recent example of a widespread stigma attached to mental and physical disability in many poor areas of Italy.
Monaco, now 47, had a history of psychiatric problems when her family decided to lock her up, allegedly because she had become pregnant out of wedlock, investigators say.
When police were brought in last week after a neighbor called to protest about the smell rising from the apartment, they found the woman in the room with a bed with soiled sheets, a filthy toilet and sink, as well as plastic bottles of water and a metal dog bowl used to feed her.
Police arrested Monaco's brother, a farmhand, and sister, who worked in a nursery school, and put her ailing, widowed, 80-year-old mother under house arrest. They are being investigated on suspicion of mistreatment and kidnapping.
Monaco's now 17-year-old son grew up with relatives and knew she was his mother, though he was told that she was too sick for visits, said prosecutor Antonio Ricci. The same was told to inquisitive neighbors or distant relatives.
The Italian media have compared Monaco's segregation to other abuse stories that have surfaced recently in Austria, including the case of Elisabeth Fritzl - who had seven children from her father and was held captive underground for 24 years in the family's home west of Vienna - and of Natascha Kampusch, the Austrian girl abducted at age 10 and held in an underground cell for eight-and-a-half years by her kidnapper.
But far from being an isolated abuse case, Monaco's fate is shared by some in rural parts of Italy, where a mix of embarrassment and ignorance pushes families to segregate relatives who have mental or physical disabilities, Ricci said.
"This is a particularly horrible case," the prosecutor said. "But this measure is often taken with the mentally ill, also because there is little access to healthcare in the most isolated areas."


Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (3)
at 13:45 on June 24th, 2008
This is terrible. You're right - how come so many stories are coming out now about people being held in dungeons or in cellars for years at a time? Seems like something happened to the world about 18 years ago and some people were locked up for it. Weird.
at 09:13 on June 26th, 2008
Good post....horrible story. I can't even comprehend what goes through these peoples' minds. Craziness
at 00:38 on July 3rd, 2008
JeffHuang, I like this story. It's good stuff.
In America, we don't have to keep our mentally ill relatives in basements or attics like this Italian family. The government here often takes care of the "problem" by locking away mentally ill citizens in prisons and jails. To date, approximately 1.25 million mentally ill citizens are serving time for crimes they either did not understand or had little self control to avoid. Many others are killed during arrest attempts by Taser guns or gunshot, and others die in Restraint Chairs subsequent to arrest. Once arrested, the mentally ill often languish behind bars for long periods without psychological evaluations or treatment.
It is too bad that Maria Monaco was treated so inhumanely by her family -- victimized and punished for being sick, just like so many mentally ill Americans.
Mary Neal
Assistance to the Incarcerated Mentally Ill
Website: http://wrongfuldeathoflarryneal.com