NP Rank:
Ben Stein Fired: Expelled From NY Times Over Conflict of Interest
Last week actor, writer and economist Ben Stein was fired from the NY Times over an alleged conflict of interest. Stein had starred in a commercial for a website offering free credit reports online, something the higher-ups at the NY Times felt was a conflict with his role as an economic columnist. Stein thinks that the claim of a conflict of interest was nothing more than an excuse to expel him from the NY Times roster.
A week after he was fired, Ben Stein posted a rebuttal to the NY Times claims that a conflict of interest lead to his dismissal. According to Stein, the conflict charges were a smoke screen and the real reasons he was ousted were much more complex.
In his post at The American Spectator, Ben Stein accuses the NY Times of firing him for being critical of US President Barack Obama. Stein suggests that while the NY Times is happy to offer politically left criticisms of the President, any critiques from the political right are not tolerated. The day before Ben Stein was fired he had written a column that was deeply critical of President Obama.
Conicidence? Maybe. But also, maybe not. Ben Stein has been in many commercials before and never once has he been cited for a conflict. However, despite his protests and in defense of the NY Times, none of his previous commercials had any conceivable conflict with his role as an economist but a free credit report commercial does tread dangerously close to that line.
In an e-mail sent to me by a person I had never met nor even heard of, I was fired. (I read the e-mail while having pizza at the Seattle airport on my way to Sandpoint.) I called the editor and explained the situation. He said the problem was "the appearance" of conflict of interest. I asked how that could be when I never wrote about the subject at all. He said the real problem was that FreeScore was a major financial company and I wrote about finance. But, as I told him, FreeScore was a small Internet aggregator, not a bank or insurer.
Never mind. I was history. "You should have consulted us," was the basic line.
Of course, there was not one word of complaint when I did commercials for immense public companies. By a total coincidence, I was tossed overboard immediately after my column attacking Obama. (You can attack Obama from the left at the Times but not from the right.)
I still do not see the conflict of interest. Credit reports on the Internet never was in my subject area. However, I don't sue newspapers. And the gig was getting to be so small that it really had a minor effect on my economic life. Still, I shall miss waking up on Sunday to see my column unless a neighbor here in Beverly Hills has stolen my paper. (No place, not one place, in Sandpoint sells the Times.)
The whole subject reminds me of a conversation Bob Dylan had long ago with a reporter who asked him what he thought about how much criticism he was getting for going from acoustic to electric guitar. "There are a lot of people who have knives and forks," he said, "and they have nothing on their plates, so they have to cut something."
I will miss writing my column for the Times but I miss many things. There were some great people there, really standup people. I got to love some of them. But as to the haters and the weak willed, I think my sister and Bob Dylan had it right.



Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (3)
at 12:35 on August 10th, 2009
I want to know what Ben's sister said! He is so cryptic - like the Bible almost.
at 12:42 on August 10th, 2009
With the economic scams and fraudulent schemes on the internet growing in number everyday, the NYT was justified in cutting a columnist who is shilling for a "free" credit report that costs $30.00 a month.
at 19:35 on August 11th, 2009
I don't blame them, I thought Ben Stein was smart enough but I guess not.